4 ms·
Agreed. More broadly, decentralization is less equipped to counteract bad actors. You really are on your own, but isn't that what you asked for when you wanted
by zelly 7y ago
Agreed. More broadly, decentralization is less equipped to counteract bad actors. You really are on your own, but isn't that what you asked for when you wanted to abandon Facebook/Google/government.
A decentralized network cannot be trusted by nature. Anyone can join and lie. Successful decentralized networks need some cryptographically-secure checksum to verify its inputs: BitTorrent uses SHA-1; Bitcoin uses Merkle trees. The network participants are just dumb mirrors to provide redundancy and compute. This solves the problem of the integrity of the information, but there is no such analogue for verifying the behavior of humans using the network. For example, you can download a valid BitTorrent file that is also a trojan (virus databases are centralized), or you could send Bitcoin to a Nigerian prince (third-party escrow layers are centralized). There is no algorithm to make sure what you're doing is ethical.
Imagine running reCAPTCHA as a decentralized service that runs on random people's machines. Impossible.
There is no way to flip a switch and change everything from centralized to decentralized without making major sacrifices. No one wants to go back to the dial-up era. Much of the lauded results of the internet are actually a result of its centralization.
- bjornjaja 7y agoThe dialup era makes more sense actually—services are designed more bandwidth-conscious and ad networks don’t masquerade on every website in existence. As for streaming media, well people consume too much media to begin with so less is more.
- tpxl 7y agoDecentralized networks lend themselves to far better moderation than centralized. Private forums have always had better moderation than something like reddit. Well, not all, but you can ignore those ;)
- perl4ever 7y agoUsenet?
- yarg 7y agoBitTorrent uses SHA1 only? That seems deeply flawed. Edit: https://www.quora.com/Does-bittorrent-support-SHA-2-256-512-or-future-SHA-3 https://www.quora.com/Does-bittorrent-support-SHA-2-256-512-...