4 ms·
Ok, let me put it like this. Gravity seems to have a magic (I don't understand it) way to increase the pressure of stuff by decreasing the volume in which inter
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
Ok, let me put it like this. Gravity seems to have a magic (I don't understand it) way to increase the pressure of stuff by decreasing the volume in which interactions are likely to occur. Fair? Increasing pressure decreases local entropy, since pressures tend to diffuse, not the other way around. To get pressures, we expect outside forces to create them. Pressures don't just statistically happen -- at least, not very strongly. So, gravity seems to create these pressures, and it isn't clear to me how this doesn't violate the second law.
I hope I'm not expressing myself too foolishly, but I really don't understand it. After much effort, I feel like I have a good understanding of entropy, though. Which is what makes gravity so weird to me.
- kgwgk 7y agoI was trying to understand what kind of macrostates and microstates you were thinking of when you said entropy would decrease when the asteroids were closer. Maybe I should try to read one of those papers to see what they are about :-) But you may not be looking at the whole picture. Just because a system occupies a smaller volume doesn’t mean the entropy is lower. In classical thermodynamics a gas can be compressed while keeping the entropy constant (at least in theory). Edit: after a look at the first paper by Verlinde I still don’t know what are the microstates in this theory (they are related to string theory and intentionally left mostly undefined). But in any case your assumption that entropy decreases seems wrong by definition because an entropic force acts in the direction of increasing entropy.