3 ms·
I have heard your arguments many times from people and understand them (after 10 years of discussion). At some point I espoused them myself. I have the followi
by EGreg 7y ago
I have heard your arguments many times from people and understand them (after 10 years of discussion). At some point I espoused them myself.
I have the following points to make (consider them questions you can answer in detail if you want).
1. Who enforces “no force allowed”? For example in the international markets for labor, currency, and other goods, there is no world police or monopoly on force through a one world government. Sure, countries can have armies. And the same on the individual level - how do you prevent marauders from using force unless you join into an entity with even larger defensive force? That entity will enforce “no force allowed” with force of its own. So even on its own terms, your “free market” system requirement requires a monopoly of force.
2. What if the “sound money” tends to be very expensive to move? Then banks tend to issue representative money or debt denominated in the “sound money” and that is what’s traded every day. It also has the advantage of being reversible so you don’t, for example, have people kidnapped for Bitcoin ransoms. Our current monetary system is largely “seller beware”, instead of “buyer beware”. Presumably, sellers of consumer goods are far larger organizations than buyers, and engage in far more transactions in a given product, and thus can better absorb the cost and quality control to minimize chargebacks and disputes etc.
3. If something is going up in price over time, people want to hoard it not spend it. On the other hand if something is gradually decreasing in price, people want to spend it. These are two sides of the same coin (pun intended). A deflationary currency would NOT be the one that’s actually being spent day to day, but only to occasionally settle debts from everyday transactions. So it depends what you mean by “used” but in terms of frequency, the more “sound” the money is, the LESS FREQUENTLY it is used. For each person who is willing to accept it, there is a person who doesn’t want to give it. Because in practice, the buyer will choose from among all possible payment options the seller offers, and choose the “worst money” to get rid of first. And sellers will compete in a race for who will accept the widest forms of payment (credit cards, venmo, whatsapp or whatever) to get more business.
In Capitalism, sellers are always in a race to the bottom unless there is a monopoly. It’s great for consumers but they are also the ones who get to choose among payment options and thus the WORST MONEY will be more frequently in consumer transactions (for goods and services).
- javert 7y ago1. A free market requires that the government exercise a monopoly on force, using force. Only the government should be allowed to use force and it should be minimized. International politics will always be a state of nature but treaties and free trade agreements can be good. 2. If the sound money is very expensive to move, people will issue bank notes. I think you are right about that. However, if there are two equally good monies, except that one can be used directly instead of using an intermediary layer (like bank notes), the one that can be used directly will win out in the market and the other one will disappear from use. Because it's less risky when there is no intermediary layer. Then again, there may be use cases when you want reversibility, and then people would use an intermediary (like PayPal). Going through an intermediary some of the time doesn't really create a different currency. For instance, Tethers (which are nominally worth 1 US dollar each) aren't really a different currency (although that's not an ideal example since Tether is so shady; perhaps Gemini Dollars is better). 3. Imagine you have Greatcoin and Shitcoin and those are the two currencies. Merchants take Shitcoin but they immediately convert it to Greatcoin (which holds its value better, or perhaps is deflationary). Consumers don't want Shitcoin, so they also immediately convert it to Greatcoin. Everybody wants Greatcoin in their bank account/digital wallet; nobody wants Shitcoin. I think you can see where this is going. Next time I go to the merchant and try to pay with Shitcoin he's going to say "Come on man, I don't want that shit. Just keep all your money in Greatcoin, which you want to do anyway, and don't convert to Shitcoin before you pay me, and I won't have to convert your Shitcoin to Greatcoin." Then Shitcoin goes away.
- EGreg 7y ago1. OK so in your definition, a free market requires a monopoly on force, using force. In mine, a free market has NO monopoly on force, so international markets are an example. And I compare them with markets that have government intervening, like public stock markets. How are they better? 2 and 3. Well what if the seller says "Come on man, I don't want that shit" and the buyer says "Well your competitor will take my shitcoin, so I'm going to buy from them?" You're only looking at possible trends in one direction, namely sellers "winning" the argument with buyers and phasing out acceptance of shitcoin. But why did they accept shitcoin in the first place? Why accept Visa, WeChat or a check when you have to trust a third party bank, rather than just cash? Because it's more convenient for the buyer. If sellers provide various options, the buyers will choose the ones they want to use. Do you think sellers LIKE to deal with VISA chargebacks disputes and other crap, when they can just take your cash and say kthanxbai? In Capitalism, the pressure is on the sellers to accomodate buyers, so what about the other way ... buyers want to get rid of shitcoins? Not to mention that the government will want to do UBI or single payer programs like SNAP food stamps or medical insurance and guess what, most doctors will prefer to take that instead of ONLY accepting direct payments. And even when they accept direct payments they are OK with VISA and paying 3% transaction fee. Why? Because many buyers have trouble paying cash at the moment, but the government or a bank has supplied them with shitcoin money. And that's my point ... a lot of economic activity can get done that way, and both sellers and buyers prefer it. And sellers accommodate buyers because often the buyers don't have any other type of payment. They've paid into their insurance. Do you think doctors LIKE to negotiate with insurance companies? But they would rather get that, than lose a customer.