10 ms·
Inequality in Equalland
- cperciva 16y agoThis blog post was inspired by the article and conversation here (especially pg's comment about income vs. wealth): http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2039503 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2039503
- chrisaycock 16y agoGreat post. An excellent explanation of why equal income still can't lead to equal wealth.
- lotharbot 16y agoI'm curious: were you also inspired by my previous posts, or did you independently develop the idea of "equalland"? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1830974 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1830974 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1904114 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1904114
- cperciva 16y agoI'm pretty sure I didn't see your comments -- at least, I don't remember thinking about this distinction at all until the article two weeks ago. Good to see that I'm not alone in thinking this way, though!
- axiom 16y agoThank you! As soon as those wealth inequality posts started popping up I've been waiting for someone to point out the idiocy of lamenting the wealth inequality between 22 yearolds just entering the workforce and 65 yearolds about to retire.
- chrisaycock 16y agoYes, and it's probably exacerbated in developed countries with an aging population.
- Unseelie 16y agoI'd argue, as a 22 year old economist just entering the workforce, that the fact that people just entering their retirement hold the most wealth is quite a social problem. For instance, the ability of the older wealth to influence politics.
- benmccann 16y agoAlso, in real life, the generation nearing retirement has much better voter turnout than the generation exiting college. So not only do they have more money to influence elections, but they're a more desirable demographic to cater to due to their presence at the polls. We see this play out clearly in their ability to influence politics. E.g. they can vote themselves unsustainable entitlement benefits at the expense of younger generations.
- bergie 16y ago...which is why we probably never get to retire. The weirdly shaped population pyramid in the Western world can make "maybe Google will buy us" a more reasonable retirement strategy than retirement funds
- zdw 16y agoObviously, we should have a political system that gives higher weight to the votes of people who will participate (suffer?) in the system longer. Therefore, everyone between 18 and 24 years of age gets 10 votes, between 24-30 9, etc, until people over 78 get zero votes (just like minor children under 18). This would deal with the problem nicely. And yes, I am kidding.
- jackowayed 16y agoPopulation growth would actually do that to a lesser extent (because there are more 25-30-year-olds than 55-60-year-olds) were it not for the fact that young people are less likely to vote.
- naa42 16y ago
- maeon3 16y agoI would like to live in Equal-land, I could live there, slouch around, work the absolute minimum and avoid work, and enjoy exactly the same benefits as those working the hardest to maintain that utopia.
- rcthompson 16y agoYou're missing the point. The point is that even when everyone is actually equal, there is still some apparent wealth inequality because different people are at different stages of life.
- MrDunham 16y agoI believe that was the promise of communism - which failed due to most people's inherent desire to be better than others or to excel. Also, people realized that they could/should do the absolute minimum, as there was no benefit for working harder. They did end up adding incentives (in the USSR) which started looking more and more like capitalism.
- jshen 16y agoI'm so glad linus did the minimum when working on Linux, you know, since he wasn't getting paid and there was no perceivable financial gain in it. This meme that money is the only significant benefit from ones efforts should be plainly false. Why smart people believe it is beyond me.
- ericd 16y agoLinus really can't be used as an example of what normal behavior would be. Noone's saying it's the only significant benefit, but for a lot of people, it is the overwhelming majority of the benefit of what they do. Programmers live in a privileged bubble compared to most.
- jbooth 16y agoOf course, when we're talking about the top of the income scale, we're very specifically talking about the group of people who live in that privileged bubble.
- btilly 16y agoAccording to Wikipedia, 87% of the wealth belongs to the wealthiest 20%. However over 80% of that wealth belongs to the top half of that group. The figures I am looking at do not break it down farther, but my understanding is that this same relative relationship holds for the top 5%, 2%, 1%, and so on. Everyone agrees that some wealth disparity is a good and necessary part of a healthy economy. But there is a lot more going on here than the straightforward "some people are older, some people save". The charts and tables at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_in_the_United_States#Distribution_of_wealth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_in_the_United_States#Dis... are very interesting. Of interest to many in the HN crowd I direct you to "Current work status of head". Note the immense disparity between "self-employed" and all other categories.
