3 ms·
The problem is that everything is relative. Did slaves have it badly? Well they were fed, had shelter, and life expectancy too. Probably better than being a
by kenjackson 16y ago
The problem is that everything is relative. Did slaves have it badly? Well they were fed, had shelter, and life expectancy too. Probably better than being a gladiator, for example.
People who grow up in Watts don't sit around saying, "At least this ain't Rwanda!" They just see folks who have nice cars drive down the street, or have nice clothes, or eat in restaurants with waiters, etc...
The argument that life is worse somewhere else is a loser argument to me. Oddly, the same people who push this argument will then collapse with convulsions if you tell them that you're going to raise income tax rates from 36% to 39%.
- Symmetry 16y agoBut if the only bad thing about being poor is comparing yourself to people who are better off then thats not a problem that we'd ever be able to solve. If we're actually increasing poor people's life expectancies with welfare (and we do!) then we have a good excuse for using government money to help poor people. If all we were doing was acting on people's envy then welfare wouldn't be justified. But if we're spending money not to cushion people's feelings but to materially improve their lives, and if we consider the life of someone in Rwanda to have the same value as someone in the US, then the relative plights of the people in Rwanda _do_ figure in to it.
- kenjackson 16y agoThe only thing we know, outside of activities like math, are relative measures. That's it. There's no "good" life or "bad" life. There's just better and worse, period. Materially improving lives, but not making them feel any better about their lives is an utter waste of money. It's the same reason why virtually no one will give away all of their money this afternoon, knowing that even with $0 to their name their life is better than the average Europeans during the Dark Ages. There is no absolute material scale at which point one is happy. There's substantial research in happiness that shows that happiness is a completely relative measure. But if the only bad thing about being poor is comparing yourself to people who are better off Not only is that the only bad thing, but it is the ONLY way to determine if you're actually poor!
- Symmetry 16y agoIf it were true that the only measure of welfare were relative then, since I care about myself somewhat more than other people, it would behoove me to not only eliminate welfare but make the lives of the poor as hard as possible so I could raise my relative status. Luckily, the scientific studies I've seen show that there are many things (health, marriage, security, etc) that are more important to people's happiness than relative status or wealth.
- kenjackson 16y agoIf it were true that the only measure of welfare were relative then, since I care about myself somewhat more than other people, it would behoove me to not only eliminate welfare but make the lives of the poor as hard as possible so I could raise my relative status. Indeed! And so it is for MANY people. In fact this is the Republican platform in the South with respect to poor blacks. This is why "small government" is so popular there. Not because they actually want a small government per se, but they view government as a force that actively attempts to reduce various economic gaps. Luckily, the scientific studies I've seen show that there are many things (health, marriage, security, etc) that are more important to people's happiness than relative status or wealth. Everything you've noted is relative. Are you happy that you'll die, most likely, before your 100th birthday? Is the fact that now a deep cut likely won't kill, but cancer likely can supposed to make me happy? How secure are you given the crime rate in your area? Given the divorce rate of something like 50% in the US, are we happy or sad, or 50/50 each way? In fact there's some great happiness research on the happiness of people after suffering great injuries, like paralysis or losing limbs. After a couple of years, they're not any less happy than people who haven't had such injuries. This is an example of self-relative happiness (versus the societal relative happiness we've been talking about), but demonstrates how happiness has no absolute metric one can use to measure it.