16 ms·
Hong Kong protestors using Bridgefy's Bluetooth-based mesh network messaging app
- enjoyyourlife 7y agoThis reminds me of FireChat which was heavily used during the 2014 Hong Kong protests
- throwaway1997 7y agoWe tried to use it this year but it got overloaded on the first day.
- rmason 7y agoUsing technology to bring down tyrants. The CIA should do something useful for a change and see this app is distributed to places like North Korea, Zimbabwe, Syria, Myanmar and Iran.
- rolph 7y agothere are a number of mesh apps available they are just not promoted mainstream as they are problematic to monetize and undercut current chat platforms
- rmason 7y agoI know of a few mesh apps. But what's significant about this one is the protesters self selected it. Dictators can cut off social media apps, even cut of Internet access. But they risk turning more people out in the streets if they cut the power.
- rolph 7y agointeresting that mentioning mesh and the problems of adopting it for anything but philanthropism is not considered valid by some. Yes there was a group consensus that a mesh was needed to communicate as a workaround to internet blockades, the only next step now would be to jam whatever the equivalent of 802.11* is over there. I seriously wish them best of luck, thats all i can hope for from here. Cutting the power would be exactly the thing that escalates it from NotMyProblem to now its affecting me
- petre 7y agoThey don't need to jam the signal. It easier to infiltrate agents broadcasting phony messages among the protesters, creating confusion.
- fiblye 7y agoHonest question, but do most people in North Korea have personal smartphones which can connect to outside networks and aren’t completely monitored by the government?
- safsafasf 7y agoYou can block bluetooth. If the Chinese authorities haven't already it's because they see more value in having these kids walking around with personal trackers on their person.
- klingonopera 7y agoIf worst comes to worst, I hope there's satellite connectivity to HK. Or landlines not under Chinese jurisdiction. EDIT: To clarify, I'm concerned about what could happen if China cuts HK off from the Internet.
- dylz 7y agoThere is a decent amount of JP/SG connectivity, iirc.
- busterarm 7y agoSatellite phones are extremely easy to determine point of origin, give or take 20m. That's enough to dispatch police or worse, launch an airstrike.
- petre 7y agoThat's exactly how Dzhokhar Dudayev was killed: using two laser guided missiles while he spoke on sat phone. The signal was interceped by a Russian reconaissance aircraft.
- busterarm 7y agoThis tactic has been used a number of times that I'm aware of, in Eastern Europe, South America and the Middle East.
- klingonopera 7y ago...and not just with satellite phones, a normal phone suffices. A drone will act as a receiver/relay for the phone signal, and then triangulate the phone's location.
- anigbrowl 7y agoSurprising given how easily defeatable it is for anyone sufficiently motivated.
- frisco 7y agoSuper interesting. At Burning Man this year it seemed like a significant percent of the city had goTennas, which had never been true before. I also remember reading about a big mesh in Brooklyn being a thing recently. I bet we’re going to be hearing more about practical mesh networks in the coming years.
- mintplant 7y agoReminds me of Nintendo's PictoChat, a peer-to-peer, physical proximity-based chat application that was built into the DS. I've written about it on here before [0]: > [You could] chat on one of four available channels with nearby users over local wireless, by exchanging text and hand-drawn pictures. > At about the peak of its popularity—right before smartphones became truly prevalent among kids my age—I was doing middle school science fairs. This involved lots of standing around waiting in front of your trifold posterboard while judges slowly worked their way along the rows and rows of other projects. We weren't supposed to leave our own stations in the meantime, and they were spaced out enough to make talking with your neighbors inconvenient. Instead, the whole room was on PictoChat, filling up all four channels with streams of chatter and doodles and mutual commiseration on our anxieties over presenting to the judges. For a company known for perpetually trailing behind its competitors in online services, Nintendo was oddly ahead of its time here (and with the Download Play feature, too: peer-to-peer software distribution and wireless networking!). [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20106929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20106929
- cwyers 7y agoI think a few things hampered Nintendo. Their (laudable) commitment to backwards compatibility led to them getting stuck behind the curve technologically -- the POWER architecture they stuck with from GameCube (when it was a mostly mainstream choice) to WiiU (when it really wasn't) and the older pre-Cortex ARM designs they were using in the 3DS years after Cortex was shipping left Nintendo of the position of not being able to really ride the bulk of the improvements happening in the marketplace. (It's notable that the Switch is an abandonment of hardware-based backwards compatibility in favor of Nvidia internals that wouldn't look out of place in an Android tablet.) And because Nintendo prides themselves on being a family company, in much the way that Disney does, they had less of a tolerance for looking the other way at just how bad other users can be. Microsoft would just throw out an "Online interactions not ESRB rated" warning and moderate the worst of it after the fact when building Xbox Live. I don't think Nintendo ever saw that as an acceptable option.
