4 ms·
I think HN is just generally interested in financial gain and doesn't mind bending ethical guidelines for that cause. I mean, they do have a high incidence of p
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
I think HN is just generally interested in financial gain and doesn't mind bending ethical guidelines for that cause. I mean, they do have a high incidence of people working for tech companies.
- MegaButts 7y agoDo you believe tech companies are inherently less ethical than non-tech companies?
- artursapek 7y agoI wouldn't say HN crowd is significantly greedier/more selfish than other online communities
- ineedasername 7y agoProbably not, though tech industry employees do tend to wave around their "total compensation" numbers in a chest-thumping competition. I see that less as "greedy" though, and more as a mistaken proxy for personal value/competence/etc. The same thing seems to happen in the finance/banking industry. I suppose anywhere you gather very well compensated people in high concentrations it's going to happen. The actual money is only part of the phenomenon.
- ct520 7y agoWell said, never thought about it that way.
- on_and_off 7y agoWould predicting the results of a horse ride count as unethical for you ?
- chillydawg 7y agoIf you win a bet, someone else loses one. Losers lose money to bookies, bookies very rarely lose it on to winners. Many people can enjoy responsible gambling. Many people cannot. Therefore, any time you win a bet, you're winning money from someone who can't stop. In my view it's similar ethically to owning tobacco or alcohol stock.
- derefr 7y ago> Many people can enjoy responsible gambling. Many people cannot. Therefore, any time you win a bet, you're winning money from someone who can't stop. Or, to put it another way: any time you win a bet, you (and the bookie) are helping gambling addicts to take one step closer to "hitting bottom" and thus getting on to the first phase of recovery—acknowledging that you have a problem. (This is the complement to the argument that charity for drug addicts is a bad thing, insofar as it delays the addict longer in the self-harming, not-prioritizing-getting-well phase of addiction. In the gambling addict case, charity would be, in effect, "giving them another pile of chips"—obviously a bad idea, no?)
- jtbayly 7y agoDefinitely not equivalent. Equivalent would be handing the gambler money to buy food when he's gambled away his house and car.
- chongli 7y agoGambling and drug addicts share another unfortunate tendency: they often end up dead. This is the nastiest but most compelling argument in favour of intervention before people hit rock bottom.
- malwrar 7y agoIs this insinuating that winning victimizes gambling addicts? If so, I don’t understand that connection. Gamblers are making a personal choice to bet their money, other gamblers should not be made to bear responsibility if that gambler’s choice turns out to be a poor one. Gambling addicts obviously exist, but they are playing the same game everyone else is. If you want to protect addicts from harming their finances, change the rules to accommodate that goal (betting limits, credit/finance checks, outright banning of gambling) rather than expect other gamblers to follow undefined rules that may or may not protect other gamblers from themselves.
- tinus_hn 7y agoIf the race is predictable betting no longer involves a gamble and could be considered unethical.
- Phillipharryt 7y agoOf all the ethical considerations of betting, not gambling seems like the most peculiar.
- tinus_hn 7y agoWhat if you just consider it cheating if you know the outcome in advance?