4 ms·
It seems a special kind of doublethink to release some software as free and some as proprietary. Software isn’t property, and applying property rights to it is
by sneak 7y ago
It seems a special kind of doublethink to release some software as free and some as proprietary.
Software isn’t property, and applying property rights to it is fundamentally unjust. This is the point of free software.
To then turn around and also license proprietary software simultaneously means that you were doing free software for the wrong reasons entirely.
- Thorentis 7y ago> Software isn’t property It's intellectual property. So, yes you can apply property rights to it. But you can certainly argue that freely available software is better than privately owned and controlled software.
- sneak 7y agoIntellectual property is a fiction, designed by legislators for one purpose: to enable industrial production of copyrightable works. Don’t let the fact that player piano reel duplicators worried composers and musicians into getting congress involved cause you lose sight of this fact. It isn’t property, we just treat it that way for purposes of business and commerce. It’s not real; you can’t own a sequence of bytes. This is the point of copyleft, to assert non-ownership within this existing, fictional framework our lawmakers have constructed for the benefit of these industries. Licensing part of one’s software as free software and licensing another part of one’s software as non-free means that the entity doing the licensing doesn’t understand this concept, or why software freedoms matter.
- pmart123 7y agoWhat about the case surrounding Anthony Levandowski? Should he be allowed to freely take Waymo's IP when another company offers him a substantial economic incentive to do so?
- geofft 7y agoSure, https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/how-the-anthony-levandowski-indictment-helps-big-tech-stifle-innovation-in-silicon-valley https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/how-the-... makes that argument (as does https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20812814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20812814). The Traitorous Eight taking Shockley's IP launched the Valley. Microsoft and Apple taking Xerox's IP (so brazenly that a movie would later call them "Pirates") launched the personal computer revolution. Google taking what the court of appeals calls Oracle's intellectual property launched Android. Illegal copies of everything from Windows to IDA Pro to Photoshop launched so many of our careers. More specifically, the free software argument is that he should be allowed to freely take and publicize Waymo's IP even when nobody is paying him to do so, that the legitimate ends of society are better reached by not protecting software copyright at all and by encouraging work to be done in the commons. Copyright produces a reward for the first company to successfully implement some idea, but then results in that company alone being able to improve - and since they have the market cornered, they have little incentive to improve until some other company catches up with them. It is far from obvious that this produces better software, better research, or better results for society than just letting anyone build on top of anyone else's work, monetizing (if necessary) on delivering whole products with a support lifecycle instead of on code itself. Waymo and Uber will both still profit from self-driving cars even if they're not the exclusive owners of the code or research behind making them work, and even if Waymo decides to stop having their own fleet of cars, it's still valuable for others to hire the original engineering team to work on specific features. Or, let me put this another way. Is the Levandowski case justification for software patents? Why should Uber be able to use Google's algorithms and ideas without licensing them? That's intellectual property too, isn't it? The free software argument is neither novel nor rare in the hacker community, and I'm confused to see someone who advocates it getting such a hostile and skeptical reception here.
- sneak 7y agoA lot of HN’s electorate’s salaries depend upon not understanding the importance of software freedom. After all, the server we are using to communicate is paid for with dollars made from keeping source code secret from the users of that same software. Let’s not forget that this is first and foremost a commercial YC project. HN is not free software and its source is not available to its users. It is unsurprising that users here are hostile to the plain, objective fact that it is clearly and self-evidently impossible to own a sequence of bits in the same way one can own a physical object.
- pmart123 7y agoI don’t agree with this. There is a lot of value to releasing open software. I’ve learned a ton from reading other people’s code and looking over various ways to implement certain patterns. Additionally, it allows a developer to see and understand how something internally functions, which can bring clarity to the positives and trade offs the software comes with.