5 ms·
For a moment there I thought this post was written by Bryan Cantrill. About the camps and their goals, the open source one is to some extent present, obviously
by 59nadir 7y ago
For a moment there I thought this post was written by Bryan Cantrill.
About the camps and their goals, the open source one is to some extent present, obviously, but the ad one I don't really see because I run Pro. There is a third camp that unquestionably won, though:
The "UX/UI designer" camp. I assume all the garbage running in the background behind obscure registry toggles (because real configurability is bad for UX) that's meant to make it easier for grandmas and end up making it worse for everyone else, like your computer isn't really fully yours (neither the resources of it or the freedom to decide to not run these daemons) comes from misguided UX designers who think they know better than you how a computer should be used and that they can earmark a fifth of your CPU at any time to do whatever they want.
The UI designers also won. Everything is a soulless black or white with one contrasting color. They managed to make this "There are two places you can modify settings with two disparate styles" because somehow that's better than one older looking but consistent place.
- AstralStorm 7y agoEven they lost. You cannot customize the colors in light mode even. Only dark mode allows it, and there of course the color is darkened. The whole thing feels like a beta version. In fact, even Whistler betas were more polished than this. OS cannot afford to break things, which apparently is MS modus operandi now. It takes about 5 minutes of playing in settings to hit broken functionality. Bonus points if the breakage is forced by unchangeable domain policy in company.
- rzzzt 7y agoI like the help buttons which open a web browser with a page saying help is not available.
- CathedralBorrow 7y agoIf you want to blame this on some UX/UI designer boogeyman that's fine, but you're heavily misrepresenting UX principles here.
- benjaminvalmont 7y agoUX designers are the problem of the Windows OS. Hilarious!