3 ms·
Note that the headline cost will be very high because much of it ends up being a partial rebate on higher taxes. (This would be true of most people with a middl
by skybrian 7y ago
Note that the headline cost will be very high because much of it ends up being a partial rebate on higher taxes. (This would be true of most people with a middle-class or better income: you'd have higher taxes, but get some of the money back.)
With any redistribution program, just looking at direct costs and not its effects on the economy, the average person breaks even. That's what redistribution means - there's no money being created or destroyed. The numerator and denominator don't change.
But most of us are not average. Like with insurance, most people end up paying most of the time, but if you're out of work for any reason, or just working a low-paying job, then you'll benefit. And like most other insurance, the advantage is security rather than actually saving money, most of the time.
Along with that security comes greater freedom. The question is a philosophical one: do you trust that most of your fellow citizens can handle freedom? Will they live in near-poverty rather than strive for more? Do you trust that if someone decides not to work, they usually have good reasons? And do you think it's worth paying in during good times in order to ensure everyone has somewhat more freedom to choose where to live and how to make a living?
Or do you think that people cannot be trusted and must be controlled via the threat of financial ruin?