3 ms·
Harry Browne demonstrates the effectiveness of asset allocation and periodic balancing in his book "Why the Best-Laid Investment Plans Usually Go Wrong". It's
by fexl 16y ago
Harry Browne demonstrates the effectiveness of asset allocation and periodic balancing in his book "Why the Best-Laid Investment Plans Usually Go Wrong". It's an old book from 1987, but the principle is timeless.
For example, I'm looking at a chart of his "Permanent Portfolio" from 1970 through 1987, which weights four asset classes equally at 25% each: gold, stocks, bonds, and cash. The portfolio has far lower volatility and far lower draw-downs than gold, stocks, or bonds alone. The portfolio also outperforms stocks or bonds alone. It does not outperform gold over this 17 year period, but by 1987 it comes close. It probably overtakes gold alone in subsequent years, since gold vastly underperformed the stock market from 1987 to 2001.
One good aspect of asset allocation is that it keeps on the opposite side of manic up or down trends. This strategy would have you selling gold at $800 in 1980, and buying gold at $250 in 2001. Gold has vastly outperformed the stock market since then.
Similarly, this strategy would have you buying stocks in 1974, when many people thought equities were "dead" and only fools were in the stock market.
You might think these references are a little dated, but again the principle is timeless. Anyone who says "it's different this time" is probably wrong.
- yannickt 16y agoAnother great book is "All About Asset Allocation" by Richard Ferri.
- hugh3 16y agoOne obvious asset class that's missing from that allocation is real estate, which (if you bought in a sensible area) has probably easily outperformed all of those since 1974 with the possible exception of gold.
- fexl 16y agoHe discusses real estate in a separate chapter, but what he says is interesting: "Real estate isn't an essential investment for a Permanent Portfolio. Real estate offers no profit or protection to a portfolio that can't be achieved more easily with stocks and gold." He then accepts the reality that many readers have invested or wish to invest in real estate, and goes on to talk about it at length. Clearly real estate can produce high income and gains for those who have the capital to buy property and the time and money to manage it, but I do see his point.