5 ms·
Since the technology moves on so fast, shortening the patent expiration to eg. 1year would solve most of the problems. Companies get 1 year head start (which i
by ajsnigrutin 7y ago
Since the technology moves on so fast, shortening the patent expiration to eg. 1year would solve most of the problems.
Companies get 1 year head start (which is a lot), and after 1 year, we all benefit.
- mstolpm 7y agoWouldn't the slowness of the courts and the lengths of processing lead to virtually no protection at all? If going through the courts takes sometimes 3+ years but parents expire after 1 year, every final court ruling would be retroactive.
- rapsey 7y agoSo if you prevail you get payed retroactively for the damages. Whats wrong with that?
- josaka 7y agoYou can get six years back damages, and often you have a substantial portion of a patent's 20-year term in front of you. And frequently cases settle well before you are three years into a suit.
- new299 7y agoIf you're suggesting a 1 year patent period for all utility patents, you might as well just get rid of patents. In the industry I work in (Biotech - DNA sequencing) it takes maybe 5 years to mature an approach and get it to market. Once your patent is published, there isn't much to stop others developing the same method [1] (they just would run into trouble if they sold it commercially). So at the same time that the patent owner is developing their platform, a competitor can be developing theirs and launch at the same time or nearly the same time as you. Certain areas, like software patents, I'd possibly agree. I don't think software/algorithm patents are a good idea for a number of reasons however... [1] General consensus seems to be patents don't cover academic work. I've also heard that they don't cover commercial research, and that in any case it's hard to provide damages. http://softlib.rice.edu/ques.html#2 http://softlib.rice.edu/ques.html#2
- rapsey 7y ago> If you're suggesting a 1 year patent period for all utility patents, you might as well just get rid of patents. In the industry I work in (Biotech - DNA sequencing) it takes maybe 5 years to mature an approach and get it to market. So have a two phase validity. Once it's in the market you have a year.
- dkersten 7y agoYou’d want some limitations on the first phase too, so that companies don’t hold onto their patents indefinitely while waiting for the perfect market conditions for their one-year monopoly.
- mcny 7y agoA real solution is don't apply for patent protection. The down side is if someone else also figured it out, you don't get anything. Makes sense to me.
- dkersten 7y agoYes, I agree. I'm not a fan of patents. While I understand the desire to protect ones investment, it doesn't make sense to me that it should be done at the expense of someone else's investment, since multiple people coming up with similar ideas around the same time isn't particularly uncommon and unfortunately there's no easy way to differentiate those from plagiarism.
- new299 7y agoThis encourages companies to withhold products from the market. In many, cases they will withhold products for the maximal allowable period before releasing them into the market. This will give them the maximum period of patent coverage, and prevent other players from releasing products. Market leaders in particular will want to extend their coverage using this technique. Aside from this, what is "on the market" most novel scientific equipment undergoes early access. This period often lasts up to a year, usually equipment is sold at a loss or near cost. The product is validated. So... they recover none of their R&D during the patent period (making the patent largely useless). So... perhaps you structure things such that you give this patent covered product away for free during early access. But you use the product to recognize revenue elsewhere (consumables, reagents... whatever)... Thereby extending your coverage period. So... how will all this be policed/structured so companies can't find ways round it? If you can find a way of enforcing it, it still doesn't work out for the companies. In my experience a scientific startup needs at least 5 years in R&D.. an then at least 5 years on the market to cover those R&D expenses. If this is going to get funded by a VC it then needs a high enough return to cover all the VCs investments. This is then looking like a minimum of 10 years of patent coverage, and something like 20 years to make it worthwhile for VCs. Yea, you can get rid of patents all together. Probably the investment/funding sources will need to change and that might not be a bad thing. But I can't see that what you're suggesting is workable.
- beefield 7y agoI would think that setting a fast increasing tax (say doubling each year) on patents would solve lots of issues. Once you do not want to pay the tax, the patent moves to public domain. Same tax should apply also to copyrighted work.
- velox_io 7y agoShortening patents (when it can take years to gain traction) or making them more expensive only plays into the hands of large companies
- mensetmanusman 7y agoAs someone who researches at a western company, this would actually get rid of a lot of research, because business moves so slow to commercialize due to the highly regulated environment. Regulation and legal arbitrage, where companies (particularly in Asia) can take what is newly invented on a silver platter and sell to the global market due to lack of environmental protections etc. would be all that is left.
- mcny 7y ago» As someone who researches at a western company, this would actually get rid of a lot of research, because business moves so slow to commercialize due to the highly regulated environment. I don't know about you but I'm perfectly ok with that.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoI like technological progress, but I would also be okay digging ditches in case our economy crashed towards a commodities-only enterprise, so I’m strange in that regards :)
- phkahler 7y agoSome people think patents are required for innovation. They are mistaken. It is human nature to innovate.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoI agree, but it is not human nature to take their innovation to the world. Post WW2 the US govt had tens of thousands of technology patents but no one to bring it to the world. Patents are risk mitigation tools for funding entities to actually support commercialization. Innovation will happen always, but most of it stays on a dusty shelf a la an academic library. It’s not necessary that anything interesting and innovative (and sufficiently complex) gets sold.
- 7y ago