- hos234 7y agoHow is it safe? I doubt its complicated to figure out which nodes are broadcasting/unicasting the most frequently, without looking at the content if you have cops at every block logging bluetooth traffic. What's interesting is how quickly China has reacted to all this, in terms of pumping massive disinformation onto Twitter/Facebook/Youtube. There have to be upper limits on scaling that capability. And that is where China's weakness lies. The more they scale their Stasi bullshit the more likely we see a Chinese Snowden/Manning sooner or later.
- rmason 7y agoIt's encrypted and the only information it gives up, only when you do a system wide broadcast, is the broadcasters phone number. So the leaders use burner phones and the problem is solved. What's important compared to other apps is that the protesters self selected it. If the US government were to provide some funding the next step would to build higher powered repeaters that can be placed on top of tall buildings. Can you imagine a city wide communication system for pro-Democracy forces in Hong Kong or Teheran?
- dbcurtis 7y ago> the next step would to build higher powered repeaters that can be placed on top of tall buildings. Nice sentiment, but technically counterproductive for mesh networks. Wide coverage nodes create/suffer the “hidden transmitter problem”. Mesh performance degrades overall. Smaller footprint repeaters, and more of them, are a better solution.
- vageli 7y ago> > the next step would to build higher powered repeaters that can be placed on top of tall buildings. > Nice sentiment, but technically counterproductive for mesh networks. Wide coverage nodes create/suffer the “hidden transmitter problem”. Mesh performance degrades overall. Smaller footprint repeaters, and more of them, are a better solution. Could you go into more detail on this/share any readings? As a ham radio operator I have learned this through experience but wonder if there are any papers on this idea.
- aficiomaquinas 7y agoI met the founder, Jorge Ribs, a couple of times. He gave me some of the best advices I've received about Silicon Valley. Great guy. I'm happy it's gaining traction!
- aantix 7y agoWhat was the advice?
- aficiomaquinas 7y agoHe introduced me to the SV culture and compared it with Latin American culture (We're both Latin American). Gave me examples I could relate to and practical advice on how to work with Americans. Introduced me to a couple of lawyers and some other persons. Explained me my options regarding raising venture capital in the Valley (in the end I wasn't ready for raising).
- mrobot 7y agoThe Hong Kongers would never get away with what they are doing to the police in the United States.
- Joakal 7y agoThe Hong Kong government would never get away with what they are doing to the people in the United States. Situation is two sides of a coin. That said, your comment is not adding to the topic of the app.
- cameronbrown 7y agoArguably it's the right of the people to bear arms against tyranny.
- sosoutre 7y agoThat’s why I find it so funny the are waving US flags, along with Pepe the Frog flags. If they tried throwing Molotov cocktails at US cops, the outcome would be very different.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThat's not really a thing. Some far-right groups sent provocateurs and livestream grifters on an all expenses paid trip to HK to cash in on 'anti communist protests' but their efforts fell flat after HKers were advised of their identities.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI should probably have included an example: https://coconuts.co/hongkong/news/not-welcome-far-right-patriot-prayer-leader-turns-up-at-hong-kong-anti-extradition-rally/ https://coconuts.co/hongkong/news/not-welcome-far-right-patr... Gibson has since been indicted for felony riot which can carry a term of up 5 years, incidentally.
