3 ms·
I’ve never understood why we need to find a gene to explain people’s gender sexual preference. No one looks for a gene to determine why some men like short wome
by scarface74 7y ago
I’ve never understood why we need to find a gene to explain people’s gender sexual preference. No one looks for a gene to determine why some men like short women with big butts and other men like skinny women.
- ummonk 7y agoA lot of those preferences tend to be subject to high erotic plasticity though. Sexual orientation, particularly in men, much less so.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is why I read HN. This led me down an interesting rabbit hole including the Wikipedia entry on “erotic plasticity”.
- matt-attack 7y agoBecause it’s so much more than just sexual attraction.
- scarface74 7y agoExplain? Besides societal stereotypes of how “gay people act” how is sexual preference anything but who you are attracted to?
- averros 7y agoBecause if homosexual behavior is genetically-determined (or inalterably biologically determined) the gays can argue that they are being discriminated for what they ARE, rather than for what they CHOSE to be. There's a large number of laws which prohibit voluntary behavior of one sort or another even if there are no direct victims (drug use would be one example) so the proponents of restricting homosexuality would have it easier to argue that there's an overriding societal concern which justifies this voluntary behavior. (The existence of laws creating "victimless crimes" is an accepted part of modern legal systems, sadly, but no one other than hard-core libertarians actually oppose the concept.)
- scarface74 7y agoIf we use that as a reason, shouldn’t we study why some people are attracted to people of another race since there are many religious people who still think interracial marriage is wrong and it was illegal in certain states as late as the 60s. We decided as a society to ignore those people because they were wrong. We shouldn’t need “studies” to get the hell out of people’s bedroom. Slowly we are changing as society. But studies won’t convince people who believe that not only are “the gays” going to hell but they are the cause of all of society’s ills and natural disasters.
- averros 7y agoWell, once there's a concept that a society should have laws restricting behaviors which don't actively hurt other people or their property (drug laws, morality laws like anti-gay, hate speech laws, anti-discrimination laws, etc) in the "interests of the society" (as defined by the politically more powerful groups), then it's very hard to argue against this kind of laws being applied against some minority groups (after all, democracy is the rule of majority). The only logically consistent way to deal with these issues is to drop the whole concept of victimless crimes, and accept that (negative) individual rights are more important than whatever (positive) vision of social good is prevalent. But, of course, both sides of mainstream political spectrum in US are hell-bent on using the legal bludgeon to force the other side to conform to their idea of utopia. I'm wondering what happened to "live and let live".
- crimsonalucard 7y agoWhy did we need to know what it's like to send a human to the moon? This is science and science is asking questions about the reality we live in. That is there are a set of people who deviate from the norm in that they are interested in other people of the same sex. This also deviates from the theory of evolution in that natural selection would supposedly eliminated this trait eons ago, yet it is quite prevalent today. It is worth asking this question and it is worth asking the question why some men like fat women and some men like skinny and what are the biological implications of it? Yes it is. A bigger question is why in the world would you question this research into a gay gene over the billions of dollars spent on getting the man to the moon (with little economic results to show for it). I think I have an answer. Because our society has become so politically correct and so afraid of racial inequality that ANYTHING even remotely suggesting things are unequal is attacked. The truth of the matter is, we are all unequal and we are all different. That is a reality that is staring us in our faces yet we choose to ignore it because we have become afraid of inequality under all circumstances. Life is unequal. And it is worth studying the differences. A counterpoint to your analogy: we study why men have penises and why women have vaginas, or in other words sexual dimorphisms... why not study sexual preference?
- scarface74 7y agoBecause our society has become so politically correct and so afraid of racial inequality that ANYTHING even remotely suggesting things are unequal is attacked. It’s just the opposite. People have been arguing that being gay “is not a choice” so society shouldn’t discriminate against gay people just like they shouldn’t discriminate against short people. I’m saying that it shouldn’t matter whether it is “a choice” or not. Just treat everyone equally. I’m also saying that they could find a whole bunch of gay genes and it wouldn’t matter to religious conservatives who think it is a “sin”. It wouldn’t change their belief system. If they still “don’t believe in” evolution and think the earth is only 7000 years old as well studied as evolution is, why do people think they will accept a gay gene and change such deeply held beliefs in how wrong it is? Just like we ignored them and struck down laws against miscegenation. We should continue to ignore them and treat everyone equally regardless of sexual preference.
- RichardCA 7y agoA simple Darwinian analysis would indicate that since homosexuals don't produce offspring, the trait should disappear, but instead it persists across generations. We don't know why this is the case. The question of why homosexuality is a stable trait of our species is inherently interesting.