4 ms·
> The fundamental issue is that while replication of information is effectively free, generation of (valuable) information most certainly is not. This is a com
by baybal2 7y ago
> The fundamental issue is that while replication of information is effectively free, generation of (valuable) information most certainly is not.
This is a complete delusion. This is what about Goebbels said, "the bigger the lie, the easier it is to believe in."
People are so indoctrinated in that way of thinking, that some times I have to show this though experiment:
1. Set up a machine that will "destroy" the IP value of something by copying it.
2. Make it do so a billion times, and watch if the company whose IP being "infringed" goes bankrupt.
Now, will the company go bankrupt? Would they "run out" of their "IP generation resource?" Definitely not, that would be completely inconsequential to them. They nor lose nor gain anything. And then, all those guys run to make up some smart "economic theory" to explain that, often mutually contradicting, one sillier than another.
My idea is: if though process coming under IP generation is an unproductive process, that does not make money, why does the society goes nuts to encourage and facilitate that? A basic understanding of economic principles tells this is just like throwing money away.
See, US always brags of its informativeness. What was the last "big thing" an American company ever came with? I will say it was transistor, and it was more than 60 years ago, when no monstrous IP protection regime was in place.
It was not American companies who came up with: hoverboards, e ciggaretes, selfie sticks, stick computer form factor, an untold number of innovations in construction materials (MgO board is a Chinese invention, as well as FRPP piping, modern foam concrete manufacturing machinery,) an untold number of advances in materials science which allowed for $200 laptops being made from carbon fibre (A US made analogue will cost you $2000 just for the casing)
Just how many new products are coming from China in virtual anonymity and never given acknowledgement for their innovative nature are made without any consideration for getting remunerated for their "IP"
Now whose system make more innovation US or China's?
I clearly see, the moment IP protection began verging on extreme, US began stagnate in science and technology, and Chine went ahead.
- xoa 7y ago>This is a complete delusion. Um, no. It's objective fact. Whether it's a video game or R&D on drugs or semiconductors, it does in fact require the expending of limited resources. Are you for real? This stuff doesn't pop into existence out of thin air. >This is what about Goebbels said, "the bigger the lie, the easier it is to believe in." Ah yes going the Nazi quote angle, always the sign of someone who is definitely not a crackpot. >1. Set up a machine that will "destroy" the IP value of something by copying it. >2. Make it do so a billion times, and watch if the company whose IP being "infringed" goes bankrupt. Did you, you know, actually READ anything I wrote, including the very first sentence that you yourself quoted? Because what you just described is information replication, which as I wrote in, again, that very sentence you quoted, is effectively free. It does not cover the step 0 of GENERATING that information to be copied in the first place. That's the problem part, which IP attempts to solve by hacking on synthetic limits on the unlimited part of the equation to handle allocation to the limited part. >What was the last "big thing" an American company ever came with? Basically the entire semiconductor and software industry? Most modern medicines? Much of modern genetic technology? Reusable rockets? Like, are you for real? >and it was more than 60 years ago, when no monstrous IP protection regime was in place. Uh, yeah when it comes to patents yes, IP is about the same as it was 60 years ago, beyond the Republicans continually trying to cut the budget of the PTO. That's part of the problem in fact. I keep wondering if you're being sarcastic or engaging in satire here yet you seem to be entirely serious, but it's utter nonsense stuff.
- baybal2 7y ago> Um, no. It's objective fact. Whether it's a video game or R&D on drugs or semiconductors, it does in fact require the expending of limited resources. Are you for real? This stuff doesn't pop into existence out of thin air. You can do a lot of normally valueless things for money, if somebody gives them to you for that, whether by legal compulsion or own volition. Not denying that. The question is whether giving money for that is a rational thing to do. >It does not cover the step 0 of GENERATING that information to be copied in the first place. I put that example exactly to demonstrate that it does not influence whether the person/business in question has his capacity "of GENERATING that information" diminished. No, that person or a business is 100% capable continuing doing so in the same capacity. The capacity "of GENERATING that information" gets diminished if it gets regulatory limited though IP monopoly (I copyrighted this mathematic formula/program, thus nobody else can use it in their mathematic formulas/computer programs) China for example has its own non-insignificant pharmaceutical industry making original drugs, low profile semiconductor industry which nevertheless makes own developments, and gigantic videogame companies all with close to none IP enforcement.