4 ms·
Anti-vax, flat earth, alt right... I often ask myself, are these the same kind of movements that brought down the civilizations before us?
by k__ 7y ago
Anti-vax, flat earth, alt right... I often ask myself, are these the same kind of movements that brought down the civilizations before us?
- Freak_NL 7y agoWhat makes the current situation unique is the ubiquitous presence of the internet as a very robust and very efficient infection vector for disinformation. We've just never had something quite like it.
- k__ 7y agoOn the other hand the civs bevor us had far less people, so they probably didn't need internet to distribute the news. Since the population boom it took quite a while to get something like the internet set up.
- vkou 7y agoIn the marketplace of ideas, a lie travels half-way around the world, before the truth gets is shoes on. It's a lot easier to broadcast low-effort bullshit, than rebut it.
- colmvp 7y agoIt's funny, having been part of the generation that was educated as a youngster midway through the rise of the Internet, I can't help but feel envious of young people now who have access to a wealth of resources I never had growing up. Nowadays, one can go online and find PDFs of textbooks, online lectures from prestigious professors teaching useful subjects, videos from conferences to learn latest findings, tutorials on practically every subject matter, Discord groups / subreddits from other enthusiasts, YouTube videos explaining practically every esoteric subject matter... I could've used so many of these resources when I was struggling in high school with classes taught by smart but bad teachers. I guess I've felt like it hasn't been that hard to separate the 'good' information from the misinformation.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoI grew up pre-Internet and I don't regret not having had access to it when growing up at all. The schools I went to had good libraries as did the town. I'm not sure I would have got more out of the Internet than I did out of books; I'm also not saying that I wouldn't, just that it is not a foregone conclusion that having access to a firehose is necessarily a better way to slake ones thirst than from a less dramatic tap. I had no trouble finding textbooks, I could ask my high school teachers, my university tutor, my friends, classmates, and so on for help. As for the esoteric subjects, well they are esoteric precisely because not many people are interested in them so I don't think I lost out there either. The amount of information available to me in the late sixties and seventies was already many orders of magnitude more than any one person could consume.
- mistermann 7y agoI wonder if we'll see to some degree much wider variance in intelligence in kids growing up with access to these resources. I was a fairly nerdy kid, but all I had access to was a crappy library, I was starving for interesting information. But then again, if I was growing up now I very well may have become addicted to iPad games.
- Nasrudith 7y agoRadio had and to a lesser extent has a similiar effect - and it was also a robust vector for (dis)information. However it had bandwidth limits and centralization over limited airwaves. Plenty of disinformation was passed before but it was limited to those who had permission or ability to act without it without any consequences.
- makomk 7y agoMeh. It looks like the UK's measles problem at least was mainly caused by the mainstream media acting as a vector for disinformation back in 1998, before most people had internet access: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/769970/UK_measles_and_rubella_elimination_strategy.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... Current childhood vaccination rates are much better than they were back then, but unfortunately there are still a lot of people who're now in their teens and early twenties who have no immunity because they missed out on vaccinations. This obviously does vary from country to country. Greece's big problem is more the complete destruction of its economy over the past decade and the vast damage this has done to healthcare access there.
- number6 7y agoThey are connected via Anthroposophy[1]. Flat earth not as much - but who knows [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophy
- pjc50 7y agoI always refer people to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_Popular_Delusions_and_the_Madness_of_Crowds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_Popular_Delusion... if they want to read about memes of the past.
- mistermann 7y agoA lack of understanding of varying viewpoints (~stereotyping) magnified by the internet resulting in social polarization seems like a more serious risk to me.
- k__ 7y agoI think so too, the examples I listed are just symptoms, but it's the symptoms that bring you down.
- mistermann 7y agoI believe the risk of them bringing us down is amplified by overly eager grouping of people into categories like this.
- magduf 7y agoIt would be extremely interesting to be able to look back in time, as if on a TV screen, and see what really happened in ancient civilizations and see why they really collapsed. From anthropological studies, it seems the usual cited reason is either environmental problems or invasions. Environmental problems are probably the main reason for most: they have a long drought, rivers dry up, crops fail, etc. But that doesn't explain why these peoples were unable to adapt, perhaps by moving elsewhere. Of course, there's the Romans. They had some problems with volcanoes (Pompeii and Herculaneum I think), but those were local, whereas the empire spanned most of the continent, so they should have been able to handle it. From what I've read about it, it seems their society collapsed basically from too much corruption and bad governance; at some point, it became more sensible for people to abandon the cities with their aquaducts and plumbing and their highly specialized trades and move to a feudal lord's land and be a serf, working in the fields and living in a hut. So I really do have to wonder: what kind of stupidity on a massive scale happened to cause things to go that badly?
- Nasrudith 7y agoWell the Romans had an unsung reason as well which goes for many but not all invasions - pissing their neighbors off and then getting too weak. I recall one documentary about Minioan archaeology - they had a practice of demanding/taking sacrifices from tributaries - the sacrificed adolescents weren't related to the other remains found. Apparently they suffered many deaths from an eruption and then when they were weakened their feared reputation backfired as their tributaries invaded and decided now was the time for vengence and to put an end to them for good. Corruption as a downfall seems to be a case of short term vested interests resulting in massive stupidity which also comes back to bite them. China weakened their navy massively over internal political disputes and even after they were forced to pay massive ransom and pardon pirates who decimated them. They even ignored the opportunity/hint as the pardoned pirates offered to sign up to be the new navy. Imperialism by western naval powers followed.
- apta 7y agoDon't forget the far left.