5 ms·
There's definitely some nefarious parts here. Namely, that most RCS compatible carriers are using Google's cloud service to operate it, as far as I am aware, an
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
There's definitely some nefarious parts here. Namely, that most RCS compatible carriers are using Google's cloud service to operate it, as far as I am aware, and its likely Google rolling out RCS without carriers in some instances is a bid to pressure them into it.
Furthermore, the strategy of implementing messaging through carriers came after all of their repeated failures to convince the public to use their chat apps, and having the carriers push the feature instead removes user agency. It's a way to force us to message with Google after we've repeatedly rejected them.
As per usual, Google is claiming to develop something in the open as a standard, but it's designed chiefly to bring everything under their roof.
RCS is kinda like AMP for text messaging.
- sverige 7y ago"Those who have adopted the system most fervently, such as Vodafone in the UK, have done so because they see the opportunity to monetise smarter messaging" Everything I need to know about why I don't want RCS is contained in this simple statement.
- kyrra 7y ago(googler, opinions are my own) Disagree. RCS is most definitely an open standard that Google has bought onto in the last few years. The standard itself is 20 years old at this point I think. The problem was that carriers could not agree on a set of features to implement, which made all of the various implementations non-compatible. Google bought Jibe that was working on a standard implementation that carriers could roll out. The biggest thing really that Google has been pushing for with the GSMA is the universal profile, which defined a set of features that all carriers would implement. We are now at the spot where universal profile has mostly been agreed upon. Carriers can implement their own version, get a self-hosted version of Jibe, or let Google host the RCS system. The last option is the easiest for carriers to do, but obviously puts Google in the middle. The nice thing about RCS is that it is a standard. Google could totally walk away from it, and all the carriers and phone makers could still use it. You can't say that about any other chat app out there (maybe matrix would be the only one).
- ulfw 7y ago> Google could totally walk away from it, and all the carriers and phone makers could still use it. Not exactly unlikely...
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoThis is getting boring. Which products that Google has given an SLA on have they dropped without transitioning users and against SLA? Not prototypes or random free experiments but actual products?
- reaperducer 7y agoWhy the SLA qualifier? That's like saying, "Go ahead and name one Google product with an owl in its logo that got randomly dropped. You can't. That means Google is stable."
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoBecause otherwise it is deeply pointless to complain about a company dropping prototypes. The SLA tells you they are planning to support it. Anything else is just you using a free prototype.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoSure. So the take-away is still, whatever you don't sign an SLA for with Google is liable to disappear on short notice. Including Google's interest in RCS.
- littlestymaar 7y agoGoogle reader wasn't an experiment, it was an 8 years old product with millions if users, and it was closed with just a little bit more than 3 months notice. Which is a ridiculously short notice…
- 7y ago
- darkerside 7y agoGoogle is basically the new Microsoft but with better PR
- jacquesm 7y agoIt's worse because the damage that MS could do was to some extent limited. Google can do a great deal of damage and in fact is already doing so on an individual level.
- krzyk 7y ago... and worse (legendary bad) customer support. On a scale from bad to good customer support, Google is on the far left and Amazon on far right - from my (paying) customer point of view.
- yowlingcat 7y agoIn my experience with AWS Amazon's paid support isn't always great, but they at least try to give you something to pay for so you can get what you pay for. This is in stark contrast to Google.