7 ms·
A Town for People with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
- strikelaserclaw 7y agodamn, C.F.S is pretty messed up. The weirdest thing is how it seems to happen so suddenly.
- fortran77 7y agoAlso, with any "syndrome" you get a range of people with the symptoms, some with different underlying causes (and some, no doubt, with psychological ones.)
- vimy 7y agoIt's not a syndrome. The scientific name is myalgic encephalomyelitis. There are very specific symptoms you need to have for it to be cfs. Did you even read the article? It clearly states it's not psychological. "For decades, many thought that it was psychosomatic. (My symptoms were so odd that, over the preceding year, I, too, had wondered if I was going crazy.) This sense lingers in popular culture. In the pilot episode of “House,” from 2004, a patient comes to the clinic complaining of C.F.S., and Dr. House successfully treats him with mints from the vending machine. In a standup set in 2007, Ricky Gervais joked about people who say they have C.F.S. because they “don’t feel like going to work.” Today, though, most doctors who study C.F.S. think that its symptoms are caused by a dysfunction of the immune system, which is typically triggered by an infection, such as the Epstein-Barr virus (which causes mono) or viral encephalitis. Still, they don’t understand why, even as most people bounce back from these ailments, a small percentage of them never recover." ... "The dominant theory holds that C.F.S. may not have a single etiology but may instead be a dysfunctional state of the immune system triggered by one of several ailments. Another asserts that C.F.S. is actually an umbrella term for several immune conditions with similar presentations. Ongoing research at Stanford and Columbia focusses on pinpointing the causes of the illness and on developing laboratory tests to diagnose it. But progress remains slow because, though the N.I.H. has now determined that the disease is biological, funding has yet to catch up."
- fortran77 7y agoOf course I read the article. > Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is a complicated disorder characterized by extreme fatigue that can't be explained by any underlying medical condition. https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/about/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/about/index.html and also from the cdc > Symptoms of myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) may appear similar to many other illnesses and there is no test to confirm ME/CFS. This makes ME/CFS difficult to diagnose. The illness can be unpredictable. Symptoms may come and go, or there may be changes in how bad they are over time.
- vimy 7y agoBan me? You would get mad and defensive too if you have been called a nutjob for the last 10 years while you know something is horribly wrong. CFS =/= feeling tired. "The most prominent symptom of chronic fatigue syndrome is an unexplained feeling of fatigue, which is not relieved by rest. This fatigue is severe enough to decrease a person's activity level at home, work or school by 50% or more. In addition, the diagnosis requires that patients should have at least four of the following symptoms that also are present for at least six months: - Impaired concentration or short-term memory, severe enough to affect routine activities at home, work, school or social functions - Sore throat - Enlarged lymph nodes (swollen glands) in the neck or underarm area - Muscle pain - Pain in several joints, with no redness or swelling - Headaches that are different in some way: a new type of headache pain, a new pattern of headaches or headaches that are more severe than before - Sleep that doesn't refresh, or not feeling rested on waking - An extreme reaction to exertion: feeling sick after exercise or strenuous activity, often not starting until the next day People with chronic fatigue syndrome often have other symptoms that are not part of the official definition of the illness, such as nausea and difficulty tolerating alcoholic beverages or medicines that act on the brain. Many people also have allergies, such as hay fever (allergic rhinitis) or recurring sinus problems. About half of people with chronic fatigue syndrome develop depression in the months and years after their illness starts. However, available evidence indicates that chronic fatigue syndrome is not a psychiatric illness. Rather, it appears to be a physical illness that leads to depression in some people." https://www.health.harvard.edu/a_to_z/chronic-fatigue-syndrome-a-to-z https://www.health.harvard.edu/a_to_z/chronic-fatigue-syndro... Edit: I want to apologize to fortran77. My temper got the better of me.
- interpenetrate 7y ago>Peterson had considered the possibility of psychosomatic illness but felt it improbable, because many of the patients were otherwise well-adjusted, with no history of mental instability or trauma. “I’d seen almost all these people for three years when they were well,” he told me. Any psychological theory just “wasn’t right.” in other words, he has no psychological theory. in reality conversion symptoms do not depend on "mental instability" or "trauma" in the popular sense. but of course why would you expect an m.d. to be trained in psychoanalysis? anyone claiming that this is a settled problem and that CFS is an "organic illness" (because the CDC says so) should study the rise and fall of stomach ulcers.
- gowld 7y agoWhat happened to stomach ulcers ?
- staticautomatic 7y agoThere is a strong association between certain psychological disorders and gastrointestinal problems.
- internet_user 7y agoH.Pylori was discovered, and we realized it could be treated with a combo of two-three antibiotics + acid suppressants + ancillary drugs. Totally psychosomatic.
