3 ms·
Autopilot. By design it encourages drivers to stop paying any attention - the fact that it has a “signal the driver” to try and maintain driver focus indicates
by olliej 7y ago
Autopilot. By design it encourages drivers to stop paying any attention - the fact that it has a “signal the driver” to try and maintain driver focus indicates that the core design produces this behavior.
If the core design produces the same behavior, in a large enough portion of the user base to require such a feature, that’s a fairly good indication that the core design is causing a problem.
- kazinator 7y agoEvery car has a measure of "autopilot" called "wheel alignment". The car was built before Alta Vista was eaten by Google, yet goes dead straight on the freeway while you rummage through the glove compartment for your second favorite CD. Maybe cars should have wacky alignment that pulls randomly left and right; that would teach drivers to keep their hands on the wheel and pay attention at all times.
- chrisseaton 7y agoSo are you saying Autopilot does or doesn’t allow you to disengage? Because you said it didn’t then argued it did...
- m463 7y agoYou are answering the opposite of the question. all cars allow you to stop paying attention. I think the idea behind autopilot is that it reduces your workload (like cruise control, or automatic wipers, or automatic headlights or any other labor-saving device)
- olliej 7y agoTools like autopilot encourage lack of attention. The problem isn't "you don't have pay attention to X" it is "you don't have to pay attention to anything during normal operation". It is human nature, if not outright physiology that it is incredibly difficult to keep someone engaged, and paying attention to a task that they are not actually doing. The problem with halfway solutions like autopilot isn't that they control the car some of the time, it's that they can, essentially without warning Stop controlling it. Self driving cars will happen. But the current model is essentially "do enough of the driving to maximize the likelihood that the human 'driver' is not going to pay attention, but don't do enough to make their lack of attention safe". My statement isn't "cars allow you not to pay attention", it is "systems like autopilot actively encourage a lack of attention", that's backed up by the need for alert systems when they have obvious signs that the driver isn't paying attention, like "no longer holding the wheel". If the system didn't in general usage result in lack of attention then such a system would not be necessary.