10 ms·
It's futile to actually have road-legal cars that go this fast because you can't do very much useful with the speed. This is much too fast for the human operat
by tialaramex 7y ago
It's futile to actually have road-legal cars that go this fast because you can't do very much useful with the speed.
This is much too fast for the human operator (driver) to safely react to things outside the cockpit, which is why for example Britain owns trains capable of 140mph in service but deliberately limits them to 125mph. Tests suggested drivers couldn't be relied on to reliably observe and react to a lineside signal (showing e.g. double amber, "Prepare to find the next signal at: Prepare to find the next signal at: Danger") passed at 140mph. The "obvious" upgrade is to put the signals inside the cab with the driver, and that's how high speed trains work. But a car doesn't have in-cab signals either, and it has a LOT more external signals to respond to, including several signs we see in that video.
- ollie87 7y agoMmmmhmmm, don't really see it as an issue here given that not many folks are going to be buying a £2.5m hypercar to drive at three times the speedlimit to work on a Monday morning.
- mrweasel 7y agoTrue, but that just makes the whole exercise even more pointless. There's really no point in building a car that can go above 150km/h, but perhaps some of the aerodynamics can translate into more fuel efficient car. I'm also slightly annoyed by the usage of the word "barrier". There's physical or perceived 300mph barrier. People have built cars that will go a super sonic speeds, so there was never any doubt that it would be possible. Admittedly it is a little funny that the Bugatti is faster than a Formula 1 car.
- ollie87 7y agoA lot of things humans do are pointless, but all the same we do them. Doesn't stop it being fun does it?
- w56rjrtyu6ru 7y agoBelieve it or not, for some people the pointlessness of an activity greatly ruins the fun of it.
- NeedMoreTea 7y ago0-180 in the same time and hitting a speed limiter is going to be just as much fun for everyone. Unless you happen to have laid out a strip at Bonneville Salt flats. That seems poor justification.
- ollie87 7y agoI'm talking about the challenge, building a car that can do 300mph and then also drive to the shops seems like a really difficult engineering task.
- Tempest1981 7y agoI thought he meant that the design work was fun. The challenge. What is the point/justification of Olympic sports?
- dvdbloc 7y agoI know you are probably just speaking in jest but "faster" is all relative. If you put this Bugatti in an F1 race, it probably wouldn't win. They are both engineered to do their very specific things.
- cs02rm0 7y agoJust to put some numbers to that... at the Nordschliefe in 1974 Lauda dipped under 7 minutes. The original Veyron managed 7:40 in 2005. BMW engineers estimated their 2006 car could lap it in 5:15. Basically, put a few corners in and I don't think it would even be close. There's quite a few cars that can claim a faster top speed than an F1 car though.
- awesomepeter 7y agoGoing around 160km/h on highways in Europe is pretty common, also higher speeds for eg. in Germany
- riffraff 7y ago> Going around 160km/h on highways in Europe is pretty common is it? That is 20-50km/h above the limit in all european countries other than Germany. There are people going that speed, but in my experience across a few countries 99% of the traffic does not go that much above the limit. Sources: https://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/knowledge/speed/speed_limits/current_speed_limit_policies_en#targetText=The%20general%20speed%20limit%20for,urban%20roads%2050%20km%2Fh https://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/knowle.... https://autotraveler.ru/en/spravka/max-speed-limits-in-europe.html https://autotraveler.ru/en/spravka/max-speed-limits-in-europ...
- gambiting 7y agoHave you ever been to Poland? The legal speed limit on the motorway is 140km/h, but 160km/h is more common, especially since there is effectively no fine for going that quickly, police are mostly interested in people going 200km/h+, because the fine for doing 160km/h would be like 100PLN(~$30/£20). I've driven my Mercedes-AMG some time ago through Germany and then through Poland, and yes, on the Autobahn I was able to hit 250-260km/h for maybe 4-5 minutes at the time(legally, which is amazing and I would 10/10 recommend to anyone who likes driving, scary as all hell though), but overal I can guarantee that my average speed was higher in Poland, the traffic is just moving a lot quicker and there's less roadworks compared to the autobahn.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoFrom experience, in France there are stretches of motorway where you would simply fit in the fast lane traffic by going at 160km/h (and yes the speed limit is 130km/h and cars going that speed stay well on the right).
