7 ms·
Facebook: "This dataset is old and appears to have information obtained before we made changes last year to remove people’s ability to find others using their p
by reaperducer 7y ago
Facebook: "This dataset is old and appears to have information obtained before we made changes last year to remove people’s ability to find others using their phone numbers."
Not that "old." Some of those "update" dates are just a few days ago.
- dvtrn 7y agoYes but "But the data appeared to be loaded into the exposed database at the end of last month — though that doesn’t necessarily mean the data is new." Somewhat curious what the Status key represents in this dump, personally.
- akerro 7y ago>ability to find others using their phone numbers." Ah right, that's why I couldn't find someone...
- Avamander 7y ago> changes last year to remove people’s ability to find others using their phone numbers. What? That's not true, I reported the issue about user enumeration via phone numbers being possible in Whatsapp, Messenger and Instagram to them last week and they claimed (paraphrased) "it's a feature, not a security issue".
- 1000units 7y agoDo you intend to publish this correspondence? I think some companies prefer to sue people using these "features" instead of changing them. It's a good thing to have on record.
- Avamander 7y agoThere's not much to publish. It is just me saying that a custom contact book allows finding out a lot of people's accounts, them saying that the behavior respects people's settings and is working as intended.
- rhizome 7y agoThey removed "people's" ability, but not their own.
- compiler-guy 7y agoHow many people change their phone numbers more than once a decade? How many people change their facebook accounts ever? The age of this data may be "old" by whatever definition Facebook is using, but it is still of great interest to identity thieves and ne'er-do-wells.
- 52-6F-62 7y agoYep. As far as I’m accustomed most people do whatever they can to maintain their phone numbers even across services. So much so that it’s law in Canada a provider can’t lock in your number and must let you take it with you to another provider.
- JeanSebTr 7y agoGood to know it's a law. I was discussing this yesterday as being easy and frequent to port over number between providers. Do you know if providers are allowed to charge a fee for the transfer?
- lstamour 7y agoNo, but if you were on a contract they can charge you the device cost prorated to how much time was left on your contract. And the new carrier can charge a setup or admin fee, though most carriers don’t for competitive reasons, or they call it a SIM card fee and waive it if you activate via eSIM. All the fine print in Plain English: https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/phone/mobile/num.htm https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/phone/mobile/num.htm Actual ruling: https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2005/dt2005-72.htm https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2005/dt2005-72.htm Further regulation covers number portability beyond the named carriers, and require all carriers to register with the CRTC, etc. https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2017/2017-11.htm https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2017/2017-11.htm In return, the CRTC helps guarantee access to the large players’ wholesale networks, though in practice the fight is still ongoing over newly installed fibre optic networks and the uncompetitive rates the incumbents charge for full speed service on their networks. It’s not all good news - A particularly disappointing CRTC ruling followed Bell Canada’s recommendation that Canadian TV should only be provided via Internet if the household has internet from that TV provider directly. Which has effectively locked out any over the top competition such as YouTube TV from Canadian markets as they won’t be able to offer Canadian OTA channels. Sadly, I can’t find the ruling in the mess on the CRTC site, as CRTC language is obscure to say the least, but as TV is heavily regulated in Canada, the CRTC has old fashioned rules saying IPTV providers must provision a box and a line for service (Internet) in order to offer TV. This limits competition to only those willing to provide Internet in Canada to every household, or requires third-parties to negotiate with incumbents for access to such households. Existing third-party ISPs/Canadian IPTV companies go along with the above rules because nobody wants US providers entering the market, they just want to carve out cheaper Internet+TV price points with competitive Internet speeds that the incumbents don’t offer at competitive wholesale rates and benefit from a high switching cost where switching TV providers means switching ISPs knowing most people won’t do it. Until we have enough VOD content, Canadians are either pirating, using VPNs or paying their ISP for television, not having any other legal choices in this country... While I can’t find the ruling just yet, here’s an article from 2015 highlighting Bell’s requirement that IPTV be restricted to ISP lines: https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/bell-crtc-25-basic-tv-1.3752176 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/bell-crtc-25-basic-tv-1.375... And here’s an article where Bell refused to license their networks to VMedia’s Roku app arguing that by going over the public Internet, VMedia was running the content on a private network outside Bell’s control (Most IPTV providers find it cheaper to bundle with Bell’s VDSL) https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/bell-vmedia-iptv-internet-roku-rogers-shaw-cable-cordcutters-telus-cogeco-ott-set-top-box-appletv-chromecast-1.3856882 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/bell-vmedia-iptv-internet-r... This later led to the ruling that only ISPs can provide TV... Personally I’m more irritated by how much VOD content Bell has exclusive license to, such as their Crave+HBO, which is cheap for now, but helps Bell compete with channels offered by Amazon Prime Video. Corus, formerly owned by Shaw (another cable provider) licenses a lot of US content, and so might limit what content is available north of the border. It’s particularly hard to find VOD episodes from Turner and Viacom networks and the expanded licensing STARZ has with Hulu is completely absent north of the border. When you can’t find a show legally on any VOD network in your country including iTunes, what are you supposed to do...? CRTC rules are not making this any easier for Canadians to watch what they want, wherever they want (ISP requirement means your cell phone must also have service from your IPTV provider, it’s nuts), and on whatever device they want...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- the_watcher 7y agoThat just means the database was updated a few days ago, not that the data is new.
- organsnyder 7y agoI've had my phone number since 2002. It doesn't matter how "old" their dataset is when some of the data predates the entire company.
- mannykannot 7y agoThe new normal in public relations seems to be to make irrelevant or simply mendacious excuses which seem to suggest that they don't have a clue, but which actually show their contempt for their users.