4 ms·
This criterion is ridiculously out of touch with reality. I just hired some people to trim my trees. I told them exactly which trees to trim, in some cases, w
by lisper 7y ago
This criterion is ridiculously out of touch with reality. I just hired some people to trim my trees. I told them exactly which trees to trim, in some cases, which specific limbs to cut off. That doesn't make the tree-trimmers my employees.
- pwagland 7y agoThe difference is that you are not "hiring" the tree trimmer 5 days a week, 52 weeks of the year. They have many "employers", and so are independent of all of them. An Uber/Lyft driver does not have many "employers", they only have 1/2, plus maybe their own other job.
- lisper 7y ago> The difference is that you are not "hiring" the tree trimmer 5 days a week, 52 weeks of the year. Sure. But that's not what the text says. And BTW, the amount of time that an Uber/Lyft driver works is entirely up to them. They can work one day, take a month off, and then come back and work another day. Any Uber/Lyft driver who works 5 days a week, 52 weeks a year, is doing so because they choose to, not because they fear being fired if they don't.
- SerLava 7y agoI mean, if you hired them to trim specific trees for other people... every day... for years...
- tyingq 7y agoPerhaps it's that you didn't specify the exact tools, methods, and timeframe. That's probably where Uber and Lyft are at risk. I agree that the rules don't consider the current reality of tools and global connectivity.
- abruzzi 7y agoPerhaps the difference is you told the group of workers “I want trees A and B trimmed in this way”, but you probably weren’t saying “Tom, I want you to trim tree A, Dick, I want you to trim tree B, and Harry, I want you on the ground passing tools up to Tom and Dick as needed.” Your example sounds exactly like a statement of work in a contract. My example reaches past that into the company to manage their use of labor. This doesn’t necessarily apply directly to Uber because they may argue that they are contracting a single ride, and the driver/contractor is fulfilling that small contract in any way they see fit.
- vageli 7y ago> This criterion is ridiculously out of touch with reality. I just hired some people to trim my trees. I told them exactly which trees to trim, in some cases, which specific limbs to cut off. That doesn't make the tree-trimmers my employees. But this legal notion has multiple criteria, all of which need satisfaction to arrive at a conclusion. Cherry picking a single criterion in this instance makes no sense unless you apply all to your metaphor.
- codingdave 7y agoHaving authority over the details of the specific job they are doing for you does not mean you are directing the rest of their business, nor the details of their other projects for other clients, so this is not an accurate comparison.
- SllX 7y agoIt’s more like they agreed to take the job of cutting these trees in a way that you would like for an agreed upon amount of money and then left. They don’t work for you, they did some work for you, but they didn’t have to, and they wouldn’t have gotten paid or been entitled to any compensation if they hadn’t. They would have been liable if they had killed your trees in the process. I think where we’re splitting hairs is whether the drivers have a direct relationship with Uber and Lyft that entitles them to the rights of a W-2 employee, or whether they are actually working for the passengers and are therefore 1099 workers merely using Uber and Lyft as a platform to find work. You see, there’s a decent case for the latter, it’s what they predicated their original business model on, but given the amount of control that Uber and Lyft does exercise on the drivers, I think that pushes them into W-2 territory. Drivers can’t even set their own rates for which they will take a job for example, Lyft and Uber hands the fee scheduling down from on high. The choice is binary, work for Uber or Lyft, or don’t work for Uber or Lyft. There was an interesting but failed startup called Sidecar I think it was. Never got to use it, but the description I received was you put in your pickup and drop off points and the amount you would like to pay, and then it broadcasts this fare out to potential drivers that happen to be available. They see it, and decide if they want to take the fare or not. If Sidecar were still around, I think they would have a much easier time proving their case that their employees are 1099 contractors, not W-2 employees. EDIT: Some additional thoughts I had after posting this. As a customer paying for a ride, are you paying to call a Lyft or an Uber? Or are you paying to call a driver. Lyft gives me no options to call upon specific drivers that might be available, or to eliminate certain makes of car that I dislike (damn Prius C drivers), and penalizes me if I cancel. When I’m calling a car, it certainly feels like my relationship is with Lyft the company, not the guy who eventually picks me up. I have no idea who that will be.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]