3 ms·
Air travel may be one of the last major users of carbon-containing fuels. Perhaps there will be sufficiently little of it that the fuels can all be sourced fro
by pfdietz 7y ago
Air travel may be one of the last major users of carbon-containing fuels. Perhaps there will be sufficiently little of it that the fuels can all be sourced from biomass (upgraded with hydrogen from non-biomass renewable sources).
- dredmorbius 7y agoI've run the numbers on that using one a biofuel crop heralded as "the biggest breakthrough that there is out there". The numbers don't add up. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wo2hl/boeings_biofuel_breakthrough_less_than/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wo2hl/boeings... We use mind-boggling amounts of fuels, and although aviation is a small fraction of the total, a small fraction of a very large number remains a very large number.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe US burns about 60 million tons of jet fuel per year. The US produces about 300 million tons of municipal solid waste per year, 360 million tons of corn, 130 million tons of hay. These are only some of the biomass streams in the US economy. It's not at all out of the question that the entire US jet fuel consumption could be produced with biomass-derived carbonaceous materials. The energy yield could be increased with extra hydrogen input, so carbohydrates could undergo hydrodeoxygenation (as in the Virent process, which can produce a drop-in replacement for current jet fuel). https://www.virent.com/technology/ https://www.virent.com/technology/
- dredmorbius 7y agoRaw biomass != fuel equivalent. There's collection and unification costs as well, and conversion to something suitable for fuels. Aircraft run poorly on cotton fibres. In 1900, the US ran a largely biofuel-powered transportation network, especially for local "last-mile" deliveries, utilising horses, which can eat minimally processed feeds. About a quarter of all grain production went to horse feed, and in fact a segment of opposition to adoption of automobiles were farmers who feared grain demand would fall. Henry Ford looked at an agriculturally-based fuel supply, based on methanol. That might have worked at the time, for a population of roughly 100 million, and widely scattered automobile ownership. It simply doesn't scale now. The Boeing study claimed to be among the biggest breakthroughs in aviation biofuel in years, but fails to pencil out. I ran numbers on numerous other biofuel crops. None, save algael biofuels (which present phenomenal practical issues) pass the basic quantity checks, even for just aviation fuel. Your supplemental hydrogen has to come from somewhere, that's not free. Producing kerosene-equivalent fuels isn't all that much of a problem chemically, the processes are understood. It's scaling the processes.
- pfdietz 7y agoOF course they are not equivalent. But the mass flow through biomass in our economy is so much larger than the mass flow of jet fuel that the objections that it can't scale, and that the numbers don't add up, are spurious. The economy is already handling these large mass flows. All that jet fuel is produced in refineries, for example. Yes, the hydrogen has to come from somewhere. This does not violate any laws of physics or economics.