- vmlinuz 7y agoA small number of protesters are waving US flags because a) they still, rightly or wrongly, see the US as a bastion of freedom and democracy, and b) they are specifically looking for foreign governments to put pressure on the HK/CCP government not to remove basic human rights from HKers. Also, some US far-right nutters trying to co-opt the protests, thinking they were among anti-commie friends. They were wrong, they are not welcome. Pepe the Frog does not have the far-/alt-right connection here that he does in the US and elsewhere. The image is simply used as something cute and funny. Molotovs... well, very few if any have actually been thrown at the police, rather than at barriers or police stations. There has been a ratcheting of violence, driven almost entirely by the police, and ultimately the government's complete failure to respond or act to massive peaceful protests. I am strongly in favour of the protests, and while I can't say I agree with every action of the frontliners, I cannot condemn then - I know what they're fighting for and against. (Some) US cops are terrible. (Many) Hong Kong cops are brutal and out of control. I don't wish either force on either population.
- imglorp 7y agoDon't they require a state-run app on everyone's phones as part of their social credit system? It should at least know who is using the mesh app if nothing else?
- hkmurakami 7y agoI don't think that applies to HK (yet), which auxiliarily is related to what the protesters are protesting about (separation of legal zones)
- loyukfai 7y agoRight. AFAIK, even in China you're not required to do such except perhaps being a Uyghur in Xinjiang... However, the PRC government is believed to have full access to popular apps like WeChat, among other surveillance tools. If I were to do it, maybe I'd just ask phone makers to install such tools as system or ring-0 apps. Why would I give the people a chance to choose whether to participate in my mass surveillance scheme?
- throwaway1997 7y agoIn the mainland there are only a few messaging apps that work and they are all either unencrypted or backdoored
- bitcurious 7y agoI just tried the app via the US App Store and it requires you to verify through SMS before use. This means that it’s neither anonymous nor fit for use in a disaster zone. Good example of software that would be better if open source.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoI had the same experience and was disappointed. But a good mesh app is inherently difficult to monetize! Combining mesh over some/several form(s) of 802.11, Signal protocol public key distribution "locally" via QR code, and Delay-Tolerant Networking (Cerf et al. 2007) would be the holy grail (and would have no reliance on SMS or phone number) and also could not be monetized. Which is a damn shame, because it's eminently technically feasible, but complicated enough that I'd probably need a professional team to implement.
- mehhh 7y agoCharging businesses to use it would be a path to monetization, hence WhatsApp's partnership with Twilio.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoNot a bad point, but what business prefers a mesh to a centralized messaging system?
- mehhh 7y agoMost businesses do not care about the technical details of the platforms they use. Look at adoption of the PSTN (centralized) & Email (federated and interoperable) among businesses, they migrate to where their customers are most reachable.
- discordance 7y agoBusinesses selling gas masks, helmets and med-kits?
- commandlinefan 7y agoObviously since it’s the only safe option, I can see why the Chinese are using it, but I have to wonder what sort of bandwidth can realistically be supported by any mesh network.
- zawerf 7y agoDoes anyone have good technical resources on how mesh networks work? Who's the authority on the identity of a recipient? Do you exchange something out of band (for example a QR code) first? How do messages get routed? How do messages behave under constant network partitioning and healing? Does it use your GPS location for network topology purposes? etc etc
- rolph 7y agohave a look at these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B.A.T.M.A.N https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B.A.T.M.A.N. https://www.open-mesh.org/projects/open-mesh/wiki https://www.open-mesh.org/projects/open-mesh/wiki https://kb.datto.com/hc/en-us/articles/360024059951-Legacy-Open-Mesh-Open-Mesh-development-information https://kb.datto.com/hc/en-us/articles/360024059951-Legacy-O... http://developer.servalproject.org/dokuwiki/doku.php?id=content:servalmesh:development http://developer.servalproject.org/dokuwiki/doku.php?id=cont... there is also an open mesh for routers if you have the hardware and propensity look at openWRT and find a mesh add on for it find out what routers you have available to flash it onto and then you will have a MESH node.