- H_Pylori 7y agoPsychoquacks have no shame. Even when the cause is discovered, and the illness cured, there is still some "psychosomatic aspect to the illness". As far as I know, there's never been a Nobel Prize awarded for someone in the field of psychosomatic medicine.
- interpenetrate 7y agostomach ulcers were an epidemic problem in the western world in the 1970s and have since virtually vanished. in 1982, a bacteria named helicobacter pylori was discovered and was said to cause IBS, cancer, stomach ulcers, and so on. nevermind that two-thirds of the world's population have this bacteria present in their gut (most showing no symptoms). a medication targeting the bacteria was discovered and then the incidence rate for stomach ulcers plummeted dramatically. not the cure rate, the incidence rate: people stopped contracting stomach ulcers in the first place. somehow, the illness no longer served its purpose (!). this is a confounding proposition so most are quick to come up with alternative explanations (maybe pry internet_user, resident M.D.). indeed the medical industries will offer you some explanations if you can't come up with any on your own that explain away any possible psychosocial etiology.
- mafuyu 7y agoI had horrible fatigue a couple years ago; I wonder if it's related to CFS at all. It was utterly bizarre: I had just come off some antibiotics, when I suddenly had no energy to do anything at all. All I could do was lay in bed. I also got walking pneumonia about a month after the symptoms began, and my roommate had the exact same symptoms. A test for mono came back negative. The worst part was that the recovery was slow and gradual. After 6 months, I felt like I could operate as a human being again, and only just this year did I feel like I'm back to normal. I'm chalking it up to it being the first time I was on antibiotics for an extended period of time, plus a run-in with some unfortunate mysterious disease. I honestly have no idea, though.
- thenanyu 7y agoWhich antibiotics? I had a horrific experience with fluoroquinolones, and it put me out of commission for months
- mafuyu 7y agoI was on topical mupirocin and then oral sulfamethoxazole for a couple months, both of which seem relatively pedestrian when it comes to antibiotics. It was my first time taking an oral antibiotic, and it probably nuked my entire gut flora.
- vimy 7y agoYou probably got 'floxed'. Fluoroquinolones are dangerous and should be reserved for life and death situations. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-03267-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-03267-5 Last year the European Medicine Agency put out a warning that the use of fluoroquinolone and quinolone antibiotics should be restricted. I also believe the FDA has slapped a black box warning on this class of antibiotics. https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/medicines/human/referrals/quinolone-fluoroquinolone-containing-medicinal-products https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/medicines/human/referrals/quino...
- cableshaft 7y agoI got 'floxed'. I was prescribed Ciproflaxin from a doctor for a fairly normal infection, who only said it was an antibiotic, with no mention of side effects, and said to take it daily for 30 days. I did look at the box when I picked up the prescription and thought it was really strange that it said "DO NOT EXERCISE WHILE TAKING THIS PRODUCT" and had a looooong list of side effects. I took a single pill and I was feeling neuropathy in my legs for the first time in my life. I kept taking it for eight more days, feeling more and more scared, as the neuropathy got more and more intense and widespread, and eventually called the doctor after I started feeling tingling all over my body and especially my face and felt there's no way that could be normal. They seemed very surprised but said to stop and gave me a different non-quinolone antibiotic instead. I then found the stories, lots of them, online, about people who experienced horrible side effects. A lot of snapped tendons, neuropathy, etc that went on for years after they stopped taking the medicine. And I saw a lot of mentions of deaths from the drug as well, which didn't help matters at all. And I got to join them in that also. I didn't exercise for at least a year afterwards out of paranoia that my achilles tendon would snap like the rest (it already felt sore all the time after that), and thankfully it hasn't so far. But I felt neuropathy often. At first pretty much all the time, but eventually it would go away for a couple of weeks and then come back for a couple of weeks, off and on, off and on. Mostly in my legs and arms, but sometimes I'd feel it in my face again. I went to urgent care to get it checked out a few times over the years and they would always have to rule out diabetes first because that's their assumption whenever they hear neuropathy apparently. I had several tests but they never pinned it down to anything they expected it to be, and didn't bother investigating my repeated mentioning that "Hey, I took Cipro, and this happened right afterwards. I read stories that it does this to people, maybe that could be checked somehow?" I now just tell people I'm allergic to Cipro and I doctors look at me funny and ask how that could be sometimes, surprised that anyone would have bad side effects to it. The neuropathy is mostly gone away now, but I had it off and on for at least 6 years. My right foot has always felt a little screwed up since as well, often sore, it's a lot harder to walk on it for long periods of time now (but I can do it). Considering there were other antibiotics I could have been prescribed and no one seems to be aware that it could have serious side effects, I'm glad the FDA finally started mandating warnings on it, but I still don't think they've raised awareness enough, as no doctor I've talked to seems to be aware of the side effects. Also I am now much, much more skeptical of anything a doctor tells me and make sure I read all side effects of drugs and I don't wait anywhere near as long when I have side effects anymore, even if they're somewhat mild. After reading that article, I'm wondering if maybe I should try to find a doctor who has experience with this and verify that I don't have lingering damage from it that could possibly be addressed.
