4 ms·
>> The first known crime in what is now New York City occurred in the 1620s, when the Lenape Indians scammed their new Dutch friends by selling them Manahattan
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> The first known crime in what is now New York City occurred in the 1620s, when the Lenape Indians scammed their new Dutch friends by selling them Manahattan island twice.
I'm not one to scream about micro-aggressions, but look at that opening sentence. It implies that no "crime" was even possible before the arrival of Europeans, that prior to contact native populations did not commit crimes. Either the native were innocent children in a garden of eden, or they were wild animals with no justice system.
Perhaps this was the first crime involving Europeans ... but even that suggests that the Europeans themselves had not committed any crimes prior to this deal. That's a big can of worms. I'd say, at best, this is the first documented case of real estate fraud in the land that would become NY.
- ianremsen 7y agoCommentary Magazine isn't exactly known for its wokeness, I'm afraid.
- Qwertystop 7y agoIt says "known". It doesn't say that native populations did not commit crimes among themselves, only that we have no record of such. I don't know whether that's accurate, but it doesn't seem too unreasonable. Pre-colonization records are sparser than post.
- sandworm101 7y agoI'm rather sure that the natives knew then, and know today, of past crimes within their populations. Many such crimes were recorded in oral histories.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mieseratte 7y ago> I'm rather sure that the natives knew then, and know today, of past crimes within their populations. Many such crimes were recorded in oral histories. Sounds like a fun weekend project, go interview tribal historians for the tribes of that region for crimes that predate the first-"known" crime from TFA and submit it such that the author can publish a retraction.
- whiddershins 7y agoIt implies none of those things. New Amsterdam was founded in 1624. New Amsterdam became NYC. The sentence is a typical structure making an joke which basically says crime existed in NYC from the start. You are somehow missing the context both of that threadbare joke, and the context of the paragraph it is in, and the article as a whole, leading you to ascribe implications that aren’t in any way present in the writing.
- JackFr 7y ago> I'm not one to scream about micro-aggressions Then why approach a piece with a pedantic, argumentative, intentional misreading of the first sentence?
- rpmisms 7y ago> first known crime Congratulations, you missed the joke.
- jessaustin 7y agoWow, people on HN will go to the wall defending an unfunny joke, if only because a little bit of awareness annoys them much more... it's somehow satisfying that this is the only thread on this page.