7 ms·
Subsistence Programming
- whatshisface 7y agoWhy aren't these packages jointly maintained by the money-making companies that use them? A lone developer writing a library isn't taking advantage of any of the positive-sum advantages of open source, he's just a guy working for free.
- PeterisP 7y agoWell, many serious open source projects are heavily maintained by the money-making companies that use them - either directly as a company, or by "accidentally" happening to employ key maintainers of these projects and letting them loose on that, or by simply having their engineers do a significant amount of feature development, or by sponsoring the projects. Where it does break down is with excessive fragmentation. A hundred small libraries each doing one thing will get much less corporate support than a single important library that does the same hundred things.
- _bxg1 7y ago> Where it does break down is with excessive fragmentation. A hundred small libraries each doing one thing will get much less corporate support than a single important library that does the same hundred things. I think you've nailed it; similar patterns have played out with news/blog sites, or even media like music and indie games. The internet has allowed for rich selections of micro-products to pop up, get created, get distributed. But we have yet to solve the problem of getting the money flowing the other way through the same ever-more-fine-grained tree. It's not that people refuse to pay for their news, it's that they don't want to sign up for and pay for dozens of different sources which they might follow a link to once a month. It's not (primarily) that people refuse to pay for software, it's that people don't want to spend the energy tracking down how to donate a couple dollars to the 100 different NPM dependencies their project has. In all these cases, unless you're a household name, you're going to get lost in the noise. Ads have traditionally been the workaround for this. They don't require any involvement from users, and they scale based on traffic. I supported Feross' experiment because I see (non-tracking) ads as a necessary evil until we come up with a better solution to this problem. Proposed solutions include bundles, Patreon, GitHub Sponsors, and what Brave is doing for web content. None of these have changed the equation yet, though, and it's a really vital problem to solve in today's world of content creation.
- agustif 7y agoWhat aboout a Spotify-like rev-share model, where the user only Subscribes once, Paying Whatever you want monthly, and then the platform redistributes that to your repo's deps on some way, make it easy to give extra tip's after nice interactions/issues-solved/pr's-merged/releases etc
- kemitchell 7y agoThe closest to that model is Tidelift, though last I checked, they still sell only add-on assurances, not permission to use the software to begin with.
- agustif 7y agoYeah I'm aware of Tidelift but it's still very not much a real thing for me. Good for enterprises I guess. It's just something I randomly but cyclically think about, here some old notes about it: What if GitHub Stars = Money Problem? I might want to give back to open source, but I’m too ignorant or lazy to actually do it. Create an indie platform that lets you create a one time or subscription donation to all your GitHub innteractions based on Stars, issues open, etc… If I have 1000 Stars and donate 100 dollars, each repo would get 10 cents, if 10 more people have starred the same repo than I have, the repo owner would get 1 dollar. So if she or he has 1000 stars, that’d mean she or he gets 100$ Stars are not so meaningless anymore. After first donation to a new repo, open an issue encouraging to get to minimum payout amount faster by pushing a badge into readme as a PR. PS: Original personal note from 23 may 2019, If I recall properly this was pre GhSponsors
- kemitchell 7y agoThere have been several attempts to create "tip jars" for open source that automatically split a total commitment across multiple projects or developers. Several ran aground on implementation issues like money transmitter regulation and payment processing. But even when the systems worked well and stayed out of trouble, they just didn't see that much money flowing through. Two subspecies of the tip jar rose to public prominence in the last few years. Crowdfunding sites like Patreon focus on perks. Both legally and practically, they eschew "donation", partly to avoid money transmission issues, partly because people are just more likely to give money for something in return, rather than gratuitously. Open software coders who've done well via these platforms number very few and often offer substantial perks that appeal to "enterprise" customers at high tiers. Sites like OpenCollective focus on raising for groups, rather than individuals. The amounts committed to groups can sometimes reach significant looking totals in the thousands of dollars, but splitting among contributors often cuts the per-individual number down significantly. The transparency and other groupware features put social pressure on individual developers not to take too much.
- ChristianBundy 7y agoThese packages aren't maintained by the companies that use them because their incentives aren't aligned. The most efficient approach would be to fund development by the current maintainers who are familiar with the project, but as long as the module continues working the companies have no market incentive to fund development.
- vorpalhex 7y agoOpen source won't pay your mortgage or buy you that yacht. It won't get you a job. It isn't going to help your resume potentially. And if you're doing it for any of those reasons, then stop doing it because you're missing the point. Do it because you care about what you're building. Do it because you want to share your solution with the world. Do it because you want to contribute.
- ummonk 7y agoWhy would anyone want to contribute solutions that others can profit off of for free? It seems really weird to me that there might be people who actually want to do this kind of charity.
