4 ms·
Disagreed about the ban. Since when is shitty technology (which any engineer worth their salt should’ve predicted - this is not rocket science) the fault of the
by Nextgrid 7y ago
Disagreed about the ban. Since when is shitty technology (which any engineer worth their salt should’ve predicted - this is not rocket science) the fault of the customer? Unless they say in bold in their marketing statements “Only drive within cell coverage” the customer isn’t at fault for trying to use it as a normal car (in fact it’s crazy to think that parking in a place with no reception is no longer normal, at least according to ZipCar).
- xzmmd 7y agoYou're justifying acting like an asshole.
- Nextgrid 7y agoNo I’m trying to justify using the product as it’s advertised. Otherwise it’s too easy to just falsely advertise something and ban the people that manage to figure out the catch.
- oh_sigh 7y agoYou said you did it a few times. How often do you have to do something with negative consequences before you learn you shouldn't keep doing it?
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoOther than being told its a signal issue, how do you determine that? IoT crap rarely, if ever, actually communicates with the user about error conditions. You usually find out shit 'no workey' after the fact. There's a lot of articles and twitter feeds. Go look up the "Internet of Shit". There's a reason why it's called that. And Zipcars are no exception, evidently.
- oh_sigh 7y agoThis isn't internet of shit though...is an iPhone shitty if you can't use cell services when you don't have cell service?
- Nextgrid 7y agoIt’s obvious that a phone won’t work without signal. It’s not (yet - and hopefully will never be) obvious that a car rental service requires cell signal to function. If this limitation can’t be worked around and they still decide to go ahead with operating the service then they should advertise this limitation prominently. Until then, the customer should be compensated (your rental car letting you stranded is definitely an issue and can cause non-negligible monetary damage to the user), not banned.
- oh_sigh 7y agoI can see maybe it not being obvious to a random member of the public. Maybe they thought their card somehow had all the data it needed. But I guess I just expected more from someone who posts on hacker news.
- mcguire 7y agoIs an iPhone shitty if you can't use it at all if you don't have cell service? Is a car shitty if it leaves you stranded due to a known issue?
- oh_sigh 7y agoIt would only leave you stranded if you lock the keys inside the car, and expect the zip card to open it back up for you. "Locking keys in car" is a well known failure mode of cars, and it is entirely OPs fault.
- stelonix 7y agoThe comment you're replying to is not the person who was banned by ZipCar, but someone else showing why the logic behind the corporativist comment is wrong.
- mcguire 7y agoAs advertised? I wonder if there's a reason why traditional rentals don't lock you out when your reservation ends.
- Shorel 7y agoI do agree it is not his fault. But the ban also prevents that particular customer from receiving bad service. Some things are not meant to be.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoZipCar should have formally requested that the customer not park cars in that lot, or what have you. Since the customer needs to use that lot, they would probably stop using ZipCar at that point—but that's better than being banned forever if their life situation changes.
- michaelt 7y agoDo you see declining to serve a customer whom you could not serve well as different to banning a customer? Because companies routinely do the former.
- lm28469 7y agoNever play the "who's dumber" game with private companies you'll always lose. If it happens twice you should switch on your common sense and stop using the service, or at the very least change your behaviour/don't be surprised if you get banned. > which any engineer worth their salt should’ve predicted - this is not rocket science There are probably tons of other issues you don't know about. Making it work offline would probably increase the attack surface, &c.
- fred_is_fred 7y agoAny engineer worth their salt knows that they have 100 things to work on and this guy's corner case didn't make the cut. Easier for them to ban him and work on a new feature that generates revenue for thousands of users.
- Nextgrid 7y agoMy point is that this isn’t some minor bug that you can leave in the backlog because it’s just a minor inconvenience. This is a major dealbreaker that should’ve been thought of when designing the service in the first place.