- thw0rted 7y agoDo you know of any good resources talking about considerations for handling adversarial nodes in these networks? For example, what's to stop a rogue implementation from advertising that it has a low cost / short distance to every other node it's ever seen, reporting that data has been sent successfully that actually wasn't, etc? These links give some good background but I haven't seen anything on there about trust in a hostile environment.
- m-p-3 7y agoI find the idea interesting, but is there some kind of open-source alternative that would be available on F-Droid? This would be extremely useful since you can share your F-Droid archive over bluetooth, and that would also allow the app to be distributed the same way. One less way for the authorities to block the app from being acquired.
- barbs 7y agoPeople have been talking about Briar in another comment thread: https://briarproject.org/how-it-works/ https://briarproject.org/how-it-works/ Seems to be available on F-Droid, but unfortunately is not cross-platform.
- Vinnl 7y agoI think Manyverse is similar, although it too is just Android for now: https://www.manyver.se/ https://www.manyver.se/
- jorgeribs 7y agoHi everybody, I'm Jorge, founder of Bridgefy. Happy to answer any questions!
- rcach001 7y agoHi Jorge, fyi I just browsed for Bridgefy on google and clicked on the first link that showed up and some random page turned up. It looked like it was hacked or something.
- Phobophobia 7y agoCan confirm
- SpliffnCola 7y agoConfirmed here as well.
- vit05 7y agoHere too. The url that I get on google is this one? http://reward0404.websitetrafficgo93.live/?utm_campaign=bKMuT7EMVXU5Z6UvvSHONGlfu-yV43iC8T8uYixAFxs1&t=main9_5a7218f92c536e6c http://reward0404.websitetrafficgo93.live/?utm_campaign=bKMu... The correct url appers to be this https://bridgefy.me/ https://bridgefy.me/
- yaps8 7y agoSame here, glad to know I'm not the only one.
- frittig 7y agoThat happened to me as well. Can anyone explain to me how that works? Is there entire site hacked, but only triggered when coming from Google? Or does it work some other way?
- gzimhelshani 7y agoI'm very confused about this as well...
- dragonsh 7y agoNo closed source mesh networking can be secure. However good user experience it has. They are no different than using WhatsApp. Indeed in that respect at least Signal is better. I am not sure why protestors did not adopt the open source serval mesh project apk and ios app. [1] In Hong Kong given the density of building it's bit hard to have a line of sight, so it will still be hard to build a local network. But it's still possible to build a completely wireless network over the top of the buildings to communicate with each other. This communications can be blocked, but then it will still work if enough people switch on their mobile phone and WiFi router to communicate with each other over peer to peer network which is a combination of wired and wireless. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [1] http://www.servalproject.org/ http://www.servalproject.org/ [2] https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide/ https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide/ [3] https://dat.foundation/ https://dat.foundation/ [4] http://subnodes.org/ http://subnodes.org/ [5] https://hyperboria.net/ https://hyperboria.net/ [6] http://www.servalproject.org/ http://www.servalproject.org/
- cwyers 7y agoBecause Serval isn't in the App Store yet?
- radicalriddler 7y agoI believe that's the point. You need to download the APK or whatever IOS provides for developer packages. This means less tracking from the vendor (Google, Apple)
- Illniyar 7y agoThere is no way to install apps on ios outside the appstore.
- iancarroll 7y agoXcode is able to dynamically generate a development provisioning profile, even if you do not have a (paid) developer account. So side-loading is definitely possible, in some respects.