- SolarNet 7y agoWell in the case of GPL it's to build a public commons. Part of GPL is to ensure that that public commons is maintained (it can be profited from, but not exploited). This article is likely referring to mostly permissive open source, which yea allows people to profit. We build a commons upon which better software can be built. People write open source to improve those commons, not for charity.
- csande17 7y agoIf you already wrote the solution for your own personal use, it can only benefit you to open-source it so other people can contribute improvements. (But sure, it might benefit you even more to sell it or distribute it as adware or something, depending on how useful it is.)
- harperlee 7y agoIn my case, even from a self interested point of view this makes sense: this only applies to improvements and bug fixes on some Clojure libraries, but: If I contribute back to a library I use, I can raise the probability that other people use it and contribute to it, thus ensuring that my dependencies keep fresh; and by sharing work I’d do nonetheless, I do not lose anything. On the other hand if I keep my changes to myself, then I do not gain anything, but I contribute to the withering of the environment Im building dependencies with.
- maxk42 7y agoThis person is complaining that subsistence isn't enough? News flash: Open source doesn't exist to pay your bills. It exists because you want others to benefit from your work. If you want to pay your own bills you should be selling something or working for someone who does.
- SolarNet 7y agoThat argument only has wings if the code in question is licensed with GPL. Besides the point this person is making is that open source developers should start selling their stuff instead.
- lacampbell 7y agoBy the same token, we should have very low expectations from open source libraries/projects that aren't backed by big companies, or where the authors aren't living off consulting. I've stopped relying on them entirely, unless they're very simple.
- ulucs 7y agoI'd argue the other way: hobby code is a product of genuine enjoyment and is probably better than the paid alternatives created to earn money.
- andymockli 7y agoSome people volunteer at a food bank or shelter and some people volunteer by writing/maintaining open source code. It's for the common good and volunteerism is a good thing.
- peterbraden 7y agoExcept there’s a big difference in people that go to food banks, and giant corporations that benefit from open source
- cthor 7y agoThat's why we have GPL.
- ChristianBundy 7y agoDoes the GPL do enough to protect us from private extraction of the commons? I used to advocate for 0BSD but at this point it seems like we need something like the AGPL or Parity.[0] [0]: https://licensezero.com/licenses/parity https://licensezero.com/licenses/parity
- cthor 7y agoAGPL closes the SAAS loophole. Outside of that, what "private extraction of the commons" is left to cover? Parity license looks like a super aggressive and untested version of AGPL. I can't see what benefit using it over AGPL would be. Prosperity license is at odds with the point of free software and almost certainly untenable.
- cortesoft 7y agoI guess the question is whether there SHOULD be developers who only make money as independent open source developers. My gut instinct says no. Open source development should be funded by companies paying their developers to work on and maintain open source projects. Developers are paid because what they write provides value to a business that will utilize that code to make money. This is true or open or closed source; many companies realize you get more value out of sharing coding resources with other companies to create shared, open source projects. This is how most open source is funded, and that isn't bad.
- msbarnett 7y ago> I guess the question is whether there SHOULD be developers who only make money as independent open source developers. My gut instinct says no. Open source development should be funded by companies paying their developers to work on and maintain open source projects. What you’re describing is a future where open source is driven and controlled solely by corporate interests, and anywhere user needs or desires or freedoms run counter to corporate interests, they go unserved by open source. That strikes me as a highly undesirable future.
- ChristianBundy 7y ago> That strikes me as a highly undesirable future. I'd argue that this is one of the most undesirable futures, and we should continue fighting however we can. Both Kyle and Feross are working their asses off trying to manifest sustainable open source funding and I've got nothing but respect and solidarity.
- cortesoft 7y agoPeople can always work on open source software for their own needs... in that case, you can treat the developer themselves as a business 'funding' the development by working on features they desire. I guess I just feel that the currency for funding open source is developer time.... you either contribute your own time or the time of developers that work for you.
- zokier 7y ago
- draw_down 7y agoThis has long seemed like a mug's game to me, and all the talk of "passion" and "community" and so forth strikes me as unconvincing. It's such a scam, you work hard on something that tons of companies use for free. If you're lucky, you get a couple bucks in donations. Then, if you decide that you're wasting your life doing this, people yell at you because you transferred the project to the wrong person. And don't you dare mess with the license, you evil greedy developer! (Greed is ok for the companies that use your stuff, but not ok for the people whose efforts they build on top of.) The whole time people are giving you shit for not solving their particular issue, not to mention the crappy things people say about the `standard` project itself. It's signing up to be treated like a donkey, branded as something virtuous and righteous. No thanks. But somehow feross is the asshole. What a world.
- pkteison 7y agoThis "article" appears to be an ad for a license selling business.
- feross 7y agoI don't know where you get this idea. Just because this essay is hosted on License Zero's blog doesn't make the content less interesting or useful.