10 ms·
Oh? I assume you have a source to back that up. All accounts I’ve seen (wikipedia and the timeline on iter’s website) show that it is due to global politics,
by willis936 7y ago
Oh? I assume you have a source to back that up. All accounts I’ve seen (wikipedia and the timeline on iter’s website) show that it is due to global politics, namely due to the US’s withdrawal (which was not motivated by finances).
You seem like you have a strong narrative you’re sticking to. Is there something you’d like to disclose?
- pfdietz 7y agohttps://fire.pppl.gov/FPA13_Freidberg2_2013.pptx https://fire.pppl.gov/FPA13_Freidberg2_2013.pptx Look at the chart on page 13, and his comments on the next page.
- willis936 7y agoThat’s a retrospective look. That was not what happened in the early 2000s and is not why ITER stalled. ITER stalled because the US pulled out. You can’t change history to fit a narrative.
- pfdietz 7y agoHe is saying that if they had done due diligence, if they had honestly extrapolated the costs of previous experiments using the demonstrated empirical scaling laws, they'd have gotten costs closer to what ITER has ended up costing. They either knew or should have know the initial cost claims were dishonest. The US opted out of ITER in 1999 and returned in 2003. The cost of constructing ITER was estimated at €5B in 2006. How could the earlier US pullout excuse the inaccuracy of that estimate? Your narrative there makes no sense.