5 ms·
> Professors are offered substantial bribes to select the most expensive texts Really? I'm still waiting for my check. Somebody call me. I know this his art
by bsder 7y ago
> Professors are offered substantial bribes to select the most expensive texts
Really? I'm still waiting for my check. Somebody call me.
I know this his article is a rant, but that particular statement calls into question the veracity of anything else he says.
Maybe. Maybe there is a bribe somewhere involved in a 200+ person introductory class. Maybe.
No one in their right mind is going to offer or accept a bribe over 30 books at $150 each. The biggest "bribe" I ever get is that the publishers often send me a free copy of a book. And, if I ask for one, it probably won't be free, I'll have to send it back.
Most EECS professors I know of are keenly aware of the price of textbooks. They do NOT go out of their way to make things difficult. And, if we pick a book, it's a book you are going to make use of again in your career. We also place it on reserve in the library, and we avoid the digital lock in which generally causes us as much grief as it causes the students.
Maybe this is different in the non-technical fields.
- bonzini 7y agoI heard it's really bad in chemistry and medicine.
- gowld 7y agoAdministration captures the profit in education, not rank and file professors. https://www.the-scientist.com/profession/textbook-adoption-how-do-professors-select-the-right-one-60192 https://www.the-scientist.com/profession/textbook-adoption-h... > Many professors and departments encourage such practices, which can be viewed as either bribes or legitimate marketing ploys. Richard McKenzie, a professor of economics at the University of California, Irvine, was appalled at schools' requests for inducements to adopt his textbook The New World of Economics (Homewood, Ill., Irwin Publishing Inc., 1989), written with Gordon Tullock. "A department at a Southwestern university chose our book and two others, and put them up for auction," says McKenzie. "They would adopt the book with the biggest side payment." So McKenzie began talking to publishers' sales reps and quickly learned that monetary enticement to adopt a book, although not rampant, does happen, and not just in economics. In science, these extras are encountered in large introductory biology and chemistry courses--but less so in physics and geology classes, which tend to attract fewer students.
- microtherion 7y agoIt's somewhat amusing that an economist is shocked to see market mechanisms at work…
- cestith 7y agoHere's a scary thought for you. It's about K-12 but the numbers definitely add up. Texas has a poorly overseen state board that produces a list of approved textbooks from which public districts may choose. It's an elected board of only 15 or so members, and they are elected in the smaller, less voted elections. https://repositories.lib.utexas.edu/handle/2152/19095 https://repositories.lib.utexas.edu/handle/2152/19095
- bsder 7y agoThat's very different. You are talking about people making a decision on textbooks for one of the two largest markets in the entire US. Yeah, that's going to be ripe for abuse. Professors taking bribes at universities overseeing 30 books? Or even 300? Please. You'd have to be a complete moron to risk your professorship over that. Perhaps an untenured lecturer in a big intro class, though, might be persuaded. Most of them are paid terribly poorly, and losing a job but gaining $5,000 in cash might be within the realm of possibility.
- linguae 7y agoI've generally had the same experiences as a CS undergrad and grad student. While sometimes CS textbook prices are high, the books I was assigned tend to be useful long after I complete the class the book was assigned. For example, I still refer to my copy of CLRS from the undergraduate algorithms course I took nearly 12 years ago; that $80 purchase was one of my best investments, especially considering the LeetCode-style interviews that so many companies tend to give these days. Unfortunately it was my math and science courses where expensive textbooks and access codes reared their ugly heads. I took a combined differential equations and linear algebra course that used a full-priced textbook that was specifically printed for my university, meaning that when it was time to resell it, the usefulness of that textbook was restricted to students of my university instead of nationwide or perhaps worldwide. The worst was the first quarter of physics. I had to use an awful online homework platform called Mastering Physics. I hated it with a passion, and ended up getting a very low (but passing) grade the first time I took the course. I ended up retaking the course with a retired professor who didn't use Mastering Physics; he preferred handwritten homework submissions.