5 ms·
Google has been fined a 5 billion dollar fine already last year, that claim simply isn't true. But I agree with the implicit demand, they clearly haven't gotten
by Barrin92 7y ago
Google has been fined a 5 billion dollar fine already last year, that claim simply isn't true. But I agree with the implicit demand, they clearly haven't gotten the message. The EU should slap them with billion dollar fines again until they learn their lesson.
- moomin 7y agoQ4 2018 earnings were around $40 billion. EU will have to try significantly harder.
- mlthoughts2018 7y agoIt will have to be executive jailtime and personal fines or it will never matter.
- icebraining 7y agoThat's the revenue, not profit.
- inetknght 7y agoThat's also the point. Profit shouldn't have anything to do with fines. Redress and compensation should. A fine is supposed to make business-as-usual unpalatable.
- icebraining 7y agoSure, I'm just pointing it out because "earnings" usually means "profit".
- cryoshon 7y ago5 billion is peanuts to google. if the fine is low enough that it can be written off as a cost of business, it's too low. effective fines devastate profit margins rather than merely crimping them.
- kittiepryde 7y agoDoing some quick googling, it looks like their quarterly revenue is in the 6-7 billion range. I don't believe 20%ish of revenue is in the peanuts range. Edit: doing some more googling, maybe it's in the 10 billion range; getting better for Google, but I still can't see a company deciding that such a fine is irrelevant.
- rbavocadotree 7y agoQ2'19 Revenue was 39.7 Billion. Income was 9.2 Billion.
- elorant 7y agoIt's not peanuts. Fines are meant as a warning. You keep ignoring them eventually they'll hit you with something that will really hurt.
- eptcyka 7y agoWould you like to transfer 1/8th of your yearly earnings to my account? After all, it's just peanuts.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wtdata 7y agoThat fine qualifies as a "slap in the hand" for Google if it happens infrequently enough (which is the case).
- icebraining 7y agoIt's not that infrequent; they got another $1.7B fine this year. Remember that these processes take a long time, but they are running in parallel.
- cj 7y agoI believe the $5 billion was an antitrust violation, not related to GDPR. I could be wrong.
- docker_up 7y agoThe executives should face jail time. That would certainly light a fire under Google's ass to finally "do no evil".
- inlined 7y agoSadly mid-level employees would probably be the ones going to jail. The tech lead and/or PM sign off on compliance. I used to joke that one of my responsibilities was to put my freedom at stake. None of my products violate GDPR in any way I could conceive, but I’d hate to be handed down a mandate to do so. Both not accepting a project and not signing off on it are pretty bold moves.
- inlined 7y agoCommon retort: don’t just downvote me, tell me why I’m wrong. I’m a professional who had signed off on legal documents. Why would the buck not stop at me? That’s the way it works in architecture and other professions.
- jodrellblank 7y agoCommon retort: don’t just downvote me, tell me why I’m wrong. "Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- hobofan 7y agoI _think_ this rule is intended to discourage "Have an upvote" (and similar) comments, commonly seen on Reddit. Reminding fellow readers/commenters to not just shallowly dismiss comments once in a while doesn't do much harm, and actually lead me to reply to the parent.
- hobofan 7y agoEven though it's not optimal, maybe that's what it takes? Then top-tier engineers would think twice about working for companies with shady privacy practices and Google would finally have an incentive to better themselves.