- gnosis 16y ago"Everyone agrees that some wealth disparity is a good and necessary part of a healthy economy." Nope.
- drunkpotato 16y agoWhile I agree with you and disagree with the original poster, indeed, not everyone agrees that some wealth disparity is a good and necessary part of a healthy economy, I think the discussion merits more than a dismissive "Nope". Perhaps, if you are one of those that disagrees, you could lay out your position and argument. It is difficult to see how to avoid wealth disparity. We can argue all day about whether that is good or evil, but it is a dangerous and destructive proxy for the complex question that, I believe, most of us actually want to answer: How do we get the most good to the most people while simultaneously preserving most or all of the autonomy, freedom, and privacy that Western cultures traditionally also value?
- Confusion 16y agoYou can't disagree with either cperciva or btilly, because they've merely been presenting facts and figures. I don't see an opinion there
- j_baker 16y agoI doubt this is a valid model of economic reality (even as a rough approximation). I seriously doubt that the average American is saving anywhere near as much for their retirement as this simulation suggests. "Nearly half of baby boomers born between 1948 and 1954 and now between the ages of 56 and 62 are at risk of not having enough money in retirement to pay for basic expenditures, EBRI reports." - http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/07/14/AR2010071405229.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/07...
- bhangi 16y agoNote that the "inequality" here is strictly age related -- in other words, if you live according to prescription, then you too will have that amount of wealth at a particular point in your life. In other words, everyone has the same opportunity for upward economic mobility. When most commentators talk about inequality they're really talking about the lack of upward economic mobility.
- monkeypizza 16y agoSo to summarize, even in an ideal equal world, inequality exists. Just pointing out that the top 20% owns more than the bottom 20% means literally nothing, because even in a totally equal world, that is true. If you introduce random variation into the performance of the stock market, then the ownership of the top 20% would increase even more!
- aneesh 16y agoThe next step is to decompose the wealth inequality into two metrics: inequality within an age-band, and inequality due to different life stages. In Equalland, the former is zero, so all inequality is due to the latter. So, when you hear that the top 20% have X% of the wealth, keep in mind that the bar isn't 20%. A better bar is the 64% from Equalland.
- stretchwithme 16y agoInequality of outcomes dos not bother me. Injustice bothers me. Unequal treatment bothers me. But not inequality of outcomes. There are simply too many variables between individuals that affect outcomes. Some are randomly assigned at birth. Others are the result of individual choice. Even if you eliminated all injustice, however you define it, individual choice and different ability would still produce inequality of outcome.
- ugh 16y agoThis is a nice demonstration that ‘raw’ inequality data is not very useful. “X% have Y% of the wealth!” really doesn’t tell you very much. I’m actually only concerned about the consequences of inequality (which could be positive or negative), not about inequality itself. What do I care if 1% of the population have 99% of the wealth if there are no consequences to it? I certainly don’t want to reduce inequality out of spite. Statistics that tell me, just as an example, how the wealth of parents corresponds with the success of their children in school are much more interesting and reducing inequality probably wouldn’t even be the best solution for such a problem. It’s not as though all that money in mommy’s and daddy’s bank account makes their kids magically more intelligent. (But it can pay for private schools or for private lessons and so on.)
- cperciva 16y agoIt’s not as though all that money in mommy’s and daddy’s bank account makes their kids magically more intelligent. (But it can pay for private schools or for private lessons and so on.) FWIW, numerous studies have found that the vast majority of correlation between parental income and the academic success of children can be explained by a third factor: Parental education. Educated parents both earn more and provide far more educational encouragement and assistance to their children.
- ugh 16y agoYeah, I knew that and should have written that in my comment. You are right. I’m from Germany where this kind of inequality is particularly egregious. The explanation is probably that the fate of students is decided early on, in fourth grade. (You continue in one of three different types of schools after fourth grade, depending on your grades. Switching between schools is a hassle and only the highest school has a clear path to all universities.) Looking back at my own experience in elementary school, I would say that it was essential for me that my parents learned with me and helped me with my homework.
