3 ms·
A train going faster than 25mph or so is already too fast for the operator to react (braking distances are huge!), so I doubt that the top speed is limited for
by adrianN 7y ago
A train going faster than 25mph or so is already too fast for the operator to react (braking distances are huge!), so I doubt that the top speed is limited for that reason.
- jdietrich 7y agoThe driver can't usefully brake in response to a person on the track, but they do need to be able to brake in response to a trackside signal. At 140mph, braking distances are greater than sighting distances - by the time you've seen a signal, it's too late to stop. That's catastrophic in a fixed-block signalling system, which can only detect the presence or absence of a train in a particular signalling block; if you end up with two trains in the same block, you've got to run the whole line at a crawl to restore safe separation distances between trains. High speed trains universally use moving-block signalling with in-cab signal indication; rather than relying on fixed trackside signal lights, the signalling system constantly tracks the exact location of each train, creates a virtual signal block around that train and indicates signal aspects and line speeds to the driver on a display in the driving cab. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling#Fixed_block https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling#Fixed_block
- pmyteh 7y agoJust a small nit: almost all high-speed systems still use fixed block signalling, but with in-cab signal indications as you say to give more warning time (and a constant reminder rather than having to spot a signal as it goes by in a flash). Moving block turns out to be much harder to implement than expected; it's included in the European Train Control System's level 3, but even most new installations are of level 2 (fixed block with in-cab signalling).
- TylerE 7y agoJust because the train can’t be stopped doesn’t mean there is no point. Much better to hit something at 50 rather than 70.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoDo not underestimate E=mv^2 ; hitting something at half the speed means quarter of the energy. Case in point: at a speed of 135 km/h, driver sees a bridge falling across the tracks half a km ahead, engages brakes, hits bridge at 90 km/h. By reducing the speed by 1/3, the total energy of the impact was reduced over 50%. There were 6 dead in that crash; without braking, the entire train plus 400 pax would have been blown to bits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Stud%C3%A9nka_train_wreck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Stud%C3%A9nka_train_wreck