7 ms·
Fires Globally Have Declined 25% Since 2003
- dependsontheq 7y agoAn overlooked problem in these kinds of articles is that fires are not a yearly problem. If you have 10 hectares of forest and in the first year 4 hectares burn down and afterwards every year one hectar ... there is no forest after 10 years. So it’s not a “win” that only one hectar got burned. There are several studies that point to possible tipping points where the Amazon as a weather/rain/cloud producing ecological system breaks down if you burn enough of it. Wherever that point may be at the end, we sure as hell are getting there step by step.
- lettergram 7y agoWhich ironically, could make the farmland they are burning the forest down for unusable (as it converts to desert)
- briantakita 7y agoWhat's not reported is recently arable land & "greened" deserts. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YBLZmwlPa8A https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YBLZmwlPa8A There are more meridonal jetstreams meaning changes to regional climate. Some places become deserts & some become green.
- blondie9x 7y agoExactly. One of the reason fires decline is because there is less to burn. Most of the major forests have already been wiped out at spots more susceptible.
- chrisco255 7y agoThis isn't the case, as it says the earth has been greening. This is in no small part due to higher CO2, which stimulates plant growth.
- drivebycomment 7y agoThe same article also contains this: > For the last 35 years, the world has been re-foresting, meaning new tree growth has exceeded deforestation. The area of the Earth covered with forest has increased by an area the size of Texas and Alaska combined. So, at least globally in aggregate, deforestration concern doesn't seem like a unmitigated disaster anymore. Of course, we still need to continue on reforestration / conservation as well as fighting more localized deforestration like in Amazon. But it's not all gloom and doom. EDIT: Deforestration is still a serious concern.
- gridlockd 7y agoReforestation does not replace conservation. Most trees are planted for commercial purposes, which usually means monoculture. These kinds of forest don't support the same species whose habitats have been destroyed. Tropical rainforests in particular are most likely irreplaceable. Having said that, commercial tree planting is still very important to keep demand for wood away from natural forests.
- labawi 7y agoAlso, cutting and possibly burning, even if trees are later planted, usually destroys soil and consequently water cycles. Poor soil with bad water retention means water, even soil runoffs, floods, and consequently water shortages. Commercial wood forests tend to have shallow soil and poor retention.
- aelmeleegy 7y agoFrankly this is a horrible headline. Even if fires have declined since 2003, we should still worry greatly about the Amazon fires. It seems that the argument here is that we need to pick up the pace on fires since they have been declining. As usual, Forbes sticking to sensationalist headlines as opposed to informing ones.
- jamesrcole 7y ago> As usual, Forbes sticking to sensationalist headlines as opposed to informing ones. How is their headline sensationalist? As far as I can tell, it is literally the opposite of how you describe it. I don't see how trying to tell the truth about something can be equated with trying to downplay the situation or encouraging people not to bother about it. You seem to be basically saying "this situation is bad so it is better to mislead people about it (by claiming the severity of the current situation is unprecedented)". Misrepresenting things might seem to have short-term benefits but it's dangerous because it erodes trust in things like the media, and ultimately can harm important causes.
- aelmeleegy 7y agoResponding to the first part, the headline goes "Forget the Amazon hype". It's not hype it's literally fire.
- jamesrcole 7y ago"hype" is referring to the reporting of it in the news and social media, not the fire itself.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThat might well be the justification of it, but there is no mention of "media" or "reporting" in that headline: a headline that does not include in it the supposed subject matter is a poor headline indeed. You need to cough up some pretty extraordinary evidence for the claim that the editor writing that headline would not be aware that it is misleading to leave out the subject entirely.
- andygcook 7y agoWill be honest: Based on the headline, I thought this was an article about declining sales of Amazon’s Fire product line. Obviously the 2003 year should have tipped me off.
- hugh4life 7y agoI have no idea what I'm talking about here, but isn't there more biodiversity that hasn't been fully explored in the Amazon compared to forests in temperate climates? That's what I'm more worried about.
- SiempreViernes 7y ago"Forget about the Syrian civil war hype, the number of violent deaths globally have gone down!" I hope everyone gets the point that you can drown a serious negative trend in a much larger set of unrelated data (how related is the incidence of fires in Ruussia with those in Brazil? I don't know, lets combine them anyway!). I hope I get to live to the point where this sort of sensationalist trash headline isn't the most common type online.
- el_cujo 7y ago>how related is the incidence of fires in Ruussia with those in Brazil? I don't know, lets combine them anyway! If the "hype" the author is crusading against is the idea that the Amazon fire is killing the planet's lungs and will result in an apocalypse or whatever, then isn't it fair to look at incidence of forest fires all over the world? The author is definitely being a contrarian and the headline is clickbait, but a lot of people in this thread are railing against the author saying nobody should care about the Amazon fire and that it's not a big deal, when really he's just arguing that the media is sensationalizing aspects of the ordeal to sell papers/subscriptions/views. You can care about/report on the story without going nuts on headlines saying the world is ending.