- lsd5you 16y agoI feel that you are omitting genetics as a possible (probable) significant cause of academic success, which because of the corelation with the parents own academic success will be hard to disambiguate as a variable. According to horizon (a main stream medium-high brow documentary series in the UK), separated twin studies show that as much as 50% of 'measured intelligence' can be attributed to genetics - which was fairly surprising (not the figure itself, because it agrees with my own suspicions) but because it was on a mainstream show. What is more earlier in the show they talked about a scientist in the 30's (nephew of Francis Galton, forget his name) who had faked a bunch of such studies and made up numbers. The figure he invented was 30%.
- jdp23 16y agoImagine another country which has government-funded secondary education and pensions that cover the bulk of retirement expenses. Wouldn't the "necessary" inequality be noticeably lower in that case?
- cperciva 16y agoActually, no. If the government of Equalland were to pay a $50k/year to each retired couple, they would need to save less and the entire graph would shrink vertically -- but the ratios would stay the same. In fact, in the real world government pensions tend to increase apparent wealth inequality, since they are usually capped (e.g., in Canada the CPP pays out a proportion of your first ~$40k/year of pre-retirement income, but ignores any income beyond that point) -- in order to maintain the same standard of living post-retirement, the wealthy need to save a greater proportion of their income.
- asmosoinio 16y agoTypo at: "The most indebted households in Equalland &mdash $130,133....", missing the ;-character.
- lucasjung 16y agoGreat post! It provides a good gedanken for sorting out how much inequality results from age and how much results from other factors. If you made this scenario a little bit more complex, you could demonstrate how other forms of "inequality" are based, in part, on age: 1: Have everyone start with equal $50,000 salary at age 22, then get a raise of $3,000 per year until they hit 65. Everyone would still have equal lifetime earnings, but you would find significant income "inequality" when looking at the population as a whole. 2: Instead of a flat $3,000 per year raise, everyone gets a 3.5% raise each year until they hit 65. This is closer to real life than the scenario above, and would produce an even more "unequal" income distribution.
- fdhjrjk 16y agoClick on our website: === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== Gold autumn, personality Mes clothing + Shoes, Travel bag that grabs an eye coat + Chao packet Free transport === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ==== === http://goo.gl/l5v0b http://goo.gl/l5v0b ====
- amalcon 16y agoThis is a good point if you make the assumption that people tend to accumulate wealth as they age as a rule. I think this is likely, but it has not been established as a general proposition. The shapes of individual "wealth curves" will not necessarily be identical. Here are a few examples to consider: - A person who is raised in a middle-class home, and has basically the life story in the blog post will have a curve similar to that one. - A person who is raised in a poor home, is unable to afford college even with loans, and makes a few bad economic decisions early on, though not so bad that he cannot pay for them, will have a similar-looking debt event, followed by little change for the rest of his life. - A person who is raised in a wealthy home, goes to college without needing loans, and is taught from an early age the value of savings and investment will have a much steeper exponential curve, and a much flatter "retirement decline". - A person who is raised in a poor home, is unable to afford college even with loans, and makes catastrophic economic decisions will likely either declare bankruptcy or end up in prison. Either event resets wealth accumulation to an unspecified negative value (to account for the stigma and reduced access to various opportunities), yielding a significantly different curve. - A person who is raised in a rich home, with a trust fund, but whose trust fund was invested in real estate and Bernie Madoff. - A person living the Equalland scenario encounters a catastrophic financial event at some point (illness, crime, failure of an over-leveraged investment such as a home) and is driven considerably into debt. Servicing that debt will require either a significant portion of income thereafter or bankruptcy. - A person living the Equalland scenario, except that his chosen field of education is overproduced in his generation, will have a similar curve to the fourth scenario above. The education debt does not necessarily produce benefits thereafter. I do think the Equalland scenario is likely to be most common, but I recognize that my suspicions are likely influenced by the fact that it is the most common scenario amongst my peers. I don't think it's a foregone conclusion that it is the overwhelmingly most common scenario in general, especially with so many different scenarios resulting in a net wealth loss over the course of a person's life.
- Symmetry 16y agoFar more useful than looking at inequality in wealth or even income is inequality in consumption.