4 ms·
Hi guys, according to the Portuguese journal, this ruling specifically holds that (a) crypto trades are not subject to VAT, like other commodities trades in Por
by gamblor956 7y ago
Hi guys, according to the Portuguese journal, this ruling specifically holds that (a) crypto trades are not subject to VAT, like other commodities trades in Portugal.
Will edit or follow-up once I can read the ruling itself on a PC.
EDIT: I was able to read the rulings and deleted (b) and the statement about mining not being income. Portugal's tax authority has explicitly said it is not yet ready to analyze the taxability of crypto mining. The rulings themselves are much less expansive the Portuguese journal cited by the linked crypto blog.
- DangerousPie 7y agoSo in other words there is no additional tax on bitcoin transactions for payments that are already taxed in other ways (eg. buying a product where the price already includes VAT) but profits from bitcoin trading are still taxable? That would be a very misleading headline in that case.
- gamblor956 7y agoI have been able to read the ruling (https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Finfo.portaldasfinancas.gov.pt%2Fpt%2Finformacao_fiscal%2Finformacoes_vinculativas%2Frendimento%2Fcirs%2FDocuments%2FPIV_09541.pdf https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...). If that is translated accurately, cryptocurrency is not considered a currency, so it's not subject to regular income tax. It's not a capital asset, so it's not subject to capital gains. The gain is derived from selling the crypto units themselves, so they don't generate capital income (i.e., "passive" income in the US). Crypto trading is taxable as business income if the individual makes a business of trading crypto, meaning they regularly engage in crypto trades. However, if it's just incidental or occasional trading, then it's not taxable as personal income. They do not provide a bright line rule from when you cross over into crypto trading as a business, but I would say more than 3x a year and you should be talking to a tax lawyer (not an accountant--accountants are good for well-settled areas of tax/accounting, but for unsettled or fast-changing areas like this they're extremely bad at making defendable tax/accounting positions that survive tax authority review). The headline is for a blog post linking to a Portuguese business journal about a new ruling which is purely about whether crypto trading on crypto platforms is subject to VAT.
- jorge-d 7y agoYes, as a Portuguese reader (but not a lawyer!) this is also how I understand it. Now the legislation is currently in a very grey area (notably on the business/occasional definition) and I'm guessing it will evolve in the coming years.
- benj111 7y ago"so mining is not taxable income in Portugal" The income is taxable, even as capital gains, though? I assume when the coins are sold.
- icebraining 7y agoIt seems it's not, at least for individuals; from what I can tell, the tax law that taxes gains is not generic, that is, it explicitly lists the types of property (shares, financial instruments, etc) that it applies to, and cryptocurrency doesn't fit any, therefore the gains are not taxable. (Native speaker, but not a bitcoin trader or tax professional)
- ska 7y agoIs it not taxable, or just taxable at regular income tax rates (not capital gains)? The latter seems likely.
- icebraining 7y agoNot taxable at all, I believe; see my other post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20830538 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20830538
- gamblor956 7y agoThis would probably be wrong. If you're mining, you're doing it as a business since it's a regular activity intended for profit, so mining income would very likely be business income. There's almost no way you can mine crypto without doing it regularly or intending profit. Business income is taxable.
- gamblor956 7y agoSorry, I deleted that part once I was able to actually read the ruling directly (and not the blogspam about the ruling). Portugal's tax authority has not actually yet ruled on the taxability of mining AFAIK, but is likely to rule that mining income is business income, and thus taxable, following the US reasoning on mining income.
- jermaustin1 7y ago> so mining is not taxable income in Portugal Is mining taxable in other parts of the world? I would have thought it was only when you SOLD the crypto for fiat.
- throwawayForMe2 7y agoIn the US mining is taxed as ordinary income at the time of receipt, meaning if you are lucky enough to mine a block, the block reward is income at that moment.
- jermaustin1 7y agoThat's kind of crappy. When I build a bookshelf from raw materials, I am not taxed on the value of the bookshelf. That would be tantamount to a wealth tax. I am only taxed when I convert said bookshelf to fiat currency, or make a trade that isn't like-kind (such as trading my bookshelf for a house).
- xxpor 7y agoThe analogy does really work though. You are taxed when you sell the bookshelf for income. In the Bitcoin case, if you were able to mine coins and not pay income taxes, theoretically you could pay for everything you need while never having paid income tax. The problem is Bitcoin is a cash equivalent, sort of.