- dictum 7y ago> a lot of people in this thread are railing against the author saying nobody should care about the Amazon fire and that it's not a big deal Any newspiece that can have a political angle, regardless of the textual content and the author's intentions, will have its potential political angle explored by other agents. Case in point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20789081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20789081 So it must be read between the lines, even though that can muddy the technical/factual debate. A more sophisticated reading of such a piece must take into account how people will perceive it, and what actions may come from it. Especially in the US (which may not be an exception — I just follow it more closely) a lot of news organizations seem to operate with a "news you can use" viewpoint: these are the facts, here's how to act in face of these facts. Readers are primed to change their minds after being presented with a set of facts. It's akin to overwriting data that should have been appended to existing data[0]. [0]: I'm dealing with data recovery, so this metaphor may be topical to me, but not entirely useful.
- jacknews 7y agoI think this guy is shill and a fraud 'land area of fires' here is not at all the same as 'area of forest destroyed', especially old-growth The 'reforestation' is often plantation. etc. "Hero of the Environment"?
- WhiteNoiz3 7y agoIf fires go down because forests are now developed areas, is that necessarily a good thing? To me that kinda says that we're running out of forests.
- chrisco255 7y agoI mean, people are part of nature too no matter how much they try to escape it. It's entirely subjective as to whether the world should have more or less forests vs savannas vs apartment buildings.
- craftyguy 7y agoThe 'humans are nature, therefore everything humans do is OK' argument is incredibly naive. Humans need to eat, for example, and there are complex global systems that our food supply depends on (e.g. pollinators), and that we do not fully understand. Turning all forests into apartment buildings is a great way to crash these global systems that we depend on to live.
- chrisco255 7y agoNaturally, but our population is kept in check by the same laws that govern nature, just as you say, we can't mow it all down. And that's part of the reason the population growth is slowing.
- jacobush 7y agoAre we running up against a wall, famine is forcing the population down? Rather the growth is slowing because we have it pretty OK, don't you think?
- sgt101 7y agoIt depends on your beliefs. I believe that people should have genuine freedom, and that requires that they have agency, if all types of environment apart from urban landscapes are destroyed then no one will have any choice about how they live - or what they experience - for the rest of time. I rate that as a massive crime. If you don't believe in freedom or the rights of our children, and their children then I expect you disagree with me.
- carapace 7y agoThe article linked from the OP: "Researchers Detect a Global Drop in Fires" https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/90493/researchers-detect-a-global-drop-in-fires https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/90493/researchers-d... > Across the grasslands of Asia, the tropical forests of South America, and the savannas of Africa, shifting livelihoods are leading to a significant decline in burned area. Using NASA satellites to detect fires and burn scars from space, researchers have found that an ongoing transition from nomadic cultures to settled lifestyles and intensifying agriculture has led to a steep drop in the use of fire for land clearing and an overall drop in natural and human-caused fires worldwide. > Globally, the total acreage burned by fires declined 24 percent between 1998 and 2015, according to a new paper published in Science. Scientists determined that the decline in burned area was greatest in savannas and grasslands, where fires are essential for maintaining healthy ecosystems and habitat conservation. > The map above, based on data from the international research team, shows annual trends in burned area over the study period. Blues represent areas where the trend was toward less burning, whether natural or human-caused, while red areas had more burning. The line plot shows the annual fluctuations in global burned area and the overall downward trend. The research team, led by Niels Andela of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, analyzed fire data derived from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MODIS) instruments on NASA’s Terra and Aqua satellites. They then compared these data sets with regional and global trends in agriculture and socio-economic development. I'm a doom-and-gloom type myself, but this seems like good news, eh?
- jacknews 7y ago"I'm a doom-and-gloom type myself, but this seems like good news, eh?" uh, not sure about that: "Scientists determined that the decline in burned area was greatest in savannas and grasslands, where fires are essential for maintaining healthy ecosystems and habitat conservation."
- carapace 7y agoYou're right, that's ambiguous at best. Is it a decline in "bad" fire or "good" fire or both or something else?
- gridlockd 7y agoThe article is completely misleading, it's not forest fires that have gone down, it's fires in general[1]. In this case, urbanization has caused less fires set for agricultural purposes, particularly in savanna regions. What you do is set a fire to get rid of all the shrubs. Afterwards, grass quickly grows, supporting grazing animals. It's been done for thousands of years. This kind of fire also occurs naturally and is actually healthy for the ecosystem. It's funny how the article uses this development that is actually negative (at least for the local flora/fauna) and spins it into a positive. Most people read it as "forest fires have gone down", when the opposite is true[2]. [1] https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/90493/researchers-detect-a-global-drop-in-fires https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/90493/researchers-d... [2] https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-global-warming-has-increased-us-wildfires https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-global-warming-has...
- labawi 7y ago> Cole claimed that, as a result of burning fossil fuels, "the oxygen content of the atmosphere must start to decrease." > That claim was incorrect and debunked as early as 1970 by climatologist Wallace S. Broecker writing for Science in June 1970. Broecker in 1970 article[1] explains that a slight decrease in O₂ concentration is a definitely a non-concern compared to increase in CO₂, yet, unlike the article claims, still projects about 0.2% decrease of atmospheric O₂ for 1970-2000 period. This is what I don't like about debunking articles. If debunking, at least they should get their facts straight. [1] https://science.sciencemag.org/content/168/3939/1537 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/168/3939/1537
- jacknews 7y agoMichael Shellenberger’s sloppy Forbes diatribe deceives on Amazon fires (commentary) https://news.mongabay.com/2019/08/michael-shellenbergers-sloppy-forbes-diatribe-on-amazon-fires-commentary/ https://news.mongabay.com/2019/08/michael-shellenbergers-slo...