4 ms·
Vegan and vegetarian are absolute terms. The only meaning of "semi-vegetarian" or "semi-vegan" is that you're not either. "Semi-vegan" is a particularly nonsen
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
Vegan and vegetarian are absolute terms. The only meaning of "semi-vegetarian" or "semi-vegan" is that you're not either.
"Semi-vegan" is a particularly nonsensical term.
- criddell 7y agoThere's no reason for them to be absolute, is there? If I eat one non-vegan meal every 20 meals, then I think it's reasonable to say my diet is 95% vegan.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> There's no reason for them to be absolute, is there? Well, yes there is since that's the very definition of "vegan" and "vegetarian". If I drink only at weekends, am I a semi-teetotaller? That's ridiculous.
- criddell 7y agoDefinitions of social things are never that rigid. Was my grandmother a teetotaler? The only alcohol she ever consumed for the last 70 years of her life was a tiny bit of wine during communion every few weeks.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThese definitions are rigid. Anyone can do something they are not supposed to once in a while but 'vegan' and 'vegetarian' do mean that you refuse to eat animal products or meat, not that you don't eat much of them.
- criddell 7y ago> Anyone can do something they are not supposed to What do you mean not supposed to? My grandmother wasn't supposed to drink? Her being a teetotaler was just the result of her daily choices. That's what eating vegan meals is for me. Do you have to explicitly choose to be a vegan? If prisoners were fed 100% vegan diets and had no options for outside foods, would they be vegans? I guess I'm wondering if intent matters just as much as action, or is one or the other good enough?
- have_faith 7y ago> If I drink only at weekends, am I a semi-teetotaller? That's ridiculous. I've been tee-total for over 10 years. I've sipped someones drink a handful of times to see what it tasted like, can I not say I was tee-total anymore? The definitions are more about proclamations. If today I decide to be a vegan, then tomorrow I will call myself a vegan despite having only abstained for 24 hours so far. If I decide to eat meat a couple times a month then I'll tell people I'm predominantly vegan, they understand what I mean.
- redthrow 7y agoCambridge physicist David McKay talked about the environmental impact of eating vegetarian 6 days out of 7. http://www.withouthotair.com/c29/page_229.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c29/page_229.shtml There's also the word "reducetarian": https://reducetarian.org/ https://reducetarian.org/ Using percentage seems perfectly rational.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoEating "Vegetarian", that is no meat, 6 days a week is not the same as being a vegetarian. That's the point. And here we go, you've dropped yet another labeling term... I'm sure there's an accompanying self-help book.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIf we have friends over, and decide on an Indian takeaway. We might order two vegan mains, two meat, and two vegan side dishes are shared between all of us. What's your term for that? Given the site's market and the story, semi-vegan seems a reasonable compromise to describe many takeaway orders.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> What's your term for that? Why should there be a specific term for that? You're describing an order that is neither vegan nor vegetarian. It's no different from a "normal" (for lack of a better word) meal consisting of a salad followed by a steak and chips.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoMost places have a far wider, and more creative set of vegetarian and vegan options than only a decade ago. Indian takeaways have had the wider range far longer, of course. Not that TFA mentioned either, but semi- seems a helpful shorthand to me, to describe changing habits, as we increasingly don't want meat every meal. Even if most people choosing those meals probably never think to describe themselves as semi-vegan yet. :)
- louhike 7y agoIt might be a bad shortcut, but it's easy to understand that the person intentionaly uses a vegan diet in some of its meals.
- Ensorceled 7y agoI try to eat a vegan meal at least a couple of times a week and vegetarian usually once a day. If semi-vegetarian is off limits, what am I?
- aloisdg 7y agoYou are flexitarian. Welcome :) Here take a fruit and if one day you want a steak go ahead.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoJust someone who does not eat meat every day...
- dfxm12 7y agoYou're just a boring omnivore, like most of us.
- astura 7y agoThe term flexitarian was invented to describe this sort of eating pattern.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoWhat words do you use to differentiate between an omnivore and someone who eats meat two to three meals a day?
- nothrabannosir 7y agoThere is a downside to insisting on the purity of that definition. In the wild, vegetarian fundamentalism puts people off choosing vegetarian options, because going all the way is too hard for many. Net result is more meat consumption. Ironically, this attitude is harmful to the environment and to animals.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis makes no sense. There are a wide variety of dishes and people may be suggested that they can perfectly eat good, tasty food without eating meat at every meal. There is no need to even mention the terms "vegetarian" or "vegan", or to invent random new terms.
- nothrabannosir 7y ago> This makes no sense. Agreed. Group behaviour doesn't make sense. That doesn't make it less real. "Pete, it's a fool that looks for logic in the chambers of the human heart." — Everett, O Brother, Where Art Thou?