- hkai 7y agoTo be fair, China doesn't block access to any websites in Hong Kong. In a sense, it's a freer internet than in the US (zero sites blocked, plus piracy is allowed).
- reaperducer 7y agoAt this moment. There was a piece posted to HN last week that Hong Kong's ISPs have been asked, or fear being asked, to implement a firewall similar to China's. Hong Kong's ISP association published a public letter of protest about it. Edit: Found it - https://www.hkispa.org.hk/139-urgent-statement-of-hkispa-on-selective-blocking-of-internet-services.html https://www.hkispa.org.hk/139-urgent-statement-of-hkispa-on-...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- woutr_be 7y agoThat’s not entirely true. Their response came after a lot of outrage and fear by the general population. This outrage came after some top pro-Beijing politicians said that declaring an emergency situation is still on the table, by doing so, it would allow the government to block certain internet services. Pro-Beijing politicians always use harsh language. The same way PLA officers hinted that the PLA could be deployed in HK if requested by the government.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoI don’t know a lot about it but would Signal be safe or even possible to use there?
- stefek99 7y agoNo internet, no Signal. No internet being key here.
- isaack 7y ago@Jorge - is there a way for me to build "relays" out of ESP32/RPi Zero? @HN Crowd - is there something I could do to prepare for possible censorship? I was thinking of mesh Internet over the air, something like DN42 but over wireless links
- alexisread 7y agoYou can do mesh networking with the esp32: https://www.espressif.com/en/products/software/esp-mesh/overview https://www.espressif.com/en/products/software/esp-mesh/over... I think that it might be possible to adjust the app to accommodate the esp32 mesh using the mesh security to identify it. Obv. not had time to look at the details, but you could start with this and the bridgefy SDK? https://medium.com/bridgefy/creating-an-offline-messaging-app-with-the-bridgefy-sdk-3940ee4e8b16 https://medium.com/bridgefy/creating-an-offline-messaging-ap...
- randaouser 7y agoI overcame TDMA problems associated with mesh broadcast networks by moving channel allocation logic into the application layer. For me it was more important for reliable delivery then bandwidth. We use geo spatial TDMA to further allocate the channel, two proximity peers would have vastly different time slots. Unfortunately this leaks location data (though most 2GHz channels will). Besides wifi + bluetooth channels, we have leveraged acoustic channels (more so for unidirectional communication from a watch tower to all peers within an ultrasonic range)
- jonplackett 7y agoHow hard would it be for the secret service to infiltrate this? If messages are being passed back and forth could they intercept, modify etc?
- pgt 7y agoInnovation in radio and communication used to be driven by wars and big government contracts. Now, progress in communication technology is driven by dissent.
- reustle 7y agoIIRC this was built on StartupBus, great to see it still being used
- ukd1 7y agoThe Bridgify ToS are egregious; under "Messaging Content", you grant them irrevocable rights to use your messaging content...
- whoopdedo 7y agoAre there many services that don't ask for this broad scope? I see it often and understand it comes from lawyers studying the business process and writing a contract that enables it within the Kafkaesque copyright laws. They ask for universal copying right because if you spin up a new VM you don't want to have to ask if every message you send to it has permission to be copied to this new instance. And they want it to be irrevocable because you store backups for three years and don't want to have to be constantly scrubbing them for deleted accounts.
- jorgeribs 7y agoThat's exactly why, whoopdedo :)
- secfirstmd 7y agoThey are also using Umbrella App, a free open source app to help protesters learn about and manage digital and physical security. Links: www.secfirst.org iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/umbrella-security/id1453715310 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/umbrella-security/id14537153... Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.secfirst.umbrella https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.secfirst.u...
- stefek99 7y agohttps://genesis.re/comms https://genesis.re/comms - help me grow this guide!
- xtat 7y agoThere are so damn many far superior systems in this thread. We should have gotten together earlier and promoted one of them.
- leegr 7y agoCool