3 ms·
It's just that what you describe has got very little to do with how open source works. So why are they mentioning open source? (As an aside, I'm also not sure
by jrochkind1 7y ago
It's just that what you describe has got very little to do with how open source works. So why are they mentioning open source?
(As an aside, I'm also not sure that's as much of an issue in enforcing copyright as it is in enforcing trademark, but I'm no lawyer. But:
> Copyright is not like trademark. Copyright has a set period of time for which it is valid and, unless you take some kind of action, you do not give up those rights… However, unlike trademarks, which do have to be defended, there is nothing the precludes you from enforcing your copyrights at a later date.
https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/stopping-internet-plagiarism/your-copyrights-online/3-copyright-myths/ https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/stopping-internet-plagiarism...
But I'm not sure how relevant this really is).
- henryfjordan 7y agoIt's an issue in enforcing copyright, not trademark. Search guard isn't pretending to be Elastic. They are pretending to have copy rights to the code beyond what the open source license says they have (hence the mention of open source). Edit: I think you changed your comment a bit, but it's not that elastic couldn't let this one slide, it's that doing so would hurt them in the future. Their code can't be worth much if they just let people violate the license left and right.
- geofft 7y agoI think the commenter above was trying to say that the "you have to enforce it every time or future cases are weaker" applies to protecting trademark rights and not copyrights. (They weren't saying this is a trademark case, they were saying that because this isn't a trademark case, trademark rules don't apply.) The "you have to enforce it" thing is about genericized trademarks: I can sell a painkiller under the name "aspirin" because everyone forgot it's a trademark and so there's no argument that there's an intent to cause market confusion with Bayer. But the copious pirated copies of Windows don't let me sell it without licensing it from Microsoft.