2 ms·
Is it an advertisement? Yes, or no? If not, what is it? (Lots of advertisements contain/are jokes.) And -- hah! You know how many papers there are which used
by eesmith 7y ago
Is it an advertisement? Yes, or no?
If not, what is it?
(Lots of advertisements contain/are jokes.)
And -- hah! You know how many papers there are which used software X, Y, and Z, all with cite-able references, and where the authors did NOT cite the software?
I mean, last year I was at a conference, talking to a vendor, who complained about academics, using their software under an academic license which clearly requires that the vendor be cited for any publications, who omit citing their work.
I have never heard of any scientific project which got in trouble for omitting a reference for an non-scientific software component like GNU parallel - and I can't think of any which have gotten into trouble for omitting a reference to a scientific software component they use.
At best it would be described as an oversight, and if the journal really is that strict (can you point to one?), resolved with a correction. It's certainly not a threat to the project.
But, let's suppose it is an issue.
Shouldn't more software components be doing this?