- cs02rm0 7y agoLast statistics I saw showed ~50% of all traffic (which includes vehicles with speed limiters) travel in excess of the 70mph motorway limit in the UK. Personally, I tend to cruise at an indicated 100mph because above that enforcement ratchets up. Which is about 160kph. I certainly think it's fair to describe that as not uncommon. I do similar speeds in France and Germany and am rarely the fastest vehicle around.
- jhrmnn 7y agoUseless does not equal pointless.
- zone411 7y agoIt sounds like you don't know about track days or drag strips. That's the way to enjoy a car that goes faster than 150km/h fully. A 300mph Bugatti is still way above any speed you'd reach, though.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoEven in that case a much lighter (and cheaper!) car like an Atom or Caterham will be a lot more fun than one of these hulking great monstrosities. Often faster as well, depending on the track.
- gambiting 7y agoThat's a matter of taste though - for some people, a smaller, lighter, weaker can is more "fun" than a car that is stupidly fast but only in a straight line. But then there are people who only care about that and that 0-60mph run is what does it for them, not tossing an MX-5 around on a twisty road.
- ehnto 7y agoBugattis aren't meant for motorsport enthusiasts anyway. They are too expensive and complicated to be track day cars and an enthusiast would buy something more driver oriented rather than stats oriented. You could definitely enjoy one on a track if you had one. But you would probably spend more time just enjoying the thought that you own it, keeping it safe, then you would take your actual track car to the track.
- zone411 7y agoYeah, I wrote the same thing in another response. But a few track days per year is a good way to have real fun in a supercar.
- ollie87 7y agoLaunching an Atom or Caterham with big power is incredibly hard for most people, even for those who own them. Not really a drag strip car, more a club circuit vehicle.
- avar 7y ago> There's really no point in building a car that can go above 150km/h. Even if you're "only" going to be driving at 160-180 km/h (as is common e.g. on the German autobahn) you want to be in a car that can do 220-240 km/h. You don't want to be 100% maxing the car out at your cruising speed.
- ollie87 7y agoIt's a 300mph barrier for a road going car you could easily drive to your nearest supermarket if you so wanted.
- arethuza 7y agoI remember reading about a German chap who used a McLaren F1 for a commute on an unlimited section of the autobahn - his average speed was so high McLaren contacted him to check that everything was OK. The F1, in pre-internet days, literally phoned home to McLaren with telemetry. Edit: I think you had to physically plug it into a phone socket... in case anyone was being put off buying an F1 for security/privacy reasons. ;-)
- ollie87 7y agoYeah the F1 had a modem that would phone home and give diagnostic and telemetry data.
- Svip 7y agoThis is why the TGV has no signals. Instead it uses a radio communication system. If no radio signal is received within a time frame, the train will warn the driver, and eventually stop. If a train has to perform an emergency stop, all other trains behind it are informed via the same system. If the driver does not react, the train will stop itself. There is a reason why the TGV has seen no accidents since its launch in 1981. As for a car, yeah, it's mostly a gimmick. Still incredible engineering, though.
- jacquesm 7y agoThe most important reason why the TGV has not had any accidents is actually a really simple one: it only runs on very high quality rails with large turn radii and excellent maintenance of the railbed.
- CptMauli 7y agoAnd even that is not entirely true. The TGV can only run this fast because it runs on tracks where only the TGV is allowed. The rail bed is even not that great, that's why only some ICEs are allowed on TGV routes, because they need a special deflector which is more robust to tolerate the stones which are thrown up in the air when the train drives over it. I think they took this in consideration when they designed the latest iteration of the ICE.
