5 ms·
The problem is that I often land on a locked SO question, and it's actually incredibly helpful, leading me to wonder why it was locked in the first place.
by kelnos 7y ago
The problem is that I often land on a locked SO question, and it's actually incredibly helpful, leading me to wonder why it was locked in the first place.
- protomyth 7y agoAs mentat pointed out, it shouldn't be locked.
- kelnos 7y ago"Shouldn't" is irrelevant; I run into plenty that are, and it's a shame.
- shagie 7y agoThe stack overflow model works well for a certain type of question. Part of this is the reaction to the resources of 2008 - trying to find things on page 15 of the a thread in the Java community forums. While there are many possibly helpful questions that could be asked, not all of them are a fit for the format. That was a design choice made on day 1 and is backed deeply into how the software works and the way people interact with it. Still, people asked those questions. The problem is that while they are interesting questions, and everyone wants to answer them - that reduces their value while at the same time putting more work on the community to try to keep it useful. Look at https://stackoverflow.com/questions/9033/hidden-features-of-c https://stackoverflow.com/questions/9033/hidden-features-of-... and consider the challenge of keeping it useful and relevant. If you were to try to add an answer to that post (if it weren't locked and closed), would you read through all 296 answers to make sure you weren't repeating someone else? Some of these questions were recognized as taking more time of the people trying to maintain the site and focus on the questions that it handles well and were locked. The other option would have been to delete them, but stack overflow tends to have a "we don't delete useful content or break the web" philosophy. There are other sites that handle the types of questions that Stack Overflow doesn't handle well quite well themselves. Quora does anecdotes well. Slant.co does comparisons. And so on.
- eitland 7y ago> While there are many possibly helpful questions that could be asked, not all of them are a fit for the format. That was a design choice made on day 1 and is backed deeply into how the software works and the way people interact with it. The issue I and I guess many of us here is talking about is that it seems the Stack Overflow community - or rather a vocal minority in the community I guess - are downvoting and flagging questions that where ok for the format.
- shagie 7y agoFor example?
- Const-me 7y agoExamples: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/56843086 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/56843086 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/57064879 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/57064879 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/57323981 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/57323981
- shagie 7y agoOf those three, only the last one is one that I can view. Consider the original question: https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/57323981/1 https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/57323981/1 which... really is "design an entire system for me" type question. The refinement, while better is still getting into discussions in the comments. While its from a different site on the SE network, consider: Green fields, blue skies, and the white board - what is too broad? -- https://softwareengineering.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/6961/ https://softwareengineering.meta.stackexchange.com/questions... The structure of Stack Overflow wants a question that has a problem that has some code that isn't behaving correctly and can be solved. The list of "any better ways" is without bound or qualification as to what "better" is. That type of question would probably be better suited to a higher density communication medium such as chat or a true forum (with threads). Stack Overflow was intentionally designed to make that type of question hard to answer. Its not that it isn't a good question - just that it isn't a question that fits well into the SO format. That should be ok, there are many other places where such questions can be asked.