- JoeyJoJoJunior 7y agoIf you think you suffer from CFS please check out Dr. Howard Schubiner and read his book. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VyH1laOd2M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VyH1laOd2M I suffered from chronic pain symptoms for almost 10 years (was unable play the piano and type on the keyboard) until I realized it was 100% psychosomatic.
- notus 7y agoThe article states that CFS is not psychosomatic and this was a misconception held by physicians previously.
- JoeyJoJoJunior 7y agoThat statement is certainly debatable.
- solresol 7y agoIt is, but keep in mind that there are biological markers that are correlated with having chronic fatigue syndrome at p < 0.001 kind of levels. e.g. if you happen to have blood work from a patient pre-CFS and post-CFS it's very, very common to see a raised T-cell count and an immune response against the Epstein-Barr virus (or some other retrovirus) in the post-CFS that isn't there pre-CFS. Of course, it's not a great diagnostic tool because you need the patient to have had some blood work just before they got sick. But it does make the "it's all just psychosomatic for everyone" argument a bit unlikely.
- cpncrunch 7y agoNone of those biomarkers has been replicated, and stress causes ENV reactivation.
- johnchristopher 7y agoDoes EBV reactivation implies fatigue and full mononucleosis symptoms or it just means T-cells count increases ?
- woodandsteel 7y agoStanford scientists discover biomarker for chronic fatigue syndrome http://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2019/04/biomarker-for-chronic-fatigue-syndrome-identified.html http://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2019/04/biomarker-for-... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19831932 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19831932
- Hydraulix989 7y agoA lot of the symptoms of sleep apnea look like Chronic Fatigue Syndrome on the surface. If you feel tired all of the time no matter how much you sleep, get a sleep study. Sleep apnea is pretty treatable. You don't have to be overweight to have sleep apnea.
- Smaug123 7y agoNo competent doctor should diagnose CFS without a full sleep study to rule out such sleep disorders.
- Hydraulix989 7y agoOne would hope. It took me until early adulthood to get diagnosed with sleep apnea because doctors had repeatedly told me such things as "you can't have sleep apnea if you're not overweight," "you have good grades in school and don't have trouble running 3 miles at track practice, you must not be THAT tired," "every teenager is tired, you just need to improve your sleep schedule," "you need to cut caffeine," and by far the worst -- "you're just depressed, let me put you on Prozac". These are competent/highly trained doctors that aren't in the Bay Area or New York but are in a US tech hub containing a Top 15 medical school. After I insisted on a sleep study, the results came back as me having SEVERE obstructive sleep apnea with 30 cessations of breath per hour (once every 2 minutes) while asleep. You just don't notice it while you're asleep because your body kicks itself out of REM sleep into lighter, less productive sleep but you're not consciously awakened whenever it happens. I even heard the last two ("you just need an earlier bedtime" and "you're depressed") EVEN after showing my doctors the sleep study results with the actual data. Terrible. If you go on /r/sleepapnea, you'll find that these kind of stories are still surprisingly and unfortunately very common. I have jaw surgery at Stanford on the books for early next year to finally fix this.
- DrAwdeOccarim 7y agoWhat an interesting rabbit hole this took me down. So it looks like Ampligen is "Poly I: Poly C12U is designated by the molecular formula, [rI(13):rC(12)rU(1)]n where: n = 46–138", which has now been improved to longer dsRNAs with additional U (https://patents.google.com/patent/US8722874 https://patents.google.com/patent/US8722874). The most interesting thing I've come across is that they dosed it as naked RNA by IV and it is rapidly cleared (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1974294 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1974294). They should try formulating it in a lipid nanoparticle. I bet they'd get some really interesting PK/PD. So the drug turns on RNase L, which basically shreds all RNA in the cell. It's a kill switch for the cell. Kind of like the last ditch effort to stop a viral infection. What's interesting about this drug is that doesn't turn on TLR3 really well because of the U:I mis-matches so it looks like only some cells turn on RNase L. I don't really get that part. The other part if they see increased in NK cells but not Tregs. Again, some cell (maybe APC?) is taking up the oligos from the blood and activating things a little bit, but not enough? That may explain why the clinical results for CFS (for example) were so hit or miss: the clearance kinetics of this type of drug is going to vary wildly from patient to patient. Another weird thing I noticed is that today, the company changed their name to AIM ImmunoTech and just got a twitter account (https://twitter.com/AIMImmuno https://twitter.com/AIMImmuno). Seems like it's tied to the New Yorker article coming out.