- roelschroeven 7y agoI'm not sure that's entirely correct. If https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_France is to be believed, the high speed lines for TGV are primarily but not exclusively used for TGV: "LGVs are reserved primarily for TGVs. One reason for this is that line capacity is sharply reduced when trains of differing speeds are mixed, ..." "Some stretches of less-used LGV are routinely mixed-traffic, such as the Tours branch ..." "Outside France, LGV-type lines often carry non-TGV intercity traffic, often as a requirement of the initial funding commitments." I'm also not so sure about the quality of the rail bed: "Track alignment is more precise than on normal railway lines, and ballast is in a deeper-than-normal profile, resulting in increased load-bearing capacity and track stability. "
- jlg23 7y ago> It's futile .... But it is fun.
- edejong 7y agoThis got me thinking. Once I thought it was fun, but the more I look at it, the more I feel it is utterly pointless. A racing car has a function: to get around a track faster than other cars (over a period of laps). To do this, it needs to be versatile: turning, braking, acceleration, fuel consumption, range of vision and suspension (among others) play a role. That's the true engineering challenge. It's why it has wheels, not wings. But to simply go fast, seems a bit pointless to me.
- krapp 7y agoThe pointlessness is kind of the point, along with a bit of juvenile thrill. These cars are a display of wealth and excess. You're telling the world you can afford this much power and don't need to worry about things like utility or efficiency, and maybe you'll just keep it in a garage or drive it around a track, but still you can have a car so powerful it's almost illegal and most people can't.
- edejong 7y agoidk... I've always assumed that the pointlessness is in the playfulness: extending our boundaries, setting new rules. We value the daring, the boundless, the discoverers and the challengers. And I understand we connect a certain status to that and I also understand that certain people just want to be able to buy the status without putting in the time, knowledge and risk. But for me at least, this is so remote from and unconnected to the original challenge and thrill, that it becomes idiotic: pointless without even the playfulness.
- krapp 7y agoSome people buy million dollar watches because they appreciate the craftsmanship and quality, some people buy them so you'll know just how much more valuable their time is than yours. It's a status display in either case, given that one could adequately tell the time on a cheap digital Casio.
- adrianN 7y agoA train going faster than 25mph or so is already too fast for the operator to react (braking distances are huge!), so I doubt that the top speed is limited for that reason.
- jdietrich 7y agoThe driver can't usefully brake in response to a person on the track, but they do need to be able to brake in response to a trackside signal. At 140mph, braking distances are greater than sighting distances - by the time you've seen a signal, it's too late to stop. That's catastrophic in a fixed-block signalling system, which can only detect the presence or absence of a train in a particular signalling block; if you end up with two trains in the same block, you've got to run the whole line at a crawl to restore safe separation distances between trains. High speed trains universally use moving-block signalling with in-cab signal indication; rather than relying on fixed trackside signal lights, the signalling system constantly tracks the exact location of each train, creates a virtual signal block around that train and indicates signal aspects and line speeds to the driver on a display in the driving cab. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling#Fixed_block https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling#Fixed_block
- pmyteh 7y agoJust a small nit: almost all high-speed systems still use fixed block signalling, but with in-cab signal indications as you say to give more warning time (and a constant reminder rather than having to spot a signal as it goes by in a flash). Moving block turns out to be much harder to implement than expected; it's included in the European Train Control System's level 3, but even most new installations are of level 2 (fixed block with in-cab signalling).
- TylerE 7y agoJust because the train can’t be stopped doesn’t mean there is no point. Much better to hit something at 50 rather than 70.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoDo not underestimate E=mv^2 ; hitting something at half the speed means quarter of the energy. Case in point: at a speed of 135 km/h, driver sees a bridge falling across the tracks half a km ahead, engages brakes, hits bridge at 90 km/h. By reducing the speed by 1/3, the total energy of the impact was reduced over 50%. There were 6 dead in that crash; without braking, the entire train plus 400 pax would have been blown to bits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Stud%C3%A9nka_train_wreck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Stud%C3%A9nka_train_wreck
- beambot 7y ago> The "obvious" upgrade ... What's stopping the trains from operating autonomously?
