3 ms·
There are several projects that have tried to use LLVM as a direct backend for higher-level languages, and not many have gone well. - Rubinius - Ruby JIT on LL
by chrisseaton 7y ago
There are several projects that have tried to use LLVM as a direct backend for higher-level languages, and not many have gone well.
- Rubinius - Ruby JIT on LLVM, often slower than the standard interpreter (!!)
- Pyston - Python JIT by Dropbox, abandoned because it wasn't going anywhere
- FTL - JavaScript backend by Mozilla, they're now doing their own thing with BBB and abandoned LLVM because it wasn't working out
The only ones that have worked well, like Falcon (Java backend by Azul), have major IR and passes in front of them and use LLVM like a portable assembler, but as you say that's not ideal anyway.
You can't just dump your language into LLVM and expect it to work miracles, but people keep trying again and again and again.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 7y ago* Crystal * R * Julia * MATLAB * Mathematica * Swift Use LLVM as their backend.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThese are just more examples of exactly what I mean! - Crystal is Ruby simplified in order to make it amenable to compilation by LLVM. They couldn't move LLVM to the language, so they had to move the language to LLVM. - R's performance is very limited. - Julia was specifically designed to be easy to compile. - Swift has SIL - they don't just output LLVM. See what they say about LLVM! https://llvm.org/devmtg/2015-10/slides/GroffLattner-SILHighLevelIR.pdf https://llvm.org/devmtg/2015-10/slides/GroffLattner-SILHighL... 'Wide abstraction gap between source and LLVM IR', 'IR isn't suitable for source-level analysis', etc. And they have these problems even with the best LLVM experts on their team! I don't know much about MATLAB or Mathematica, sorry.
- comex 7y agoEven Clang would greatly benefit from an intermediate IR between the C/C++ AST and LLVM IR; the presentation you linked starts off by going over that (and I can confirm that it’s still a problem). That doesn’t mean that LLVM or its IR is bad, or that C or C++ are not suited to being compiled to it. It just means that some analyses and optimizations are best done at a higher level.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> It just means that some analyses and optimizations are best done at a higher level. Yes that’s my point - you can’t just emit LLVM and cross your fingers. But people keep on trying.
- swsieber 7y agoRust as well. Notably not on this list and known for fast compile times: * Nim * Go
- chrisseaton 7y agoNo, Rust has MIR, and Go is a relatively simple to compile language that maps to LLVM pretty directly. I don't know about Nim, sorry.
- swsieber 7y agoAh, I missed "directly" in you original comment. Yeah, rust has a couple of layers.