4 ms·
The skills startups want are taught at coding bootcamps, not universities. The degree is called computer science for a reason.
by paxys 7y ago
The skills startups want are taught at coding bootcamps, not universities. The degree is called computer science for a reason.
- hildaman 7y agoI disagree with this. A good Computer Science program must have enough software development curriculum that people actually learn to write code.
- ericd 7y agoMIT's was (is?) heavy on theory, light on coding practice. I still think it was a pretty good program, they just expected that you'd learn to program outside of class.
- ghaff 7y agoI took the 6.001 edX courses a while back. Introduction to Computer Science and Programming in Python--actually broken in 2 parts for edX. Yeah, it came across to me that the expectation was that you'd learn to program mostly outside of the course. Or, really, that you already had a reasonable grasp on the basic concepts. Otherwise I think that course would feel to most people like being tossed into the deep end of the pool from a great height. To be sure, with the campus version of the class there would be recitation sessions and other resources to get help on the programming side. There's also a companion textbook that goes into more Python details. But that's certainly not a class to "learn to program," much less how to work on a command line, use an editor, etc. That may be reasonable for an MIT CS curriculum but most other majors probably don't have the same degree of implied prerequisites.
- ericd 7y agoYeah, that was a pretty common feeling in 6.001, especially among those who hadn't done much programming in high school. At the time, it was taught in Scheme (a Lisp), which no one I knew taking it had any experience in, so everyone was on sort of equal footing there, at least. And more generally, it seemed to be a pretty common approach there to throw students into the deep end and let them figure it out - people liked to compare the experience to trying to drink from a firehose :-D. I'm not sure if it's optimal for learning the material itself, but it does make jumping into new subjects seem less daunting after you've gone through that a few times.
- ghaff 7y agoYeah. Course 2. '79. :-) There's probably an expectation these days that students have some degree of exposure to computers. When I took an intro to computing course (FORTRAN) it was pretty much no expectations. But times have changed. And I found 6.001x useful. But then I had a lot of experience with computers even if not programming full-time professionally.
- ericd 7y agoHaha so you know the feeling well. Makes sense, guessing not many high schools even had one computer until the Apple II, which I guess would have been a bit after you graduated. Side note, I love that it's possible to take a course like that online for ~free now.
- ghaff 7y agoI didn't touch a personal computer until a few years later in a job where we had an Apple II to do some engineering calculations. High school was BASIC using a teletype connected to a local community college--and that was pretty forward looking at the time. I did take a FORTRAN course in college which people would consider very rudimentary today. This was the textbook :-) https://openlibrary.org/works/OL6795090W/A_Fortran_coloring_book https://openlibrary.org/works/OL6795090W/A_Fortran_coloring_... But I didn't really use a computer to speak of (other than as a text editor in grad school) until I was working--and later got into programming as a hobby.
- ericd 7y agoOh, that's a pretty sweet looking textbook. Reminds me a bit of http://landoflisp.com/ http://landoflisp.com/
- sli 7y agoI'm not an MIT grad, but this has been my approach over the past few years when I decided I needed to educate myself on more paradigms rather than more languages. I found it less helpful to expand my skillset of similarly-styled languages and far more helpful to learn languages that are fundamentally different than the ones I already knew. Basically, I decided I should learn Lisp instead of yet another C-style language. The end result is nice little feedback loop of far better understanding of the theory and concepts behind the code that I write feeding into writing better code, which then feeds back into better understanding. So now when I help peers (especially friends still in college), I focus less on the language and more on helping the concept click for them. I can't say how well this works in practice in a university -- it sure seems to work for MIT -- but I know that in my professional life it has made just about everything I do far easier to reason about and my work is all the better for it.
- ericd 7y agoYeah, Lisp especially is one of those mind-expanding languages, I think everyone should at least play around with it at some point.
- yodsanklai 7y ago> light on coding practice I did for fun two MIT graduate students labs (operating systems, and distributed system) that complement the lectures. https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/6.828/2014/overview.html https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/6.828/2014/overview.html http://nil.csail.mit.edu/6.824/2015/ http://nil.csail.mit.edu/6.824/2015/ I found them very challenging and interesting. It took me a few weeks to complete them, and I didn't even do the "project" part which was more open-ended.
- ericd 7y agoRight, the labs were the major exception (and by far my favorite part, even though they tended to involve a lot of sleeping on things other than beds).
- jbn 7y agoYMMV, but 6.172 (https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-172-performance-engineering-of-software-systems-fall-2010/ https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-compu...) doesn't seem light on coding to me (full disclosure: I have been one of the MITPOSSE for this class for multiple years).
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoMost major schools offer degrees called Software Engineering. Most Computer Science students are looking for careers in Software Engineering. So ultimately it is called computer science for the wrong reason.
- paxys 7y agoWhat schools? I don't know of any such degree at MIT, CMU, Berkeley, UIUC or any other top school. At best it will be a single course or some added certification to your degree, and even then they will teach you software engineering processes, not Node.js and React.
- stale2002 7y agoI went to CMU (econ major/CS minor) , and we absolutely had such a degree. It was called Information Systems, and generally taught people the skills needed to become a web developer. Skills such as front end developement, Ruby on rails, ect, as well as even some mobile dev electives I think. Unfortunately, even though it was one of the best such programs in the world, and turned out graduates who made 80k+, it was still generally looked down upon, as the degree that people took who "couldn't get into Computer Science". It is unfortunate that people in academia severely look down upon anything that has a more practical focus on useful skills, and only respect theoretical studies.
- SkyPuncher 7y agoInformation Systems is NOT an engineering degree. The problem for most schools is an engineering degree is a specific, formally defined degree. It seems that ABET has recently updated their Software Engineering criteria, but for decades a software engineering degree required extensive curriculum in physical science.
- stale2002 7y ago> Information Systems is NOT an engineering degree. It teaches you how to work as a web developer. Web development being something that people often call software engineering. Use whatever word or definition that you want to group Info Systems under, but at the end of the day, these people with these degrees are still getting jobs at Google, FB, and the other top companies, and/or startups, and are giving the job title "software engineer". That is the definition of software engineer that I use. It is defined as "Those people who are working at google, or top startups or whatever".
- blueatlas 7y agoJust curious if anyone here has attended or graduated from Neumont College, or a school like it. Seems to be focused on solving this problem. https://www.neumont.edu/ https://www.neumont.edu/ I have no affiliation with them, but like the model.
- dikdikvandik 7y agoI think this might be true of the startup is focused on building a web app since that's what most bootcamps teach. From what I've seen bootcamp grads are weaker candidates than CS grads because at least CS grads know enough theory and engineering to learn how to build something.
- bdcravens 7y agoStartups need developers who can hit the ground running and solve problems quickly. Many bootcamps focus on bulletpoints, not depth.
- flukus 7y agoThen their needs are mutually exclusive and they have to compromise somewhere. If they want someone that can hit the ground running then they need developers with experience and not fresh graduates. If they really need someone to hit the ground running they might need highly specialized (expensive) experience too.