- Svip 7y agoDrivers are still a lot better at spotting pedestrians on tracks than autonomous systems. Autonomous train systems already exists, but those are completely enclosed systems, like a city metro system. Not a system where speeds reach 200 km/h, or even 100 km/h.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoModern rail can (and does) run autonomously, at 160 km/h. How-e-ver, it can run autonomously about 90% of the time...and it's far, far more cost-efficient to keep a driver in the cab than to add reliability nines here: detecting and reacting to humans is far harder for machines than for humans (think Elaine Herzberg, but at 160 km/h).
- rurban 7y agoThe ability to spot pedestrians on tracks is something you want to avoid. First you cannot break it anyway that fast. Second, rolling over suicidal pedestrians has a high psychotherapy cost. Driver-less trains not.
- TylerE 7y agoUnions, mostly. The tech is there, especially on a 100% grade separated line like the TGV - no road crossings, and the full length is either fenced, in tunnels, or on bridges.
- pmyteh 7y agoThat's true of attempts to remove the guard, but I don't think it's true of automating the driver. Automatic train operation systems are expensive to design and maintain, and their advantage is mainly in precision: if you're trying to put 30 trains an hour down a segment of tube tunnel, it's very helpful if the system reacts immediately to red signals and brakes at a constant predictable rate. For longer distance services, not only is the cost of fitting ATO equipment to the track much higher (as the routes are much longer), but the schedules don't need such precise operation. It is probably cheaper to retain drivers. In practice, even most metro systems with automatic train control still have someone on the train: it's important in an emergency and if there are degraded conditions or unusual operating needs it's helpful to have someone trained to take over.
- clouddrover 7y ago> It's futile to actually have road-legal cars that go this fast Bugattis are high-end collector's cars. The average Bugatti owner owns 84 cars, 3 jets, and a yacht: https://jalopnik.com/the-average-bugatti-owner-has-three-jets-one-yacht-an-1641143522 https://jalopnik.com/the-average-bugatti-owner-has-three-jet... You buy a Bugatti simply so you can say you have one.
- parsimo2010 7y agoPretty much all modern cars will go faster than is useful and/or safe. Only a small set of public roads allow cars to go their top speed. I have a 1991 Corvette that will go 153 mph, and I've only done it twice. It scares the crap out of me. Top speed is a cool thing to boast about, but most people won't ever see it, and a few stupid people will hurt themselves with it. That's okay on the balance, because millionaires are spending their money and supporting the economy. Buying one of these cars probably funds an engineer's salary and likely a few others supplying materials to Bugatti.
- arethuza 7y agoAlso Bugatti is part of the VW Group - so it's possible that some day the engineering may trickle down to all of the other brands in the group (such as the humble Skodas I've been driving for the last few years).
- 2sk21 7y agoperhaps chassis and suspension may benefit but with rapid electrification impending in the future, even that is of dubious value. A Bugatti is like a piece of jewelry in my opinion - beautiful but of no practical value.
- arethuza 7y agoElectric cars still have chassis and suspension?
- blattimwind 7y agoNo, electric cars are completely different from regular cars. You really have to approach their design from a software-oriented perspective.
- sschueller 7y ago/s
- mytailorisrich 7y agoBugatti and all supercar manufacturers are in the "futile" business.
- Kuinox 7y ago140mph -> 225 km/h 125mph -> 201 km/h When converted I understand the high speed you talk about. The TGV go at 300km/h.
- harperlee 7y agoI rented a car a couple of years ago that read speed signals and kept them in the dashboard for about 30 extra seconds. It was great usability. It only dealt with speed limitations and a couple of other signals, though - if it dealt correctly with “next exit” signs I would never buy a car without that system.
- m0zg 7y agoThe obvious upgrade is to have no operator at all. It boggles the mind that we're seriously talking about self-driving cars on shared roads, and at the same time don't have self-driving trains, and instead allow them to fly off the rails every year due to operator error.
- dalbasal 7y agoEven if it could be operated safely by a person, it still would have no practical value. This is not a transport feat, it's an engineering/brand feat.
- Tempest1981 7y agoI love engineering feats.
