3 ms·
>In general a problem is that wealthier people have the time, energy, and expertise to manipulate the system better than poorer people. Notwithstanding its own
by hammock 7y ago
>In general a problem is that wealthier people have the time, energy, and expertise to manipulate the system better than poorer people.
Notwithstanding its own merits, this argument is a non sequitur. This is not a case of rich people affording a maneuver that poor people can't. Poor people won't ever be in the situation where they have to separate from their kid in order to qualify for financial aid. In that sense, poor people have an advantage.
- DougN7 7y agoThere are a lot of people in the middle though that aren’t poor but can’t play the shenanigans the rich get away with.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIt's not a non sequitur. In the case of tax loopholes, sure. Poor people don't pay a lot of taxes. But in the case of spending real money paying for tutoring to raise SAT scores: yes. SAT scores, in some sense, are a transactional measure of the free resources one has available to obtain a good score: A quiet place to study, tutoring, etc. Money helps provide these things.
- nathanvanfleet 7y agoI think the point is that you have poorer people who qualify, and rich people who can organize and pay to manipulate the situation. Then there are people in between, people who don't qualify, but also who don't have the ability to manipulate the system. Furthermore, that rich people are taking advantage of programs meant for poorer people is ultimately an unethical thing to do.
- MegaButts 7y agoThat doesn't quite apply here, because it seems pretty obvious the intent of these laws was to help out those less advantaged. Now those that have means have figured out a way to take away something from those less advantaged in order to enrich themselves even more. Financial aid is limited - every time a rich person gets aid a poor person doesn't. And even worse, this isn't even just trying to get admitted in the first place. If that were the situation, then it would be much more understandable as rich and poor alike both want the best education for their children. But now the rich don't have to pay full price for the education and take advantage of a program designed for those with less money? I get what they're doing is (almost certainly) legal and everybody wants to minimize their bill, but they are directly harming the people who actually need it in this case. The argument "poor people have an advantage" in receiving benefits designed solely for poor people is absurd - there shouldn't be competition between rich and poor here at all.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoThere are many levels of poverty and wealth. You're right, very poor families making $20k per year will qualify for need-based financial aid. However, "middle class" families making $50k may not. They're sharing expenses and the kids are working just to stay in a house and have a car to split among the family members, and it feels like there's not enough to go around for day-to-day, but hypothetically enough to send one kid to college. Maybe they have two kids and the younger is a high school junior, FAFSA will assume that all the available money is available to send the first to their freshman year and not plan for next year. But if they're making $150k/year, they can have a lawyer and accountant help them structure their funds so that the kids do get financial aid.
- klipklop 7y agoYeah the people in the middle that have any form of income get screwed with FAFSA. I was > 24 years old already so financial aid only considered my income. One year I made $11k and it dramatically reduced my grants. I imagine a dependent student with both parents working and making $60k+ get essentially nothing in grants. Hearing that 'rich kids' are essentially hiding their parents income/contribution to get max financial aid is a cruel joke. The parents and student should go to jail for fraud.