4 ms·
While this experiment was interesting, I think it was doomed from the get go. One of the problems with advertising is that it works a lot off of a novelty fact
by jchw 7y ago
While this experiment was interesting, I think it was doomed from the get go.
One of the problems with advertising is that it works a lot off of a novelty factor. Like, you can come up with a new technique, and for a brief moment in time this new technique of advertising may be effective. Think popup ads, or those annoying newsletter popups, etc etc etc. But then everyone does it, people start ignoring it, and it becomes immediate noise.
The trouble is, why wouldn't anyone `npm install funding`? Soon npm install would have to block the ads just so its own user experience wouldn't be absolutely demolished. This idea simply wouldn't have scaled.
I love open source and I contribute as much as I can, and have definitely been a long time user and supporter, longer than I've worked in software professionally for sure, but along with all of the "Open source is not about you" points that were brought up, there is one point that may hurt but is nonetheless equally true: You are not entitled to make a living off of open source. There is no reason this would be guaranteed to be possible. It would be nice to live in a world like that, but if it doesn't work, it doesn't work. I'm not for solutions that will just deteriorate open source as I think it is much more valuable to society than just a way to make money, to basically all parties involved. I sympathize with people who pour hours of unpaid work into it, but when you donate your time and effort into something, you don't necessarily get anything in return, much like giving gifts to someone you love.
If you need to make a living, you can always sell software, or work for someone else. There's still opportunities to contribute to open source in both of those cases. I would love to see a detailed breakdown is between open source work that's donated versus funded by companies to understand what the open source community really is; I think it would help our understanding about how open source gets funded today.
Of course, though, it is absolutely people's right to do what they wish with their own projects, and I do wish everyone luck in finding a good way to make contributing to open source more sustainable as a source of income.