4 ms·
Gravity is weird. On the face of it, it seems to directly contradict the second law of thermodynamics, that overall entropy in the universe must increase. Entr
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
Gravity is weird. On the face of it, it seems to directly contradict the second law of thermodynamics, that overall entropy in the universe must increase.
Entropy generally involves "spreading out." It eliminates gradients, it doesn't fill them up. It is weird that there is a way to increase overall entropy by bringing diffuse parts together.
Despite the term "entropic gravity", I still don't understand how this or other versions of gravity do not violate the second law. Does anyone here?
- username90 7y agoEntropy is not just about position, but about temperature as well. Objects with higher temperature have higher entropy since you have more options with how velocities are set, hence entropy increases as things gets pulled together by gravity and energy gets spread out among the particles, at least with a classical interpretation of gravity.
- vanderZwan 7y ago> Objects with higher temperature have higher entropy That surely must be a bit too oversimplified, since that would imply that the beginning of the observable universe had more entropy than the current one (given that it was way hotter than the present)
- cgio 7y agoNot necessarily more. It could be the same.
- hvidgaard 7y agoWe know that early universe was low entropy - that is the explanation for the 2nd law of thermodynamics. That is known as the past hypothesis. The laws of physics dictate that the most likely state to come from and go to, is higher entropy because there are vastly more high entropy states than low. That directly violates the 2nd law, but is not unreasonable. Imagine 2 boxes of gas with 10 gas molecules in side A and B. They are separated by a wall with a single small hole in it. Every now and then a gas molecule with go from one side to the other, A to B, without one going the other way. We just went from a high entropy state to a lower entropy state in a closed system. But, coming from a high entropy state does not fit with the world we see, so we're pretty sure that the past hypothesis is true. One of the leading theories about the early universe and how it lead to the world we know today, is inflation. In that theory "stuff" is basically created out of nothing, meaning that the early universe was small, hot, and with (relatively) few particles in a specific configuration. The inflation and reheating dramatically increased the entropy. In other words - there was much less stuff, and it needed to be in a particular configuration to expand into the universe as we know it. That is low entropy. Note: I am not a theoretical physicist, so the above is my layman understanding of the topic.
- gnode 7y agoThis breaks down with negative temperature, where adding temperature to the system decreases its entropy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_temperature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_temperature Additionally, the Big Bang is theorised to have passed through "absolute hot" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_hot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_hot
- dr_dshiv 7y agoSo, I'm thinking about two asteroids in deep space. When they are drawn together in an orbit via gravity, this would seem to lower their entropy (a smaller number of possible microstates required to define their macrostate). So, gravity should produce some tidal forces that would heat them up to a greater extent than the entropy they lose for being brought closer together?
- kgwgk 7y ago> When they are drawn together in an orbit via gravity, this would seem to lower their entropy (a smaller number of possible microstates required to define their macrostate). What do you mean by macrostate? If the macrostate is related to the geometry of the asteroids considered as solid bodies (and the changes in their positions and orientations) I don't see why the entropy would be lower.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoIsn't the relationship between macrostate and microstate the basis for entropy? Like, there can be more possible microstates (positions and momenta) for a given hot macrostate than a cool one. In the case of the asteroids, I guess I'm thinking of number bits required to accurately model the system accurately. Is that an appropriate way to think about it? I see it as lower because fewer cells in a matrix are needed to model the solid bodies...
- kgwgk 7y agoIn the typical example of statistical mechanics, the ideal gas, the macrostate is described with a few variables (say volume, pressure and temperature with PV proportional to T). The microstates correspond to the precise configuration of every gas atom. If we heat the gas at constant volume then the temperature, the pressure and the entropy will increase. You can also increase the entropy by expanding the volume at constant temperature. But I fail to see the analogy with the asteroids. If the microstate is the atomic configuration it doesn’t seem to depend (at least significantly) on the macroscopic description of the position, momentum and angular momentum of the asteroids. The number of bits (?) is not a physical quantity (and why would you need less bits to describe the microstate?).
- sklivvz1971 7y agoWell, think about a star shining, that's a hell of a lot of gravitational energy being turned in to radiation...
- novaRom 7y agoBut it also creates stable long living structures called atoms. Without gravity there will be no elements.
- comboy 7y agoSame can be said about the strong force and electromagnetic interaction. So why gravity would be the one that's weird in the context of the second law?
- opportune 7y agoDo you think gravity is what keeps subatomic particles bound into atoms? Perhaps I am too much of an amateur but to my knowledge that is a gross misunderstanding... that would be the strong nuclear force and electromagnetic force that hold atoms together. Gravity is much too weak at such a small scale
- 317070 7y agoIt is the weak force, strong is what keeps quarks together in subatomic particles like protons/neutrons. But yes, gravity is way too weak at that scale.
- opportune 7y agoAgain I could be wrong, however I thought the strong force holds protons/neutrons together but is also responsible for protons and neutrons being attracted to each other
- 317070 7y agoYou are correct! I learned something again today. There is no thing the weak force keeps together, the strong force does both subatomic particles and quarks.
- knzhou 7y agoMy favorite exposition of this is from this string theorist's blog: http://rantonels.github.io/gravity-entropy-and-life/ http://rantonels.github.io/gravity-entropy-and-life/
- dr_dshiv 7y agoOk, so they are just as confused, that's helpful to know: "You can imagine life without the chemistry, nuclear physics, condensed matter physics we know. You can imagine intelligence made of plasma or computers made of dancing stars in clusters. If you have a powerful enough imagination, every cog in the architecture of life is replaceable. Except for one: gravity. Only gravity can reduce entropy and create complexity where it doesn't already exist. It is, ultimately, the origin of anything worthwhile in the Universe."
- lubesGordi 7y agoGravity does seem to start processes that end up producing entropy though. I think entropy might increase as a result of information production? It's a thought I've been playing with for a while. Like we definitely have maxwells demon adding information to decrease entropy of a system. But I bet if the demon were 'real' it'd be generating more entropy than the information it's producing in its little gas separation experiment.
- goldenkey 7y agoAll the titans of physics, including Albert Einstein, believed in a zero energy universe. Electromagnetism represents positive energy while gravitation represents negative energy. Energy is related to change of state, which brings us to action. Action is measured in J⋅s. The famous Planck's constant, h, is 6.62607015×10−34 J⋅s. Energy = Action / Time = (Energy x Time) / Time = Energy Essentially, a given amount of energy causes a certain amount of state changes per second. Since the total energy of the universe is 0, once the universe reaches equilibrium, it should be back at the Big Bang, with no change to its initial state. If one believes entropy is actually only increasing, probably largely informed by the electromagnetic field, then we should end in the so-called Heat Death instead of the aforementioned Cyclic Universe. A lot of the eventual informing will come from knowing more about the magnitude of expansion of spacetime - its history of values through the past, present, and future. ++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_constant
- evanb 7y agoThe second law requires a generally-covariant extension. The statement is, roughly: in appropriate units, the sum of normal entropy and the area of black hole horizons is non-decreasing. See, for example, https://inspirehep.net/record/91796 https://inspirehep.net/record/91796 and literature surrounding "Generalized Second Law".