6 ms·
For a while the President was tweeting from a consumer-grade Android (!) phone, likely made by China, in the Oval Office. It makes me wonder how many groups pw
by nostrademons 7y ago
For a while the President was tweeting from a consumer-grade Android (!) phone, likely made by China, in the Oval Office. It makes me wonder how many groups pwned that phone and have access to critical national security information.
- mieseratte 7y ago> For a while the President was tweeting from a consumer-grade Android (!) phone, likely made by China, in the Oval Office. It makes me wonder how many groups pwned that phone and have access to critical national security information. You mentioned tweeting, was he doing NATSEC-relevant work from the phone or was he using an official device for those purposes?
- nostrademons 7y agoAs I understand it he wasn't doing NATSEC-relevant work from the phone, but on Android spyware can turn on the microphone and camera remotely. During the Cold War our adversaries would've given anything to slip a bug into the Oval Office; now every hacker group who can pwn an Android phone has one.
- isostatic 7y ago> During the Cold War our adversaries would've given anything to slip a bug into the Oval Office See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device)
- bubblethink 7y ago>but on Android spyware can turn on the microphone and camera remotely. Seems like an unsubstantiated claim. Also, Android is a broad umbrella term where security varies widely across implementations and devices. Do you have any concrete information about reference Android devices (i.e., Pixels)
- opencl 7y agoHe was using a Galaxy S3 long past the time it stopped receiving security patches. https://www.androidcentral.com/which-android-phone-does-donald-trump-use https://www.androidcentral.com/which-android-phone-does-dona...
- okmokmz 7y ago>Seems like an unsubstantiated claim It absolutely isn't. Evidence supporting his claim are easily found online, both in leaked documents as well as from other first and second hand sources
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoI'd be surprised if anyone in this thread has any way of knowing whether that's the case.
- mirimir 7y agoThere might be, but they would never comment.
- akersten 7y agoI can't speak for GP, but certainly this adminstration has used consumer Android devices for a little more than tweeting: https://www.theverge.com/2017/2/13/14597700/donald-trump-phone-flashlight-north-korea-hacking-security https://www.theverge.com/2017/2/13/14597700/donald-trump-pho...
- mc32 7y agoAnd previous administrations had blackberries. I don’t think it’s possible to get high level pols to forgo their devices and follow good security hygiene. It’s in their nature to be communicative and available.
- entee 7y agoIt’s my understanding that Obama had a specially locked down device, not just the off the shelf blackberry/iPhone.
- ColanR 7y agoThat was after a while. From my recollection, the locked down blackberry was a compromise after he insisted on his prior insecure blackberry.
- frankzinger 7y agoOne would hope for a little continuity in the Presidential Office's security department. Why would they reset their security at the beginning of each administration, only to have to learn the same lessons the hard way again?
- SiempreViernes 7y agoUh, he is doing pretty reckless diplomacy on twitter, does that count as natural security work?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duxup 7y agoI used to work for a company that serviced a very secure site (military). The rule was NOTHING electronic went in that wasn't accounted for, and NOTHING ever left. We sent people onsite with what were effectively disposable laptops that were single use items and never left the location. Showing up at the gate with anything extra was said to be a very bad idea. It never happened so I don't know what would happen. You drove to the site in a car with only what you needed in it. Your license, keys, the equipment you were scheduled to bring. Smartphones weren't ultra common yet, but were absolutely forbidden. The car itself was searched too even though it was in a parking lot far from anything sensitive. You were warned that anything suspicious would not be in the car when you came back (like the extra stuff rule I don't know of anyone that happened to as nobody was foolish enough to drive out with anything but a clean rental car). I honestly think that is the only security that makes sense. That should be the status quo for some areas the White House too IMO. At least as far as meetings and etc. Maybe one day we get physical switches that power off cameras and mics, but hard to trust anything until that day....maybe not then.
- nostrademons 7y agoI have friends that work in defense. Their experience is basically like yours - physically and electronically isolated clean rooms where you do the actual work. Nothing goes in. Nothing comes out. Also, one of the Snowden disclosures was that apparently the NSA can power on the cameras and mics of Android phones even when the phone is off. I don't know exactly how it works, but it does, probably based off the residual current drawn from the battery and the circuitry that handles the power button. Smartphones are basically never safe, although I've heard iPhones are significantly safer than Android.
- duxup 7y agoYeah i'd be wary about the switch unless I understood it.
- kuzimoto 7y ago> Also, one of the Snowden disclosures was that apparently the NSA can power on the cameras and mics of Android phones even when the phone is off. I don't know exactly how it works, but it does, probably based off the residual current drawn from the battery and the circuitry that handles the power button. Smartphones are basically never safe, although I've heard iPhones are significantly safer than Android. I mean, even if you could turn on the mic/camera, I would think you still need to possibly save it to storage for retrieval later which pretty much requires the OS to be running. Otherwise, maybe, you could somehow transmit the data but that would require the ability to communicate with the device via Bluetooth/WiFi and for the data from the camera to be passed to the wireless interface. Unless a device was designed with that sort of functionality, I'm not sure how the NSA could just turn that on.
- fortran77 7y agoIt was probably made in Korea, albeit with many Chinese parts.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoSeems like it was the last administration that made all the opsec mistakes. Like running a private email server holding classified data.
- cryptonector 7y agoMy guess is that besides whatever the microphone, camera, and radios on that device can capture, there's no classified information on it. The microphone and camera can be dealt with by keeping the phone in a somewhat sound-proofed box, or just powered off. I would hope there's no classified data access via WiFi at the WH, so perhaps that device's radios are of little importance. I'm not going to address the possibility of the radios being used to gather emanations, but keeping it on for very limited time periods is a mitigation. (Yes, even so, the radios and microphone could perhaps be used for clever side channels for exfiltrating data during the times when it's powered on, but I'm sure there's lots of those side channels. This is partly why we have SCIFs, so again, not an issue.) In any case, provided all he does with that device is tweet, provided when he's not tweeting it's powered off and locked away, provided the device is never ever taken to a SCIF, and provided there's no access to classified data over WiFi at the WH, I'd tolerate the President (whoever it might be) tweeting from a consumer-grade mobile device. That said, my preference would be for the President use a room for the purpose, and wired devices maintained for the purpose of tweeting. The twitter account itself is of relatively low value. Of course, perhaps he and his staff are quite careless with that device. Perhaps that device has been the source of many leaks! I thought NSA wouldn't let the President conduct the nation's business on an unsecure device, so I assume he only uses for tweeting, thus carelessness would be about the microphone, camera, and radios.