4 ms·
GPZ has some of the very best whitehats in the entire world and they are evaluated based on what they find, not what they fail to find. They have the time to re
by UncleMeat 7y ago
GPZ has some of the very best whitehats in the entire world and they are evaluated based on what they find, not what they fail to find. They have the time to review code in depth. They are also usually investigating vulnerable code rather than malicious code, which doesn't seek to hide from investigation.
PlayProtect needs to be able to evaluate every app in existence (millions of apps on the Play store, ??? off the play store, and dozens or hundreds of versions of each of these apps). Malware authors are incentivized to perform all manner of tricks to avoid detection (code obfuscation to prevent static analysis, environment detection to prevent dynamic analysis, etc). It needs to do so in a (presumably) fully automated fashion since there are so many apps. It also gets little credit for when it works and instead only makes the news when it fails.
So 100% of the coverage of GPZ is positive and 100% of the coverage of PlayProtect is negative.
- ignoramous 7y agoI get your point but my intention was not to highlight the different areas of security GPZ and PlayProtect tackle, but the gulf in class in competence and level of execution between those groups (if I may say so from the armchair I'm sitting on). That said, the last bit abt a 100% coverage rings true. The signature check; however, seems like one of the important things to do (of course, there are lot of edge cases to be taken care of)? It can't be any more expensive than the AI they run on millions of apps.
- UncleMeat 7y ago"It isn't that hard" isn't always a good reason to implement something. I don't know the details, but it could be entirely reasonable that at every prioritization step people have decided that something else was higher impact. Add to this the fact that signing keys are often shared in weird ways (usually with OEMs) and maybe it doesn't make too much sense to use "this is signed weirdly" as sufficient evidence to remove from Play.