3 ms·
I guess my definition of open source is that you can read the source so you theoretically know what you're getting or if things don't go the way you want you ca
by bryanrasmussen 7y ago
I guess my definition of open source is that you can read the source so you theoretically know what you're getting or if things don't go the way you want you can figure out why.
This means that open source could theoretically be free as in Mel Gibson shouting but not free as in money found in between the cushions of your couch.
That said I dislike MongoDB but for various other reasons.
- filleduchaos 7y agoAnd so what do you do after "figuring out why" when you're not actually free to modify the software?
- bryanrasmussen 7y agowell often when I read the source of a library (or tool or framework or what term we wish to use), even one that I am free to modify the source of, I will see that the way I thought I was going to solve my problem was not the way to do it and I will need to alter my code not the code of the library. In a few occasions I see that I need to alter the library, if I do not have the rights to do that then I would probably end up dropping the library as being inadequate to the task. In some occasions I have seen that I would like to get rid of the library but I am generally not allowed to by other business decisions, in those cases I have always been able to find some hack that allows me to do what I need to even if it goes against the preconceptions of the used library. I then make extensive comments in my code explaining why, probably referring to the other solutions I would prefer to use and explaining why I was unable to do so. Why? What do you do?
- gwd 7y ago> I guess my definition of open source... Then you've misunderstood what "open source" means. The term "open source" was invented specifically to describe software with the following properties (among others) [1]: ~~~ 1. Free Redistribution The license shall not restrict any party from selling or giving away the software as a component of an aggregate software distribution containing programs from several different sources. The license shall not require a royalty or other fee for such sale. [...] 3. Derived Works The license must allow modifications and derived works, and must allow them to be distributed under the same terms as the license of the original software. ~~~ Any software which doesn't meet those criteria isn't open-source. [1] https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd (edit: formatting)
- bryanrasmussen 7y agothere's a bunch of stuff on HN currently about not believing everything you're told and fake memories and such, but anyway I could swear that this has not always been the exact definition - that this definition, and the referenced site, have sort of taken over the definition and applied an extreme version of the term. I believe this because I also believe there used to be two terms open source, and free, that these were distinct, and that all things that were open source were not necessarily free or vice versa. But it seems to me with the above definition that all things which are open source must then be free although all things that are free still do not need to be open source. on edit: clarified I was referring to HN in first use of the term "site"
- pizza234 7y ago> I could swear that this has not always been the exact definition Following the "paper trail", the chronology is: 1. the "Open Source Definition", last modification in 2007, is based on "The Debian Free Software Guidelines", I suppose v1.1 2. the "Debian Free Software Guidelines" v1.1 was ratified in 2004, and is based on v1.0 3. the "Debian Free Software Guidelines" v1.0 was ratified in 1997 so ultimately, in strict terms (but that's arguable), the "Open Source Definition" is newer.
- xtiansimon 7y agoI’m confused. I believed the story of Open Source software begins in the 50s and 60s when early OS was essentially free, and the beasts software ran on was the profit center. The culture for free open source software (and its benefits) was prevalent. But by the 70s companies we’re changing their attitude about this IP. I’m a reaction to increased restrictions Richard Stallman founded the GNU project in 1983. Is there an Other World theory where this was not the case? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_free_and_open-source_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_free_and_open-sourc...
- bryanrasmussen 7y ago