4 ms·

It is about equal opportunity, not equal outcome

• scoobyyabbadoo 7y ago
  That's not how diversity success metrics are reported though. It's said to be a travesty if half the number of women as men choose a STEM major
• fromthestart 7y ago
  Well, no, and here is the Crux of the issue with affirmative action, and possibly one of the strongest base drivers of the cleavage between the American left approach to race and equality, and the American right approach to the same. These policies attempt to achieve equality of outcome based on the implicit presumption that given equality of opportunity outcomes will be equal among various demographics. Thus any systematic inequalities are, without much in the way of hard evidence (a limitation of the related fields of psychology, economics, and the like) immediately explained by uncompetitive social norms of successful groups, i.e. racism/discrimination - unlocking the justification for penalizing those on top to equalize outcomes for those on the bottom. The result of this implicit and fundamentally unproven assumption is the conflation of equality of outcome with equality of opportunity by the modern American left. This is a point of consternation for those near the center and leaning right primarily because it punishes success without allowing for the possibility of personal/internal explanations for discrepancies, i.e. cultural factors independent of poverty which limit economic success, and/or things like proven heritability of intelligence. Further, one could argue that such a conflation optimizes economic equality over merit, which is probably worse for society overall.
• Excel_Wizard 7y ago
  When you allow the most competent people to rise to positions fitting their competence, they can create wealth for everyone.
  • awakeasleep 7y ago
    They can do whatever they want to do and can get away with.