3 ms·
I only glanced at it but it looks like you were saying that the problem is caused when using qdbusviewer together with rythembox, but neither of the nokia guys
by dkersten 16y ago
I only glanced at it but it looks like you were saying that the problem is caused when using qdbusviewer together with rythembox, but neither of the nokia guys have rythembox and requested a Qt-only project to use instead of rythembox which demonstrates your bug, which you didn't provide them with. They also said that, from the log you provided, the problem appears to be with rythembox and not with Qt - ie, it is not a Qt bug - and asked you to demonstrate that the bug is on Qt's side with a Qt-only project.
They did ask you for a Qt-only demonstration of the bug a number of times and each time you didn't provide one.
Their actions seem quite reasonable to me.
I guess you could spell it out for them by posting the d-feet and dbus-monitor log and showing exactly where qdbusviewer gets it wrong (and d-feet gets it right). Better yet: do as they ask and reproduce the problem with a Qt-only project, instead of rythembox.
- jda2000 16y agoUntil very recently, if you had Ubuntu, you had Rhythmbox.
- dkersten 16y agoCounter argument: I'm a heavy linux user, yet I don't have rythembox. Seriously, who knows why they won't just install it. Perhaps its because of a nokia program-installation policy. Who knows. I don't think we should expect that they will have it or are able to install it.
- jda2000 16y agoHowever, time permitting. I guess I will send them the dbus-monitor trace of the d-feet call.
- dkersten 16y agoHopefully that will be enough to convince them.
- jda2000 16y agoLet's hope so. What they were asking me to do was to rewrite a small portion of Rhythmbox as a QT app to expose the bug. I still think it was more reasonable for them to just get Rhythmbox from the repository and run qdbusviewer under a debugger. Did I mention that I am not a QT programmer?
- dkersten 16y agoI get that and understand that (if they're on a debian based system) they can probably just apt-get install rythembox and test it for themselves (I don't use a debian-based system, but I imagine I can get it just as easily with yaourt -S rythembox). That would be the easiest. But, for whatever reason they cannot or will not install it and I don't think we can criticize them for that decision. Anyway, since you were saying that it is definitely not rythemboxes fault, I would suggest you 1) show the dbus-monitor trace of the d-feet so that they can see that rythembox and d-feet do work perfectly and 2) show them, again, the dbus-monitor output for qdbusviewer, in as much detail as you can and clearly highlighting where it diverges from the expected. If that isn't enough for them, then they definitely are being stubborn... The sad thing is, even if you do as they ask and write a Qt program, it really won't give them anything over what they'd have if you give them logs, since, as you say, the problem is not with rythembox. Sigh. In any case, good luck.
- jda2000 16y agoOK. Thank you very much and sincerely for your time and thought. It looks like your opinion is going to be unanimous. ;-)