2 ms·
See that's just a cop out. The world's climate is sufficiently complex and unevenly distributed such that any given year, some record will have been broken in s
by chrisco255 7y ago
See that's just a cop out. The world's climate is sufficiently complex and unevenly distributed such that any given year, some record will have been broken in some part of the world. It's neither useful nor informative to predict extremes in general. If you don't a precise prediction about the world and the climate, then you don't have science: you have random guessing.
NOAA, one of the leading world institutions in climate science, predicted in October 2018 that the U.S. would have a warm winter and the West's drought would continue.
October 2018 prediction: https://www.noaa.gov/media-release/winter-outlook-favors-warmer-temperatures-for-much-of-us https://www.noaa.gov/media-release/winter-outlook-favors-war...
March 2019 retroanalysis: https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/enso/winter-outlook-2018-2019-how%E2%80%99d-we-do https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/enso/winter-outl...
They were way off. They can't predict the next six months with a high degree of accuracy, much less the next century.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBut you're not actually answering SketchySeaBeast's point. The point isn't that "some record will be broken in some part of the world". The claim is that more records are being broken in more and bigger parts of the world. That claim should actually be statistically testable. And it has nothing to do with NOAA's inability to accurately predict six months out.
- chrisco255 7y agoShow me your source on that quote. More and bigger? If you don't have a quantifiable prediction (temperature, sea ice extent, drought extent, hemispheric snow mass totals, precipitation amount, etc), you don't have a valid hypothesis. You just have broad blind brush that you can conveniently retroactively fit any outcome. That's not science. Nostradamus had the same methodology. Make your predictions as generic as possible and you'll always be correct. "More and bigger" are relative terms. Pegged to what date in history? It has everything to do with NOAA's ability to predict 6 months out because uncertainty for predictions increases as a function of time. If you can't predict 6 months accurately, you have even less of a claim to predict 60 years accurately. That's how predictions work.
- hanniabu 7y ago> If you can't predict 6 months accurately, you have even less of a claim to predict 60 years accurately. You do realize that climate change is a long term trend?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoTake just temperature for a moment. The second year a weather station keeps records, you would expect half of the days to be "hottest ever". (You would also expect half the days to be "coldest ever".) As you have kept records for 1/N years, you would expect something like 1/N of the time you get a new record (or less, if you assume a normal distribution). That is, you expect the number of records to decrease over time. It's the same with all the other kinds of records (sea ice, etc.) So if you see the number of records increasing over time (modulo new data sources), then something interesting is happening. Either the center point is moving, or things are getting more extreme. If you see more records of both ends (hot and cold, say), then you can say that yes, things are getting more extreme. If you see more records on both ends, but more records for heat, then you can say that things are getting both hotter and more extreme. I don't have to have a quantifiable prediction of what the temperature will be in order to make that observation. If it were to be cast as a prediction, it might be something like "among weather stations that have existed for at least 30 years, there will be more temperature records set next year than there were 10 years ago".