4 ms·

Clever Hans learned to copy and mirror the expectations of smarter beings. We are not being watched by smarter beings who are constantly giving us feedback, so

Clever Hans learned to copy and mirror the expectations of smarter beings. We are not being watched by smarter beings who are constantly giving us feedback, so there's no analogy there. If we were performing for an audience of super-human intelligences, we would be wise to use all the signal we could from them about what they expected us to do. > Look at the history - it's actually hard to find something that is not biased - false, biased believes are spread throughout the timeline of human kind. Given enough time, our knowledge gets closer towards truth How do you think you know any of that?

mlthoughts2018 7y ago
> “We are not being watched by smarter beings who are constantly giving us feedback, so there's no analogy there.” Parents, family, teachers, community... ???
- inimino 7y ago
  "We," as in the human race. (Remember Clever Hans was a horse, being watched by us.) However, even on an individual level, haven't you ever had a new idea that didn't come from another person but just your own observation and contemplation?
  - jbob2000 7y ago
    The human race watches itself. It creates ideas of supreme beings so that its subjects will mirror and copy behaviours deemed to be "supreme".
    - inimino 7y ago
      And the human race is not smarter than the human race, which is why we are not in a Clever Hans situation. There's no hidden signal, telling us when to stop, that allows us to fool other smarter creatures into thinking we're as smart as they are when we are actually just mimicking them. We're just humans, learning from nature and from other humans, and that's just culture.
      - sooheon 7y ago
        I think it's comparable, it's just that nature is a much more consistent teacher than Hans' handler was.
creditletter 7y ago
Nice one Letters generator services are being use of a huge service where you will be offered to get your own designs for the letters generator. Make it possible and useable for you by visiting here https://creditlettersgenerator.com/ https://creditlettersgenerator.com/

mlthoughts2018 7y ago

> “We are not being watched by smarter beings who are constantly giving us feedback, so there's no analogy there.” Parents, family, teachers, community... ???

inimino 7y ago
"We," as in the human race. (Remember Clever Hans was a horse, being watched by us.) However, even on an individual level, haven't you ever had a new idea that didn't come from another person but just your own observation and contemplation?
- jbob2000 7y ago
  The human race watches itself. It creates ideas of supreme beings so that its subjects will mirror and copy behaviours deemed to be "supreme".
  - inimino 7y ago
    And the human race is not smarter than the human race, which is why we are not in a Clever Hans situation. There's no hidden signal, telling us when to stop, that allows us to fool other smarter creatures into thinking we're as smart as they are when we are actually just mimicking them. We're just humans, learning from nature and from other humans, and that's just culture.
    - sooheon 7y ago
      I think it's comparable, it's just that nature is a much more consistent teacher than Hans' handler was.

creditletter 7y ago

Nice one Letters generator services are being use of a huge service where you will be offered to get your own designs for the letters generator. Make it possible and useable for you by visiting here https://creditlettersgenerator.com/ https://creditlettersgenerator.com/