3 ms·
The ballot question was: > Do you want Britain to remain or leave the EU? With the accompanying pamphlet stating: > The government will implement what you de
by nailer 7y ago
The ballot question was:
> Do you want Britain to remain or leave the EU?
With the accompanying pamphlet stating:
> The government will implement what you decide.
This includes the government negotiating with the EU. If the government must accept any deal the EU offers (because someone dislikes No Deal being on the table) then the EU will offer the worst deal possible, and has done so (the current deal has been rejected by parliament three times).
- gambiting 7y agoAs someone else already pointed out - a "no deal" in reality means "no deal until any deal is reached". UK cannot be on WTO terms with the EU forever, but by going on them in the first place the economy is taking a hit until something else is negotiated. And that negotiation will be exactly the same as now - backstop, immigrants, EU regulations - none of those issues disappear with a no deal. They just get delayed a little bit. It feels like a no deal is hitting your own face out of spite for the other side.
- jessaustin 7y ago"The government will implement what you decide." Well there's your problem! That's a vague reference. To a lawyer, it might obviously refer to the voter's decision with respect to the immediately preceding question. To the average UK voter, it might also refer to her decision that she wants blue skies, decent food, and a personal unicorn pony for everyone. It's hard to vote against unicorn ponies. [EDIT:] Apparently parent just pointlessly made up something, to which I credulously responded. Sorry for the distraction.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoExcept the ballot didn't actually say that. Here's what the ballot looked like: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:2016_EU_Referendum_Ballot_Paper.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:2016_EU_Referendum_B...
- nailer 7y agoThe information leaflet provided by the government contained this statement. The ballot paper itself only provides the question (as is the nature of ballot papers). I suspect you probably know that. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CmlykgDXEAAGs6C.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CmlykgDXEAAGs6C.jpg
- gambiting 7y agoThe contents of the leaflet are irrelevant, the leaflet was not provided at the time of voting and no such statement was on the ballot. It holds exactly as much legal weight as "£350 million for the NHS" printed on the side of the bus. If you took the government to court over it the court would most likely decide that information printed on leaflets have no legal standing, even if they are distributed by the government.
- nailer 7y agoThe leaflet was an official government communication provided to every household in the UK. And yes, 350M came from the Office of National Statistics, which is pretty solid.
- gambiting 7y agoI'm not disputing the number, I'm saying that writing "[by leaving the European Union] let's give £350m to the NHS instead" on a side of a bus is not a legally binding promise. It's just a slogan, nothing more. I'm not sure what we're arguing about at this point. The referendum was advisory, that's the legal status of any decision made in it - the government chose to implement the result, but it was at full liberty not to as well. That's irrelevant at this point because things didn't go down that path 3 years ago.
- nailer 7y ago> I'm not sure what we're arguing about at this point. It seems you think people didn't believe the government was going to implement what the people decided. The people were told the government was going to implement what the people decided. If you agree with the latter then let's move on with our day.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThere was, and is, no legal obligation on a UK government to take note of a referendum. They're just a big opinion poll, legally speaking. In some ways that's a big part of the problem. Other countries, e.g. Switzerland, that use referenda have rules about super-majorities, campaigning and spending, when and if they will become law and so on. Ensures that you don't get vague hand-wavy referendum that is campaigned as "we'll get a deal easily" morphing into WTO terms hard brexit some painful time later.
- nailer 7y agoThat is correct. There obligation is moral.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoPoint being there is no moral mandate on such a thin margin of the minority who voted when there were laws broken in the campaign finance, the claims made and so forth. At least elections have the veneer of election law behind them. Referendum nations have a similar veneer behind referenda - to decide whether it was fairly arrived at, etc. Switzerland not long threw out a result because the electorate had been given some sort of misleading information in the campaign.
- nailer 7y agoWell we lost by something like 1.5 million people. Overturning the referendum result because of campaign finance law seems somewhat excessive.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoPerhaps so, but I think it would be better to have had those parameters established beforehand, and where the limits of what was considered fair under law were. Maybe people could consider it settled even if they didn't like the result Anything would be better than how we did do it, really. :)