- beatgammit 7y agoHow is it not practical? We have race tracks in my area, so if I owned one of these, I'd get a ton of use out of it destroying other people on the track. That's pretty practical from my perspective. It's not going to make my commute any faster, but that's not the only use for cars.
- kenned3 7y ago"destroying other people on the track." this isnt practical. also, tracks have turns and this thing weights like 2 tons so good luck with that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- southerndrift 7y agoIt is not futile. You can drive to a race track and have fun without having to rely on a trailer and another car.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoCorrection: transmitting the track signal to the cab is how high-speed trains worked half a century ago. That's SOP on most modern trains by now, with high-speed rail using moving blocks now (no more physical signals at predefined distances, control system negotiates the safe distance for each train, based on realtime data).
- safgasCVS 7y agoNo one decides to marry their spouse based on how punctual they are. Cars like these (and just sports cars in general) are things you buy with your heart
- Arbalest 7y agoNot like you'd get anywhere any faster when there's traffic around. Punctuality is a sign of planning, and that's a desirable trait, so I don't know about no one.
- dazc 7y agoPeople who are punctual tend to be reliable in general, so maybe it's not a bad idea?
- CPLX 7y ago> No one decides to marry their spouse based on how punctual they are. Not their first spouse at least.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> No one decides to marry their spouse based on how punctual they are Anecdote to the contrary: I've broken off a relationship with someone who was habitually very late, for that reason (and the denial that it was a problem). One of the things that I really like about my current partner is that they are habitually very punctual, or early.
- gcatalfamo 7y agoSometimes, things don't have to really make sense for people to love it.
- toyg 7y agoIt’s futile to have quad-core laptops bought by managers who barely run office apps. But the world of commerce runs on dreams.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoQuad core is entry level now, when did you last buy a laptop :-) Having a laptop with say a 16/32 Ryzen 3 (which believe is due fairly soon) would be pointless
- mcv 7y ago> "Quad core is entry level now, when did you last buy a laptop :-)" It may be entry level, but it's also overkill for what the vast majority of people need their laptop for. But it does help drive demand for advanced in computing power, which helps drive prices down for the computing power engineers need.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoNot sure Engineers are concerned with laptop power that's just a client. There is no such thing as too much IPC, Primary memory, and Backing store - this has been true since WW2 when Colossus was state of the art. There Is such a thing as to little budget :-(
- lazylizard 7y agoBut its mostly people using bloated software that need those fast computers...i just need a shell n ssh client...
- fyfy18 7y agoI wonder how well their next model would sell if it was limited (with no option or upgrade to unlock it) to a maximum of 100mph. I imagine most buyers aren't buying to race it around a track.
- GhostVII 7y agoI mean they obviously aren't doing this with the intention of having people actually take advantage of this speed on the road. The whole point is to build a vehicle which can go these kinds of speeds with the added constraint that you must be able to drive it on the road. Not everything people do or create has to be for purely practical purposes, that would be boring.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoYou don't have to drive road legal cars 300mph on a street. That's why they have streetcar races at racetracks. Also, I'm very much doubting that any Bugatti owner bought because it's in any way a practical purchase.
- skim_milk 7y agoI drive a nice looking car and get asked almost daily how fast it goes or how expensive it is or how much power it has. Bugatti is on point bringing out all the big numbers because that's what all the non-car-guys want to know! Who cares about practicality when you can be the guy that owns the car that makes all the dudes brag to their friends that they spotted a car that can go x miles per hour etc. On the other hand, if I get asked those questions, I have to judge the person asking and do some calculus in my head to determine if I can get away with lying that it goes 200mph or costs 200k despite not even coming close to reaching those numbers. Or respond with another impressive factoid they can go home and brag about when I don't want to reveal my wealth or my lack of it. Bugatti owners don't have that problem!
- exadeci 7y agoEvery improvement made of expensive cars luxury or sports ones were eventually adapted to cheaper cars. The ABS is one of those examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-lock_braking_system#Modern_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-lock_braking_system#Moder... Will their owner often if ever use them at their full potential? Probably not but if they can afford it, who cares? As long as the research can be funded through it.