4 ms·
One factor that this article does not take into account is the signal correlation between detectors. LIGO only counts signals as a detection of an event if the
by pdonis 7y ago
One factor that this article does not take into account is the signal correlation between detectors. LIGO only counts signals as a detection of an event if the same signal appears in multiple detectors with the appropriate time delays (indicating light speed travel time in a particular direction through the Earth). The same signal in multiple detectors rules out detector errors, and the relative timing rules out terrestrial origin: no signal of terrestrial origin will travel at anywhere close to the speed of light through the Earth (earthquake waves travel orders of magnitude slower).
- comex 7y agoThen why were 9 events for which alerts were sent later “downgraded because they were identified as likely of terrestrial origin”?
- tobinfricke 7y agoIt is always possible for a random signal to appear by coincidence in several detectors simultaneously. LIGO also gathers data from a huge number of "auxiliary channels" that monitor the local environment (seismometers, microphones, radio receivers, etc). Possible detections are heavily scrutinized by ensuring that the detectors were operating normally during the time of detection, and no local disturbances are seen in the auxiliary channels.
- pdonis 7y agoBecause looking at the signal correlation is not the only test that is applied. But it is a significant test that was not discussed in Hossenfelder's article.
- throwaway2048 7y agoBecause analyzing them takes time, and they want to inform telescopes as soon as possible so optical/EM data can be captured while the event (possibly) occurs. A false positive is a lot better than a false negative here.
- tobinfricke 7y agoMoreover, it is through these time delays, and knowledge of the angular "antenna pattern" of the detectors, that it is possible to localize the sky position of a gravitational wave source.
- dnautics 7y ago> The same signal in multiple detectors rules out detector errors Only if the cross correlation frequency is higher than the autocorrelation frequency. In other words, how often do signals with signature X appear, in each detector? If it's frequent then the likelihood of a by chance cross correlation is higher.
- tobinfricke 7y agoFigure 4 in the original detection paper shows a histogram of this false alarm rate (SNR versus detection frequency) and the detection as a significant outlier: https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.061102 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.11...
- BurningFrog 7y ago> the relative timing rules out terrestrial origin: no signal of terrestrial origin will travel at anywhere close to the speed of light through the Earth Well, there is still the chance that similar terrestrial events might happen at the same time near each detector. Especially while we only have 2 or 3 active LIGO detectors. I don't know how closely "fingerprinted" each event is to rule out such coincidences. It might be purely theoretical. Then again there is still the theoretical chance that an event will occur at an equidistant point from the LIGO stations and produce a signal of the same signature at all places at the same time. Probably absurdly unlikely, even as a conscious prankster attack. (Sorry for being so difficult...)
- pdonis 7y ago> I don't know how closely "fingerprinted" each event is to rule out such coincidences. Such a coincidence would have to produce the same specific signal in each detector. That's highly unlikely. > there is still the theoretical chance that an event will occur at an equidistant point from the LIGO stations and produce a signal of the same signature at all places at the same time. You're misunderstanding the relative time criterion. It is not that the signals are seen at the same time in all the detectors. It is that the signals are seen at just the right different times at the detectors that would be expected from an outside signal that travels at the speed of light through the Earth, hitting the different detectors at different times as it passes through. An event that really is seen at the same time in all the detectors would obviously be of terrestrial origin and would not be reported as a detection of an outside signal. Even events that are at different times, but the wrong different times for a light speed signal coming from outside, would not be reported as a detection.
- darkmighty 7y ago> no signal of terrestrial origin will travel at anywhere close to the speed of light through the Earth (earthquake waves travel orders of magnitude slower) To be fair, electromagnetic (i.e. radio) waves do travel at the speed of light through the Earth, though almost none can significantly penetrate the Earth itself, except extremely low frequencies. Electromagnetic interference should be quite easy to measure and look for correlations though; if scientists did their homework (likely), it has been ruled out.
- tzs 7y agoIs the index of refraction of the Earth at low radio frequencies really 1? I'd expect it to be higher, and so there to be some slowdown for radio waves.
- darkmighty 7y agoDepends on how low the frequency is :) But indeed I'm not an expert by any means on magma properties, perhaps someone else can chime in. If magma is conductive then even less radiation goes through. Keep in mind at extremely low frequencies the whole Earth is in mid-field or near-field of emissions, so it doesn't behave attenuated like light rays.
- ncmncm 7y agoMagma is, for practical purposes, infinitely conductive. Only atmospheric EM events are plausible causes of spurious correlated events.
- darkmighty 7y agoEven an infinitely conductive sphere does not screen the quasi-static near field very well. Although the delay is probably going to be weird, greater than direct visibility. Atmospheric EM events indeed are what comes to mind.
- pdonis 7y ago> electromagnetic (i.e. radio) waves do travel at the speed of light through the Earth, though almost none can significantly penetrate the Earth itself, except extremely low frequencies Yes, but they won't jiggle the test masses in LIGO, so they won't produce a signal.