3 ms·
Syncthing is peer to peer replication, you don't need a server online 24/7, you just might choose to if you have a small number of devices and you want changes
by OJFord 7y ago
Syncthing is peer to peer replication, you don't need a server online 24/7, you just might choose to if you have a small number of devices and you want changes to replicate immediately, not hours later or whenever two devices are online at the same time.
- acdha 7y agoThat’s a huge caveat: most people do not have multiple computers and even if you do, it leaves a lot of room for data loss if you have to go wake your desktop up before your laptop’s data is safe.
- OJFord 7y agoI said 'devices' not 'computers' - a popular use case is synchronising phone photos to a computer. If you only have a single device you're probably not in the market for a cross-device file synchronisation program! (Like Dropbox, it's not really a backup tool - bad data will be replicated just like good data. Also like Dropbox it does have versioning, but that's still not really a replacement for regular snapshotting IMO.)
- acdha 7y agoMy point was that for most people, a sync limited to unused space on an inconsistently available device is not a replacement for a cloud service. In the scenario you mentioned, your phone is likely not to lose too much data as long as you use your laptop nearby frequently but the reverse isn’t true unless you have only a modest amount of data which fits on the phone. It also leaves you far more exposed to correlated failures since the same compromise, flood, mugger, etc. is likely to get both devices. (Malware is also why I really like Dropbox’s minimum retention period since it breaks the ransomware model)
- pizza234 7y agoYou don't stricly need a server 24/7, but you need the peers with changes to be connected at the same time, which is inconvenient (that's why a server 24/7 is ultimately needed). If one applies changes on a machine, then switch to another, they must ensure to leave them on for a brief time to allow syncing, then turn off the previous one. If they don't do this, they'll (likely) get conflicts. If one's requirement is not to entrust a 3rd party with one's own data, of course, cloud/proprietary solutions are excluded, but to expect open/local solution to be as convenient as the former, is just false.
- OJFord 7y agoIt completely depends on use case, you're only going to get conflicts if you modify the same files on different devices before they've had time to sync. If you're using it to collate photos from different sources for example, that's fine. If you're trying to collaborate on a document, yes, of course, it's the wrong tool.